Civil Laws at Guinea-Bissau
Guinea-Bissau's civil law system is primarily based on the civil law tradition, heavily influenced by its colonial past, specifically Portuguese law. However, it also features a significant role for customary law, particularly in rural areas, leading to a dual legal system.
Here's a breakdown of the civil laws in Guinea-Bissau:
1. Primary Sources of Civil Law:
Portuguese Civil Code and Civil Procedure Codes: After gaining independence, Guinea-Bissau largely retained the Portuguese Civil Code and Civil Procedure Code that were in force during the colonial period. These codes form the bedrock of its statutory civil law, covering areas such as:
Contract Law: Rules governing agreements, their formation, validity, performance, and remedies for breach.
Tort Law: Principles of civil wrongs and liability for harm caused (e.g., negligence).
Property Law: Principles of ownership, possession, and other rights related to real and personal property.
Family Law: (Though heavily influenced by customary law, the Civil Code provides a framework for statutory marriage, divorce, adoption, and inheritance.)
Succession Law: Rules for inheriting property.
The Constitution of Guinea-Bissau (1984, with amendments): This is the supreme law of the land. It enshrines fundamental rights and freedoms, including principles of equality before the law, and influences the interpretation and application of all other laws. It also acknowledges the role of customary law.
National Legislation (Laws passed by the National People's Assembly): Over time, Guinea-Bissau's Parliament has enacted its own laws to modify, supplement, or replace aspects of the inherited Portuguese law, adapting it to the specific needs and context of the country.
Customary Law: This is a vital and often dominant source of law, particularly in rural areas and for matters related to personal status for a significant portion of the population.
Application: Customary law governs many aspects of daily life, especially:
Marriage and Divorce: Many marriages are contracted under customary law, and traditional mechanisms are often used for dispute resolution in these matters. Child marriage, despite legal prohibitions, remains prevalent due to customary practices.
Inheritance: Customary norms dictate how property is inherited, particularly outside of formal wills or statutory procedures.
Land Tenure: Traditional land holding systems are largely governed by customary practices.
Community Disputes: Many minor civil disputes are resolved through traditional authorities and local mediation.
Challenges with Customary Law: A key challenge is the potential for customary law to conflict with constitutional human rights, particularly concerning women's rights (e.g., in inheritance or marriage) and children's rights (e.g., female genital mutilation, child marriage). There's a recognized gap between formal legal protections and the practical application of customary law.
2. Key Areas of Civil Law:
Family Law: This is an area of significant overlap and tension between statutory and customary law. The Civil Code provides for formal marriage and divorce, but customary marriages and traditional dispute resolution mechanisms are very common. Issues of child custody, maintenance, and inheritance are often settled through customary means, although formal legal avenues exist. Laws exist to prohibit practices like female genital mutilation (FGM) and child marriage, but their enforcement is challenging.
Property Law: While the Portuguese Civil Code establishes general principles of property ownership, land tenure is a complex area where state ownership, private ownership, and customary land use rights intersect. The government has been working on developing a comprehensive strategy for land rights, given the historical context of state ownership of land after independence.
Contract Law: Governed by the Civil Code, applying to commercial transactions and agreements.
Tort Law: Principles of civil liability for causing harm to others.
Employment Law: Governs labor relations, wages, working conditions, and rights of employees and employers.
Commercial Law: Covers business transactions, company formation, and commercial contracts.
Insolvency Law: Deals with bankruptcy and related procedures.
3. The Civil Justice System:
Guinea-Bissau's judicial system is designed to handle civil cases, but it faces significant challenges, including political interference, corruption, lack of resources, and limited reach into rural areas.
Supreme Court of Justice (Supremo Tribunal de Justiça): The highest court in the land, serving as the final court of appeal for civil (and criminal) matters.
Regional Tribunals of First Instance: These courts handle a broad range of civil cases at the regional level.
Tribunais de Pequenas Causas (Courts of Small Causes/Sector Tribunals): These are the lowest level of formal courts, handling minor civil matters at the local level.
Customary Justice Mechanisms: In many rural areas, traditional authorities and community elders play a vital role in mediating and resolving civil disputes, often due to the limited presence and accessibility of the formal court system. While these provide a form of "access to justice," they may not always align with national and international human rights standards.
Specialized Courts: There may be specialized courts or tribunals for specific matters, such as administrative courts, although the general courts often handle contentious administrative matters.
Challenges to the Civil Justice System:
Access to Justice: The formal justice system is largely concentrated in the capital and a few major cities, making it difficult for people in rural areas to access courts. This perpetuates reliance on traditional justice mechanisms.
Weak Institutions and Corruption: The judiciary has historically been subject to political manipulation, and issues of corruption, inadequate pay for judges and legal professionals, and lack of resources contribute to dysfunctions.
Enforcement of Laws: Even when laws are in place, their effective enforcement, particularly in areas like human rights (e.g., FGM, child marriage), can be weak due to societal norms, limited institutional capacity, and cultural resistance.
Legal Aid: Access to legal representation, especially for indigent clients, is a significant challenge. Initiatives by organizations like UNDP aim to improve legal aid through "Centers for Access to Justice" (CAJs) that bridge formal and informal justice systems.
In essence, Guinea-Bissau's civil law reflects its historical ties to Portugal while grappling with the deeply embedded customary practices of its diverse communities. The country is in a continuous process of strengthening its formal legal institutions and ensuring that its laws effectively protect the rights of all citizens, particularly the vulnerable.
RELATED Blog
0 comments