When to File a Counterclaim?
What is a Counterclaim?
A counterclaim is a claim made by a defendant against the plaintiff in response to the plaintiff’s original claim. Essentially, the defendant is saying, "Not only do I deny your claim, but I also have a claim against you."
When to File a Counterclaim?
You should file a counterclaim when:
1. The Defendant Has a Claim Against the Plaintiff Arising from the Same Transaction or Occurrence
If your claim is connected to or arises out of the same facts or transaction as the plaintiff’s claim, you can file a counterclaim in the same lawsuit.
Example: If the plaintiff sues for breach of contract, and the defendant believes the plaintiff breached the same contract in a different way, the defendant can counterclaim.
2. To Settle All Related Disputes Together
Filing a counterclaim promotes judicial economy by resolving all related claims between the parties in one case.
It avoids multiple lawsuits.
3. If You Have a Claim Independent of the Plaintiff’s Claim
Sometimes the defendant may have a claim against the plaintiff that is unrelated to the plaintiff’s claim but wants to address it in the same litigation.
These are called permissive counterclaims and can be filed if the court has jurisdiction.
However, courts may allow or disallow permissive counterclaims depending on the rules.
Types of Counterclaims
| Type | Description |
|---|---|
| Compulsory | Arises from the same transaction/occurrence as the plaintiff’s claim; must be filed in the same case or else waived. |
| Permissive | Does not arise from the same transaction; can be filed separately or with permission in the same case. |
Timing to File a Counterclaim
A counterclaim is usually filed along with the defendant’s written statement or defense (e.g., in the written statement under Order 8, Rule 6 CPC in India).
Filing a counterclaim late may lead to it being disallowed.
Why File a Counterclaim?
To assert your rights and claims against the plaintiff.
To reduce or eliminate liability by offsetting the plaintiff’s claim.
To avoid multiple lawsuits and save time and cost.
To increase your bargaining power during settlement or trial.
Example Scenario
Plaintiff sues Defendant for unpaid rent.
Defendant believes the plaintiff failed to maintain the property, causing damage.
Defendant files a counterclaim for the cost of repairs against the plaintiff in the same suit.
Summary Table
| When to File a Counterclaim? | Explanation |
|---|---|
| Same transaction or occurrence | If claim arises from the same facts as plaintiff’s claim |
| Judicial economy | To resolve all disputes between parties in one case |
| Independent claim (permissive) | If unrelated claim but court allows it |
| Along with written defense | Typically filed with the defendant’s reply or written statement |
RELATED Blog
0 comments