Interpleader Suit CPC
Interpleader Suit under CPC
1. What is an Interpleader Suit?
An Interpleader Suit is a special type of suit where a person (called the stakeholder) who holds property or money, but claims no right over it, asks the court to decide between two or more parties (called claimants) who claim rights over the same property or money. The stakeholder wants to avoid multiple litigation and wants to be discharged from liability.
In simple terms:
When a person holding some property or money is unsure who the rightful owner is because multiple parties claim it, the person files an interpleader suit asking the court to decide who should get the property or money.
2. Legal Basis of Interpleader Suit in CPC
The provisions for Interpleader Suit are governed by:
Order 35, Rules 1 to 3 of the CPC
Also, Section 151 CPC (inherent powers of the court) plays a role.
3. Key Features of Interpleader Suit
| Feature | Explanation |
|---|---|
| Stakeholder | The person holding the property or money but not claiming interest in it. |
| Multiple Claimants | Two or more parties claiming rights over the same property or money. |
| Purpose | To avoid multiple suits and protect the stakeholder from liability. |
| Relief Sought | The stakeholder asks the court to decide the rightful claimant and discharge the stakeholder from further liability. |
| Nature of Suit | It is a summary proceeding to prevent multiplicity of suits. |
4. When Can an Interpleader Suit Be Filed?
When a person holds money or property in which two or more persons have a claim.
The stakeholder is unsure about the correct claimant.
The stakeholder wants the court to decide the matter instead of risking liability by delivering the property to the wrong claimant.
The property or money should be in the possession or control of the stakeholder at the time of filing the suit.
5. Procedure under Order 35 CPC
The stakeholder files a suit with a concise statement of facts.
The court issues notice to the claimants.
The claimants contest and the court decides the rights over the property or money.
The stakeholder is discharged from liability once the court decides the rightful claimant.
6. Important Points
The stakeholder does not claim any right in the subject matter.
The stakeholder deposits the money or property with the court if required.
It is a safeguard to avoid being liable to multiple claimants.
Costs and expenses of the suit are usually borne by the claimants.
7. Case Laws on Interpleader Suit
a) Kusum Ingots & Alloys Ltd. v. Union of India (2004) 6 SCC 254
Held: The Supreme Court held that an interpleader suit is a summary and expeditious procedure to avoid multiple litigations.
The court emphasized that the stakeholder is not a real party to the controversy but only acts as a stakeholder.
The court clarified the scope and procedure of interpleader suits under Order 35 CPC.
b) State of Uttar Pradesh v. Renusagar Power Co. Ltd. (AIR 1988 SC 1737)
The court reiterated the principles of interpleader suits and stated that the suit is meant to free the stakeholder from multiple liabilities.
It was held that once the suit is filed, the stakeholder should not be drawn into the controversy about the ownership or title.
c) Nagappa v. Chikkanna (AIR 1957 SC 660)
The Supreme Court held that interpleader is a remedy to avoid multiplicity of proceedings and conflicting decisions.
It was further observed that the procedure should be simple and speedy to protect the stakeholder.
8. Illustrative Example
Suppose a bank holds a fixed deposit account, and two persons claim the money in the account as rightful heirs of the deceased depositor. The bank (stakeholder) doesn’t want to risk paying the money to the wrong claimant and getting sued by the other. So, the bank files an interpleader suit asking the court to decide who is entitled to the deposit. The bank deposits the money with the court and is discharged from liability.
9. Difference Between Interpleader Suit and Regular Suit
| Aspect | Interpleader Suit | Regular Suit |
|---|---|---|
| Purpose | To determine rightful claimant of disputed property or money. | To enforce a legal right or claim by a plaintiff. |
| Stakeholder's Role | Neutral; does not claim rights in property. | Plaintiff claims rights in property or money. |
| Procedure | Summary and expeditious under Order 35 CPC. | Ordinary procedure with full trial. |
| Multiple Claimants | Yes, at least two claimants contest ownership. | Usually between two parties, plaintiff and defendant. |
10. Conclusion
An Interpleader Suit is an effective legal remedy that allows a neutral stakeholder to avoid multiple litigations and liability by depositing the disputed property or money with the court and asking it to decide the rightful claimant. The provisions under Order 35 CPC ensure a quick and efficient process to resolve disputes involving multiple claimants.
RELATED Blog
0 comments