Civil Laws at Ecuador
Ecuador operates under a civil law system, where codified laws are the primary source of legal norms. Its legal framework is significantly influenced by the Chilean Civil Code, which was adopted by Ecuador in 1858, and further incorporates elements from the Napoleonic Code and Roman law. The 2008 Constitution of Ecuador has also played a crucial role in shaping the legal landscape, emphasizing fundamental rights and social justice.
Here's a detailed look at civil laws in Ecuador:
1. Sources of Civil Law:
The Constitution of the Republic of Ecuador (2008): This is the supreme law, overriding any other legal norm. It establishes fundamental rights, principles of justice, and the framework for the entire legal system.
International Treaties and Conventions: Treaties ratified by Ecuador form part of its domestic law. Notably, human rights treaties that offer more favorable conditions than national law prevail over internal norms.
Organic and Ordinary Laws: These are enacted by the National Assembly.
Organic laws regulate the organization of the state, fundamental rights, and territorial structures.
Ordinary laws cover general matters. Organic laws hold a higher hierarchy than ordinary laws.
Regulations and Executive Decrees: Issued by the President, these are necessary for the application of laws, as long as they do not contradict or alter the laws.
Municipal and Provincial Ordinances: Local governments have the authority to issue these ordinances to govern local affairs within their competencies and jurisdictions.
Judicial Precedent (Jurisprudence): While a civil law system, the decisions of the Constitutional Court are binding. Additionally, a triple repetition of a cassation ruling by the National Court of Justice (the highest court) establishes a binding precedent for the interpretation and application of laws, except for the National Court itself.
Customary Law (Indigenous Justice Systems): Ecuador explicitly recognizes indigenous justice systems based on their ancestral traditions and their own laws, within their territorial scope. These systems operate as long as they do not contradict constitutional norms and human rights.
General Principles of Law: These are fundamental legal principles that can be applied by judges when no exact law is applicable to a disputed case.
Legal Doctrine: Scholarly writings and legal interpretations, while not a formal source, influence judicial and legislative decisions.
Equity: Judges may apply principles of equity when legal norms do not provide a clear solution, provided their decisions align with justice and reason. The Civil Code explicitly recognizes equity as an applicable legal principle.
2. Key Statutes Governing Civil Matters:
The Ecuadorian Civil Code: This is the foundational private law, regulating relations between individuals. It covers:
Law of Persons: Rights, duties, and legal status of individuals.
Family Law: Matters related to marriage, divorce, parental authority, and adoption (though many aspects are also in specific family codes).
Law of Obligations: Principles governing contracts, quasi-contracts, and torts (delictual liability). This includes requirements for contract validity, performance, breach, and remedies.
Property Law (Law of Things): Rules regarding ownership, possession, usufruct, servitudes, and other real rights over movable and immovable property.
Succession and Inheritance: Rules governing the distribution of property upon death, whether by will or intestate succession.
Organic General Code of Process (Código Orgánico General de Procesos - COGEP): Enacted to modernize civil, commercial, labor, and administrative litigation, this code introduced oral procedures and streamlined processes. It covers:
Jurisdiction of courts.
Filing of claims and defenses.
Procedural stages, including preliminary and evidentiary hearings.
Rules of evidence.
Execution of judgments.
Appeals.
Family Code: While the Civil Code covers some aspects, specific laws within the broader family law framework regulate marriage, divorce, alimony, child custody, and other domestic relations in detail.
Labor Code: Governs employment relationships, workers' rights, and employer obligations. Labor disputes are typically handled by specialized labor courts.
Commercial Code: Regulates commercial activities, contracts, and companies.
Arbitration and Mediation Law: This law provides the framework for alternative dispute resolution mechanisms, particularly arbitration and mediation, which are actively promoted in Ecuador.
3. Civil Litigation Process (General Overview):
The litigation process in Ecuador has been significantly reformed with the introduction of the COGEP, emphasizing oral proceedings. Key stages include:
Filing of the Claim (Demanda): The plaintiff files a written claim outlining the facts, legal basis, and desired relief.
Admission and Summons: The court reviews the claim for admissibility and, if accepted, orders the summons (notification) of the defendant.
Answer to the Claim (Contestación a la Demanda): The defendant files a written response, admitting or denying allegations and raising defenses or counterclaims.
Preliminary Hearing (Audiencia Preliminar): This crucial oral hearing involves:
Attempt at conciliation/settlement.
Purification of the process (resolving procedural issues).
Formulation of the dispute's points.
Announcement of evidence.
Scheduling of the evidentiary hearing.
Evidentiary Hearing (Audiencia de Prueba): This is where evidence is presented and debated orally, including witness testimony and expert reports.
Judgment (Sentencia): The judge delivers an oral judgment, which is later formalized in writing.
Appeals: Parties can appeal judgments to higher courts.
Execution of Judgment: If a judgment is not voluntarily complied with, the winning party can seek enforcement through court orders.
4. Court Structure for Civil Matters:
Ecuador's judicial system is hierarchical:
Courts of First Instance (Juzgados de Primera Instancia): These are the entry-level courts, handling various civil, commercial, and labor cases, often categorized by subject matter or monetary value.
Provincial Courts of Justice (Cortes Provinciales de Justicia): These courts hear appeals from the Courts of First Instance within their respective provinces. They review both factual findings and legal application.
National Court of Justice (Corte Nacional de Justicia): This is the highest ordinary court in Ecuador, located in Quito, with jurisdiction throughout the country. It functions as a Court of Cassation, primarily reviewing points of law and ensuring uniform application of law across the country through specialized chambers.
Constitutional Court (Corte Constitucional): This is an independent body that is the highest interpreter of the Constitution. Its rulings are binding and can affect the interpretation and application of civil laws, especially concerning fundamental rights.
Indigenous Justice System: Recognized by the Constitution, these systems operate in indigenous communities, applying customary law for disputes within their territorial scope.
5. Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR):
Ecuador strongly promotes ADR, particularly mediation and arbitration, as efficient ways to resolve civil disputes.
Mediation: Widely used and often mandatory before litigation for certain types of disputes. Mediation centers are established by Chambers of Commerce and other institutions. A mediation agreement that is certified by a recognized mediator has the same legal force as a court judgment.
Arbitration: Regulated by the Arbitration and Mediation Law, arbitration is a popular method for resolving commercial and other civil disputes, including those involving the State. Arbitral awards are legally binding and enforceable.
For any specific legal matter in Ecuador, it is crucial to consult with a local Ecuadorian lawyer who can provide tailored advice based on the intricacies of the law and recent developments.
RELATED Blog
0 comments