Prima facie – At first sight.
Meaning of Prima Facie
Prima Facie is a Latin term which literally means “at first sight” or “on its face”.
In legal context:
Prima facie case refers to a case where the evidence presented is sufficient to establish a fact or raise a presumption unless disproved.
It does not mean the accused is guilty or liable, but that there is enough evidence initially to proceed with the case.
Essentially, it is an initial assessment of the case before full trial or detailed examination.
Key Points
Prima facie means the evidence is sufficient to establish a claim if not rebutted.
It is used at the initial stage of investigation, trial, or civil proceedings.
Courts use this concept to decide whether a case should go to trial.
It does not determine the final outcome; it is only a preliminary evaluation.
Case Laws on Prima Facie
1. State of U.P. v. Rajesh Gautam, AIR 2003 SC 258
Facts: The Supreme Court dealt with preventive measures and examined the sufficiency of initial evidence in criminal cases.
Observation: The Court held that if there is prima facie evidence of an offence, the court can proceed with investigation or grant interim orders.
2. B.K. Educational Services v. Parag Gupta and Associates, AIR 2011 SC 2251
Facts: The case involved injunction in civil matters.
Observation: Prima facie case must exist to grant interim injunction. The Court emphasized that a prima facie case is one where the plaintiff has shown enough evidence at the outset to justify protection.
3. R v. Dudley and Stephens (1884) 14 QBD 273 (UK Law)
Facts: In this English criminal case, the court assessed the actions of the accused.
Observation: The concept of prima facie was used to determine whether the initial evidence was sufficient to charge the accused with murder.
4. Tata Engineering & Locomotive Co. Ltd. v. State of Maharashtra, AIR 1974 SC 785
Observation: Court held that for issuing interim orders or granting relief, there must exist a prima facie case, i.e., the claim should not be frivolous or vexatious at the outset.
Illustration
Suppose a person files a civil suit claiming that their land was encroached.
The court examines documents, photographs, and preliminary evidence.
If the evidence seems sufficient at first glance to proceed with the case, it is considered a prima facie case.
The defendant still has the right to disprove the claim, and the final decision is made after full trial.
External Law References
Indian Evidence Act, 1872
Section 3 defines “evidence” as all statements which may be used to prove or disprove a fact.
Prima facie evidence relies on the concept that sufficient evidence is present at first sight to establish a fact.
Civil Procedure Code, 1908
Courts often require a prima facie case to grant interim injunctions (Order XXXIX, Rule 1 & 2).
English Law
The term prima facie is widely used in criminal law to decide whether sufficient evidence exists to frame charges.
Reference: R v. Governor of Brockhill Prison Ex parte Evans (2001) UKHL 41.
Distinguishing Prima Facie
| Feature | Prima Facie | Beyond Reasonable Doubt |
|---|---|---|
| Stage | Initial assessment | Final stage in criminal trial |
| Meaning | Sufficient evidence at first glance | Evidence sufficient to convict |
| Burden | Initial | Full proof required |
| Example | Filing a civil suit | Criminal conviction in court |
✅ Conclusion:
Prima facie means “at first sight” or “on its face.” In law, it indicates sufficient initial evidence to proceed with a case or legal action. It is preliminary, not final, and serves as the first threshold in judicial decision-making.
RELATED Blog
0 comments