Civil Laws at New Zealand
New Zealand operates a civil law system based on English common law, combined with its own extensive statutory law enacted by the New Zealand Parliament. This means that while much of the law originates from judicial decisions (case law), there is also a significant body of legislation that codifies and develops various areas of civil law.
Here's an overview of the civil laws and the civil justice system in New Zealand:
1. Foundations of New Zealand Civil Law:
Common Law System: New Zealand inherited its legal system from the British Empire. This means that judicial precedents (decisions by higher courts) are binding on lower courts, ensuring consistency in legal application. Judges also play a role in developing the common law to adapt to changing circumstances.
Statutory Law: Acts passed by the New Zealand Parliament are a primary source of law. These statutes can codify existing common law, introduce new legal principles, or modify common law rules.
Treaty of Waitangi: The Treaty of Waitangi, signed in 1840 between the British Crown and Māori chiefs, is an important constitutional document. While not fully incorporated into domestic law, its principles are increasingly recognized and referenced in legislation and judicial decisions, particularly in areas affecting Māori rights and interests, including land and property.
New Zealand Bill of Rights Act 1990: This Act affirms fundamental human rights and freedoms in New Zealand. While not a "supreme law," it requires judges to interpret other statutes consistently with its provisions where possible.
2. Key Areas of Civil Law:
Civil law in New Zealand covers disputes between individuals, companies, and sometimes local or central government. It generally does not involve the Police (who deal with criminal matters). Some of the main areas include:
Contract Law: Governs agreements between parties, including formation, performance, breach, and remedies. While initially derived from English law, New Zealand contract law has evolved with specific legislation, offering courts wide discretionary powers in granting relief.
Tort Law: Deals with civil wrongs that cause harm to another, leading to legal liability. This includes:
Negligence: Where a person's carelessness causes loss or injury to another.
Defamation: Harm to reputation.
Trespass: Unlawful interference with person, land, or goods.
Accident Compensation (ACC Scheme): A unique feature of New Zealand law is the Accident Compensation Corporation (ACC) scheme. This "no-fault" scheme provides comprehensive cover for personal injuries by accident, regardless of who was at fault. Critically, it bars most civil claims for personal injury damages in the courts. Instead, injured parties claim compensation through ACC. This significantly limits personal injury litigation compared to other common law jurisdictions.
Property Law: Governs rights and interests in real (land) and personal property. Key legislation includes the Property Law Act 2007 and the Unit Titles Act 2010.
Family Law: Addresses matters such as marriage, divorce, care of children, and division of relationship property. The Family Court of New Zealand handles these disputes. Key statutes include the Care of Children Act 2004 and the Property (Relationships) Act 1976.
Consumer Law: Protects consumer interests and promotes fair trading practices. Important legislation includes:
Consumer Guarantees Act 1993: Provides guarantees for goods and services supplied to consumers.
Fair Trading Act 1986: Prohibits misleading and deceptive conduct, and promotes fair competition.
Credit Contracts and Consumer Finance Act 2003: Protects consumers in credit contracts.
Employment Law: Governs the relationship between employers and employees, covering issues like wages, working conditions, dismissal, and discrimination. The Employment Court and Employment Relations Authority handle disputes in this area.
Insolvency Law: Deals with bankruptcy and the financial affairs of individuals and companies unable to pay their debts (e.g., Insolvency Act 2006).
Privacy Law: Regulates how personal information is treated by both private and public agencies (Privacy Act 2020).
Trusts Law: Governs the creation and administration of trusts (Trusts Act 2019).
Wills and Succession Law: Determines how a person's property is distributed after death.
3. The Civil Justice System:
New Zealand's court system for civil matters is hierarchical:
Disputes Tribunal: Handles small claims (up to $30,000) informally, often without lawyers, focusing on resolution rather than strict legal procedure.
District Court: The busiest court, handling a large number of civil cases where the amount in dispute is less than $350,000. It also houses the Family Court and Youth Court.
High Court: The highest court of first instance, hearing more serious civil matters, including those involving disputes over $350,000, complex cases, and appeals from lower courts and tribunals. It also has specialized commercial panels.
Court of Appeal: Hears appeals from the High Court, playing a key role in developing legal principles and ensuring consistency.
Supreme Court: The highest and final court of appeal in New Zealand, established in 2004 (replacing the UK Privy Council as the final court). It only hears cases of general importance, commercial significance, or substantial miscarriages of justice, or those relating to the Treaty of Waitangi.
Key Principles of the Civil Justice System:
Adversarial System: The judge relies on evidence and arguments presented by the parties and their lawyers to determine facts and legal outcomes.
Open Justice: Court hearings are generally open to the public, promoting transparency and public confidence.
Proportionality: Efforts are made to ensure that the complexity and cost of legal procedures are proportionate to the importance and value of the dispute.
Access to Justice: There's an ongoing focus on improving access to civil justice, addressing concerns about costs, delays, and complexity, and promoting alternative dispute resolution (ADR) mechanisms like mediation.
Civil cases are typically initiated by a "plaintiff" (the person bringing the action) who must prove their case on the "balance of probabilities" (i.e., it is more likely than not that their version of events is correct). Many civil cases are settled outside of court through negotiation or mediation.
RELATED Blog
0 comments