Insolvency Law at Venezuela
In Venezuela, insolvency law is governed by a combination of civil law principles, national commercial codes, and more recent reforms. The system is rooted in continental European legal traditions, particularly the Napoleonic Code, which Venezuela adopted and adapted into its own Commercial Code (Código de Comercio).
Key Legal Framework for Insolvency in Venezuela:
Primary Legislation:
Commercial Code (Código de Comercio, 1955, as amended) – This is the main source of insolvency regulation in Venezuela. It outlines procedures for bankruptcy (quiebra) and preventive composition (concurso preventivo).
Civil Code and various special laws also apply, especially regarding creditor rights and contract enforcement.
Types of Insolvency Proceedings: Venezuela recognizes two main types of insolvency processes:
a) Bankruptcy (Quiebra):
Initiated when a person or company is permanently insolvent, unable to meet obligations as they fall due.
A court can declare bankruptcy at the request of the debtor or creditors.
Once declared, the debtor’s assets are managed by a court-appointed trustee (síndico), and a liquidation process begins to pay creditors.
The process is highly judicialized — it involves extensive court supervision.
Aimed at restructuring debt and avoiding bankruptcy.
Debtors propose a plan to restructure or settle debts with creditor approval.
Requires judicial authorization and creditor consent.
If successful, the business continues operating. If it fails, the debtor may fall into full bankruptcy.
Creditor Hierarchy: Venezuelan law sets a ranking of claims, generally as follows:
Secured creditors (those with mortgages, pledges, etc.)
Preferred creditors (e.g., labor claims, tax debts)
Unsecured creditors
Subordinated creditors
Court Involvement: Insolvency proceedings are handled by the civil and commercial courts. These courts:
Supervise the appointment of trustees.
Validate creditor claims.
Oversee the distribution of assets and the execution of debt restructuring plans.
Role of Trustees (Síndicos): Court-appointed professionals who:
Administer the debtor’s estate.
Evaluate and rank claims.
Liquidate assets and distribute proceeds.
Report to the court on the insolvency progress.
Limitations and Criticism:
The system is slow, bureaucratic, and lacks transparency.
Corruption and inefficiency in the judiciary often complicate proceedings.
Venezuelan law lacks a modern insolvency framework akin to Chapter 11 in the U.S. or pre-packaged restructuring seen in other jurisdictions.
Cross-border insolvency issues are especially complex, with no alignment to UNCITRAL Model Law.
Cross-Border Insolvency:
Venezuela is not a signatory to international treaties like the UNCITRAL Model Law on Cross-Border Insolvency.
This makes it difficult for foreign creditors to assert claims or participate in local insolvency proceedings.
Recent Developments:
Given the ongoing economic crisis, many companies are insolvent or in financial distress, but few formal bankruptcy proceedings are filed due to:
Lack of creditor confidence in courts.
Political and economic instability.
Currency volatility and inflation.
There have been calls for reform to modernize and depoliticize insolvency proceedings, but significant change is still pending.
Summary:
Venezuela's insolvency law is formalized under its Commercial Code, distinguishing between bankruptcy and preventive composition, but the system is outdated and deeply affected by institutional challenges. Although there is a legal framework, in practice, businesses often avoid formal proceedings due to a lack of trust in judicial processes and broader economic instability.
RELATED Blog
0 comments