Civil Laws at Sint Maarten (Netherlands)
Sint Maarten is one of the four constituent countries that form the Kingdom of the Netherlands, along with the Netherlands (Europe), Aruba, and Curaçao. As such, its civil laws are deeply rooted in the Dutch civil law tradition, which is a comprehensive, codified system.
1. Key Characteristics of Civil Law in Sint Maarten:
Dutch Civil Code: The primary source of civil law in Sint Maarten is the Civil Code of Sint Maarten (Burgerlijk Wetboek). This code is largely based on the Civil Code of the Netherlands, with adaptations for local circumstances. The current Civil Code for Sint Maarten is the result of a significant legislative modernization effort that has been ongoing for the former Netherlands Antilles (which dissolved in 2010 to form Sint Maarten and Curaçao as separate countries within the Kingdom, with Bonaire, Saba, and Sint Eustatius becoming special municipalities of the Netherlands).
Codified System: Unlike common law systems, civil law relies heavily on systematically organized codes and statutes. General principles and specific rules for various civil relationships are laid out in these codes.
Constitutional Framework: The Constitution of Sint Maarten (Staatsregeling van Sint Maarten), adopted in 2010, is the supreme law. It defines the structure of government and enshrines fundamental rights and freedoms, which guide the interpretation and application of all laws, including civil laws.
Kingdom Law: As part of the Kingdom of the Netherlands, certain Kingdom Acts and Orders in Council for the Kingdom also apply to Sint Maarten. International treaties and agreements ratified for Sint Maarten are also part of its legal framework.
Role of Case Law: While codified law is primary, case law (jurisprudence) from the Joint Court of Justice of Aruba, Curaçao, Sint Maarten and of Bonaire, Saint Eustatius and Saba and, ultimately, the Supreme Court of the Netherlands plays a crucial role in interpreting and developing the Civil Code and other civil statutes.
2. Main Areas of Civil Law in Sint Maarten:
The Civil Code of Sint Maarten is divided into various "Books," each covering a distinct area of civil law. These include:
Book 1: Law of Persons and Family Law:
Law of Persons: Regulates the legal status of individuals, including birth, death, names, domicile, and legal capacity.
Family Law: Covers marriage, civil partnership, divorce, parental authority (custody), child maintenance, adoption, and guardianship. Sint Maarten's family law includes provisions for prenuptial and postnuptial agreements. When couples marry without a prenuptial agreement, they are automatically married in a system of "community of assets" unless they opt out.
Book 2: Legal Persons (Corporate Law):
Deals with the formation, governance, rights, and obligations of legal entities such as foundations (including the Private Fund Foundation, which is popular for estate planning), associations, and companies (e.g., N.V. - Naamloze Vennootschap or public limited company, and B.V. - Besloten Vennootschap or private limited company).
Book 3: General Part of Property Law:
Covers general principles applicable to all property rights, including the distinction between movable and immovable property, legal acts, and general rules of acquisition and transfer of property.
Book 4: Law of Succession/Inheritance Law:
This book has been updated by the National Ordinance on Inheritance and Donation (AB 6 of 2014).
Regulates the distribution of assets upon death, whether by a will (testate succession) or by law (intestate succession).
It defines who the legal heirs are and their shares in the absence of a will.
Provisions relate to wills, legacies, and the administration of estates. The Civil Law Notary plays a central role in inheritance matters, issuing "declarations of inheritance."
Book 5: Real Property Law:
Focuses specifically on real estate and property rights related to land and buildings.
Covers ownership of land, mortgages, servitudes, and long-term land leases (erfpacht), which are common in Sint Maarten, especially for government land.
All real estate transactions must be executed before a civil law notary and registered in the public register for real estate property (Kadaster) to be valid.
Foreign ownership of real estate is generally permitted without residency requirements or legal restrictions.
Book 6: General Part of the Law of Obligations:
Establishes fundamental principles for obligations arising from contracts and from unlawful acts (torts).
Contract Law: Governs the formation, validity, interpretation, performance, and breach of contracts. It emphasizes principles like freedom of contract and good faith.
Law of Torts (Unlawful Acts): Deals with liability for civil wrongs that cause harm (e.g., negligence).
Book 7: Special Contracts (e.g., Employment Law):
Details specific types of contracts, such as purchase agreements, lease agreements, and, significantly, employment contracts.
Employment Law: Governs the relationship between employers and employees, including contract types (fixed-term, indefinite), working hours, minimum wage, annual leave, sick leave, termination rights and procedures, and anti-discrimination laws. Recent amendments to Book 7A of the Civil Code have updated labor laws, including rules on unilateral changes to employment conditions and stricter requirements for termination.
Book 8: Transport Law:
Deals with the legal aspects of transport, including maritime and air transport.
Book 10: International Private Law:
Contains rules for resolving conflicts of laws in cases with international elements (e.g., a contract between parties from different countries or a marriage between citizens of different nationalities).
3. Judicial System for Civil Matters:
Court in First Instance of Sint Maarten: This is the trial court for most civil cases. It is an organizational part of the Joint Court of Justice. Cases are generally heard by a single judge.
Joint Court of Justice of Aruba, Curaçao, Sint Maarten and of Bonaire, Saint Eustatius and Saba: This is the appellate court for decisions from the Courts in First Instance. Appeals are typically heard by a panel of three judges. The Joint Court is also responsible for justice administration in first instance and appeal across these islands.
Supreme Court of the Netherlands (Hoge Raad der Nederlanden): Decisions of the Joint Court of Justice can be appealed "in cassation" to the Supreme Court of the Netherlands in The Hague. The Supreme Court reviews points of law, not facts, ensuring consistent interpretation of the Civil Code across the Kingdom.
4. Role of the Civil Law Notary (Notaris):
The civil law notary plays a central and distinct role in Sint Maarten's civil law system, particularly in property law, corporate law, and succession law. They are public officials who draft and execute authentic deeds (like property transfer deeds, mortgage deeds, wills, and incorporation deeds for legal entities). Their involvement is mandatory for the legal validity of many civil law transactions.
In essence, Sint Maarten's civil laws provide a robust and well-structured legal framework, largely mirroring that of the Netherlands, but with specific local adaptations and ongoing modernization efforts.
RELATED Blog
0 comments