Industrial Dispute and Individual Dispute
Industrial Dispute vs. Individual Dispute
Both terms relate to conflicts arising in the workplace but differ fundamentally in scope, parties involved, and nature.
1. Industrial Dispute
Definition:
An industrial dispute is a conflict or difference between employers and employees (or among employees themselves) that relates to employment, non-employment, terms of employment, or conditions of labor. It typically involves collective issues affecting a group or class of workers.
Key Characteristics:
Involves groups of employees or the workforce as a whole.
Concerns matters such as wages, working conditions, hours of work, layoffs, or terms of employment.
Usually arises in an organized form — often through unions or employee associations.
Can lead to strikes, lockouts, or collective bargaining.
Nature of Disputes Included:
Disputes over wage rates.
Issues of working hours.
Demands for better working conditions.
Disagreements over terms of employment like promotions or layoffs.
Recognition of unions.
Case Law Example:
🔹 Bangalore Water Supply and Sewerage Board v. A. Rajappa (1978)
Facts: The dispute was about the employment conditions of a large group of workers.
Held: The court clarified that a dispute is industrial if it relates to a collective issue between employers and employees regarding employment terms.
Significance: This case emphasized the collective nature of industrial disputes, distinguishing them from individual grievances.
2. Individual Dispute
Definition:
An individual dispute arises between a single employee and employer concerning individual rights and obligations. It relates to the rights of a single employee regarding their employment terms.
Key Characteristics:
Involves only one employee (or a small number) and the employer.
Relates to personal issues such as promotion, termination, salary increments, or disciplinary action.
Does not affect the workforce as a whole.
Usually handled through internal grievance procedures or civil remedies.
Examples of Individual Disputes:
A wrongful dismissal or termination claim.
Dispute over an employee’s promotion or salary.
Personal harassment claims.
Disagreement on individual contract terms.
Case Law Example:
🔹 Workmen v. Management of Steel Authority of India Ltd. (1993)
Facts: The case involved a dispute about the dismissal of a single employee.
Held: The court held that such disputes are individual and not industrial disputes because they relate to a personal grievance.
Significance: Helped clarify the distinction between individual and industrial disputes.
Differences Between Industrial and Individual Disputes
| Aspect | Industrial Dispute | Individual Dispute |
|---|---|---|
| Parties Involved | Group of employees and employer or union | Single employee and employer |
| Nature of Dispute | Collective issues related to employment terms | Personal issues related to an individual |
| Subject Matter | Wages, working conditions, layoffs, union issues | Promotion, dismissal, salary, discipline |
| Result | May lead to strikes, lockouts, collective action | Grievance resolution or court proceedings |
| Resolution Mechanism | Labour courts, industrial tribunals | Grievance cells, civil courts |
Summary
Industrial disputes concern collective matters involving a body of employees and usually have a wider impact on industrial relations.
Individual disputes concern personal grievances between an individual employee and employer, often related to specific contractual or employment issues.
Understanding this distinction is crucial for correctly addressing the conflict through appropriate forums and remedies.
RELATED Blog
0 comments