Civil Procedure Code at Taiwan
The Civil Procedure Code (CPC) of Taiwan governs civil litigation in Taiwan and sets forth the procedural rules for resolving civil disputes. Taiwan's legal system is based on civil law principles, and the Civil Procedure Code plays a critical role in ensuring that civil cases are handled in a structured and fair manner.
Here are the key features and aspects of the Civil Procedure Code of Taiwan:
1. General Principles
Civil Law System: Taiwan follows a civil law system, influenced by the German and Japanese legal traditions. The Civil Procedure Code is designed to be comprehensive, establishing clear procedural rules for civil cases.
Impartiality and Fairness: The CPC guarantees the right of both parties in a dispute to present their case. It is designed to ensure fair treatment, due process, and the equal application of the law.
2. Court System
Taiwan’s civil cases are handled by a tiered court system:
District Courts (First Instance): These are the courts of first instance for most civil matters. They have general jurisdiction over civil cases, including those related to contract disputes, property, torts, family law, and inheritance matters.
High Courts (Appeals): Appeals from district court decisions are taken to the High Courts. The High Court handles cases on appeal and can review both the facts of the case and the application of the law.
Supreme Court: The Supreme Court is the highest appellate court in Taiwan. It generally does not reexamine the facts of the case but instead focuses on legal issues and the uniform application of law.
Family Courts: Family disputes, such as divorce, child custody, and inheritance matters, are handled by specialized family courts.
Administrative Courts: Cases involving administrative law or disputes between citizens and governmental bodies are handled by specialized administrative courts.
3. Commencing a Lawsuit
Writ of Summons: A civil lawsuit in Taiwan begins with the filing of a Writ of Summons (訴狀), which is served to the defendant to notify them of the claim. The Writ of Summons outlines the plaintiff’s claims and the relief sought.
Complaint (Plaint): The plaintiff submits a complaint along with the writ, stating the facts, legal grounds, and specific requests for the court’s intervention.
Jurisdiction: The jurisdiction of a court in Taiwan is determined by factors such as the nature of the claim, the residence of the parties, or where the events in the dispute occurred. A party may file the lawsuit in the appropriate district court based on these factors.
4. Court Procedures
Service of Process: The plaintiff must ensure that the defendant is properly served with the writ and summons. The service is usually carried out by the court or a legal officer.
Defendant’s Response: The defendant is required to file a response (答辯狀) within a specific period, typically within 30 days of receiving the writ. This response can either accept the claim or provide defenses and counterclaims.
Pre-Trial Procedures: In some cases, there may be pre-trial conferences where the court may encourage the parties to settle the dispute or clarify the issues to streamline the proceedings.
5. Trial Procedures
Burden of Proof: The burden of proof generally rests with the plaintiff. The plaintiff must establish that their claims are more likely to be true than not. The defendant may provide evidence to refute the plaintiff’s claims or raise defenses.
Presentation of Evidence: During the trial, both parties are allowed to present evidence, such as documents, witness testimony, and expert reports. The court evaluates the credibility and relevance of the evidence presented.
Witness Testimony: Both parties have the right to call witnesses to testify. Cross-examination is allowed, and the court can question witnesses directly.
Judicial Investigations: The judge may also take an active role in gathering evidence, which includes questioning parties or witnesses and requesting expert opinions.
6. Judgment and Orders
Issuance of Judgment: Once the trial is concluded, the court will issue a judgment that includes the court's findings of fact and the legal reasoning behind its decision. The judgment may include:
Monetary damages: Compensation for harm or loss caused by the defendant.
Injunctive Relief: Orders to stop certain actions, such as an injunction to prevent unlawful behavior.
Declaratory Judgment: A statement of the rights and obligations of the parties involved in the case.
Interim Orders: Courts can issue interim measures during the proceedings, such as a temporary restraining order, asset freezing, or preservation of evidence.
Enforcement: If the judgment is in favor of the plaintiff and the defendant does not voluntarily comply, the plaintiff may request the enforcement of the judgment. This can involve the seizure of property or garnishment of wages.
7. Appeals Process
Appeals to High Court: If a party is dissatisfied with the judgment issued by a District Court, they can appeal to the High Court. The appeal process includes a review of the legal and factual aspects of the case.
Appeal to the Supreme Court: The Supreme Court is the highest appellate court, and appeals are only accepted on points of law rather than facts. The Supreme Court reviews whether the lower courts applied the law correctly.
Review by the Court of Last Resort: The Supreme Court provides final decisions on cases of importance or those involving legal clarification, ensuring uniformity in legal interpretation.
8. Special Procedures
Summary Judgment: In certain cases, where there is no genuine dispute of material facts, a summary judgment may be issued, allowing for the case to be resolved without a full trial.
Small Claims Procedures: Taiwan has simplified procedures for small claims (usually with a value below a certain threshold). These procedures allow for quicker and cheaper resolution of disputes without the need for formal trials.
Family Law Cases: Family matters, such as divorce, child custody, and inheritance, are typically handled by family courts, which apply special procedures tailored to the nature of these disputes.
9. Execution of Judgment
Enforcement of Court Orders: If a party fails to comply with a court's judgment, the prevailing party can apply for enforcement of the judgment. This may involve actions like seizing property, garnishing wages, or other measures to ensure the judgment is carried out.
Execution Officer: The execution officer (usually a court bailiff) is responsible for implementing the enforcement orders.
10. Legal Costs
Costs of Litigation: The losing party in a civil case is generally required to pay the legal costs of the prevailing party. This can include court fees, attorney’s fees, and other expenses.
Legal Aid: Taiwan has a legal aid system that provides assistance to individuals who cannot afford to hire legal representation. This is particularly helpful in cases involving family law, personal injury, and other matters where access to justice may be hindered by financial constraints.
Conclusion:
The Civil Procedure Code of Taiwan is a comprehensive legal framework that ensures the orderly and fair resolution of civil disputes. It provides detailed procedures for initiating lawsuits, presenting evidence, and enforcing judgments. The code is designed to ensure that individuals have access to justice, while also promoting fairness, transparency, and the rule of law.
RELATED Blog
0 comments