Civil Laws at Puerto Rico (US)
Puerto Rico has a unique and complex legal system that blends elements of both civil law and common law. This is primarily due to its history as a Spanish colony and its current status as a U.S. territory.
Here's a breakdown of civil laws in Puerto Rico:
1. Civil Law Tradition as the Foundation:
Spanish Influence: Puerto Rico's civil law system is largely derived from the Spanish Civil Code of 1888, which was extended to the island in 1889. This forms the historical foundation for many private law matters.
Civil Code of Puerto Rico (2020): While influenced by the Spanish Civil Code, Puerto Rico has its own Civil Code, with a significant revision enacted in 2020. This Code serves as the primary source of law for many areas of private practice.
Key Areas of Civil Law: Civil law principles are typically applied in areas such as:
Family Law: Divorce, child custody, marital property, etc.
Real Property Law: Ownership, transfer, and rights related to land and buildings.
Contractual Law: Agreements, obligations, and their enforcement.
Succession/Estate Law: Inheritance and wills.
Obligations: Concepts of debt, sale, etc.
Codification: A hallmark of civil law systems is the reliance on comprehensive legal codes that provide general principles and rules, rather than relying heavily on judicial precedent (as in common law).
2. Interaction with U.S. Common Law and Federal Law:
Mixed Legal System: Due to over a century under U.S. sovereignty, Puerto Rico has incorporated aspects of the common law system. This creates a "hybrid" or "mixed" legal system where both civil law and common law principles are present.
Common Law Influence: Common law has influenced local legislation, judicial opinions, and legal commentary, particularly in areas like:
Constitutional Law
Bankruptcy Law
Federal Criminal Procedures
U.S. Federal Law Applies: As a U.S. territory, most, but not all, U.S. federal laws apply to Puerto Rico. This includes the U.S. Constitution (the supreme law of the U.S.), federal statutes (codified in the U.S. Code), and decisions by federal courts.
Coexisting Court Systems: Puerto Rico has its own Commonwealth judiciary (including the Puerto Rico Supreme Court and Court of Appeals), which operates mostly in Spanish. Alongside this, the United States District Court for the District of Puerto Rico hears cases of a federal nature and operates in English. This means both Commonwealth and federal judiciaries constantly interpret and apply legal norms from both systems.
Judicial Precedent: While civil law theory does not formally recognize stare decisis (the principle of binding judicial precedent) in the same way as common law, judicial decisions of the Supreme Court of Puerto Rico do establish precedent for lower courts.
3. Key Characteristics of Puerto Rico's Civil Laws:
Language: The primary language of the Puerto Rico legal system, particularly in Commonwealth courts, is Spanish. However, federal courts operate in English, requiring bilingual proficiency for attorneys.
Sources of Law: Puerto Rican courts frequently rely on three sources:
Written law: Primarily the Civil Code and other statutes.
Judicial opinions: Decisions of courts.
Treatise writers (tratadistas): Scholars who author detailed commentaries on civil law.
Constitutional Rights: The Constitution of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico, ratified in 1952, includes a Bill of Rights that resembles the U.S. Bill of Rights, emphasizing human dignity and equality and prohibiting discrimination.
Important Note: The legal landscape in Puerto Rico is dynamic, with ongoing legal reforms and interactions between its distinct civil law heritage and its relationship with the U.S. federal system. For specific legal advice, it is crucial to consult with a qualified attorney in Puerto Rico.
RELATED Blog
0 comments