Remedies under Contracts
Remedies Under Contracts
When one party breaches a contract, the other party is entitled to remedies — legal means to enforce a right or compensate for a loss. The main goal of contract remedies is to put the injured party in the position they would have been if the contract had been properly performed.
1. Types of Remedies
There are generally two broad categories of remedies in contract law:
A. Legal Remedies (Damages)
B. Equitable Remedies
A. Legal Remedies (Damages)
Damages are a monetary compensation awarded to the injured party for loss caused by the breach.
i. Compensatory Damages
Purpose: To compensate for actual loss suffered due to breach.
Nature: Puts the injured party in the position as if the contract was performed.
Example: If a seller fails to deliver goods, damages would cover the cost difference to buy similar goods elsewhere.
Case Law:
Hadley v. Baxendale (1854)
Facts: Delay in delivering a broken mill shaft caused the mill to stop working, resulting in lost profits.
Held: Damages are recoverable only for losses that arise naturally or were foreseeable by both parties at the time of contract.
Significance: Established the rule for foreseeability of damages.
ii. Consequential (Special) Damages
Purpose: Compensation for losses indirectly caused by breach but reasonably foreseeable.
Requirement: Must be specifically communicated or known at contract formation.
Example: Loss of profit due to delay in delivery.
Case Law:
Again, Hadley v. Baxendale is the landmark case where consequential damages were defined based on foreseeability.
iii. Nominal Damages
Awarded when breach occurred but no actual loss or damage proven.
Symbolic recognition of rights.
iv. Punitive Damages
Designed to punish the breaching party.
Rarely awarded in contract cases unless tortious conduct is involved.
v. Liquidated Damages
Pre-agreed sum specified in the contract for breach.
Enforced if reasonable and not a penalty.
Case Law:
Dunlop Pneumatic Tyre Co Ltd v. New Garage & Motor Co Ltd (1915)
Facts: Contract included a liquidated damages clause.
Held: Courts enforce liquidated damages if they represent a genuine pre-estimate of loss, not a penalty.
Significance: Set principles distinguishing liquidated damages from penalties.
B. Equitable Remedies
Used when damages are inadequate or inappropriate. These remedies are discretionary and depend on the fairness of the case.
i. Specific Performance
Court orders the breaching party to perform contractual obligations.
Typically used in contracts involving unique goods or property (e.g., land sale).
Not granted if damages are sufficient.
Case Law:
Lumley v. Wagner (1852)
Facts: A singer contracted to perform exclusively for the plaintiff but agreed to sing elsewhere.
Held: Court ordered specific performance to restrain breach.
Significance: Established specific performance as an equitable remedy for contracts involving unique personal services.
ii. Injunction
Court order restraining a party from doing something that breaches the contract.
Can be temporary or permanent.
iii. Rescission
Cancels the contract and returns parties to original positions.
Available in cases of misrepresentation, fraud, or breach.
iv. Reformation
Court modifies contract terms to reflect parties’ true intentions.
Used when there is a mistake or fraud.
3. Mitigation of Loss
The injured party has a duty to mitigate (reduce) their losses.
Failure to do so can reduce damages awarded.
Case Law:
British Westinghouse Electric Co Ltd v. Underground Electric Railways Co of London Ltd (1912)
Held: The injured party must take reasonable steps to mitigate damages.
4. Summary
| Remedy | Description | Purpose | Example Case |
|---|---|---|---|
| Compensatory Damages | Monetary compensation for direct loss | To put injured party in pre-breach position | Hadley v. Baxendale |
| Consequential Damages | Compensation for indirect loss | To cover foreseeable consequential loss | Hadley v. Baxendale |
| Nominal Damages | Symbolic damages when no real loss | To recognize breach | - |
| Punitive Damages | Punishment damages | Punish wrongdoer (rare in contract) | - |
| Liquidated Damages | Pre-agreed damages | To provide certainty in breach | Dunlop Pneumatic Tyre Co Ltd |
| Specific Performance | Court order to perform contractual duty | When damages inadequate, unique subject matter | Lumley v. Wagner |
| Injunction | Court order restraining breach | To prevent ongoing breach | - |
| Rescission | Contract cancellation | To undo contract in cases of fraud etc. | - |
5. Conclusion
Remedies in contract law aim to enforce contracts fairly and compensate parties when breaches occur. The choice of remedy depends on the nature of breach, adequacy of damages, and fairness. Courts balance these factors using well-established principles illustrated by case law.
RELATED Blog
0 comments