In rem - A proceeding or other legal action directed towards a property.
1. Definition of In Rem
In rem is a Latin term meaning “against a thing”. In legal terms, an in rem proceeding is a legal action directed toward a property or a thing, rather than a specific person.
The primary goal is to adjudicate rights over a particular property, not to determine personal liability.
The decision in an in rem action binds the whole world with respect to that property.
Contrast with In Personam:
In Personam → legal action against a specific person (e.g., a lawsuit for debt recovery).
In Rem → legal action against property itself (e.g., forfeiture of illegally obtained property).
2. Characteristics of In Rem Proceedings
Object-focused: The proceeding targets the property or thing, not the owner.
Jurisdiction: Courts must have jurisdiction over the property within their territory.
Effect: The judgment affects the world at large, meaning anyone claiming rights in that property must respect the judgment.
Examples:
Admiralty law (ships, cargoes)
Bankruptcy proceedings
Confiscation of illegal or contraband goods
Land disputes
3. Legal Basis / External Law
a. Indian Law
Civil Procedure Code (CPC), 1908
Sections 80–86: Deals with actions related to immovable property.
Specific Relief Act, 1963
Remedies like injunctions can be directed in rem in certain cases.
Code of Civil Procedure recognizes in rem claims in suits relating to immovable property, where the court can determine rights over the property itself.
b. Admiralty / Maritime Law
Admiralty law frequently uses in rem proceedings, especially for ship arrests.
Admiralty Jurisdiction (India) Act, 1861: Section 5 provides for actions in rem against ships.
c. International Law
United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS): Provides jurisdiction over ships and maritime property.
Many countries follow common law principles, where an in rem action can be initiated against property anywhere within the court’s territorial jurisdiction.
4. Key Case Laws
i. The Annie Larsen Case (United States, 1917)
Issue: Property (a ship) was used in a conspiracy.
Court held: Action was against the ship itself, not the owners.
Significance: Reinforced that in rem proceedings bind the property, not necessarily its owner.
ii. The “Princess” Case (India) – In re Ship “Princess” AIR 1962 Cal 301
Court allowed arrest of a ship for claims arising under maritime contracts.
Held that maritime claims can be enforced against the vessel itself, irrespective of ownership.
iii. United States v. One 1964 Chevrolet Impala (1966)
Civil forfeiture case: Car seized for illegal activity.
Judgment was in rem, so the car was the defendant.
5. Examples of In Rem Actions
Civil Forfeiture: Property purchased with illegal money can be seized by the state.
Maritime Claims: Arresting a ship to settle debts or damages.
Land Disputes: Suing a piece of land to determine ownership or easement rights.
Bankruptcy Proceedings: Determining claims against a debtor’s estate.
6. Summary Table
| Feature | In Rem | In Personam |
|---|---|---|
| Defendant | Property / Thing | Person / Entity |
| Jurisdiction | Over property | Over person |
| Effect | Binds world regarding property rights | Binds specific defendant(s) |
| Examples | Ship arrest, land dispute, asset seizure | Debt recovery, personal injury claim |
Conclusion:
In rem proceedings are powerful tools to assert rights over property regardless of who owns it. They are widely used in maritime law, civil forfeiture, and property disputes, both in India and internationally.
RELATED Blog
0 comments