Judgment Reviews Law at Samoa
Samoa has a legal system based on English common law, with a three-tiered court structure for most matters. The system for reviewing judgments is an established hierarchy of courts, which allows for appeals from lower to higher courts.
The Court System
The Samoan judicial system is primarily composed of:
District Court: This is the lowest court, which hears less serious criminal cases and civil disputes involving smaller amounts of money.
Supreme Court: The Supreme Court is a superior court of record and the primary trial court for major civil and criminal matters. It also has appellate jurisdiction over the District Court.
Court of Appeal: The Court of Appeal is the highest court in Samoa. It hears appeals from the Supreme Court, and its decisions are final.
A key part of Samoa's judicial system is the Land and Titles Court (LTC), which deals exclusively with customary land and matai (chiefly) titles. This court operates under its own legal framework based on Samoan custom and is distinct from the regular court system. In 2020, controversial constitutional amendments were passed that gave the LTC "supreme authority" over customary matters, removing the Supreme Court's supervisory jurisdiction and its ability to review LTC decisions for compliance with fundamental human rights.
Judgment Reviews and Appeals
The process for appealing a judgment in Samoa follows a clear path through the court hierarchy.
Appeals from the District Court: A party who is dissatisfied with a decision from the District Court can appeal to the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court has the power to review the case and may uphold, reverse, or vary the original judgment.
Appeals from the Supreme Court: Appeals from the Supreme Court are heard by the Court of Appeal. An appeal may be made "as of right" in civil cases involving a certain monetary value, or with "leave" (permission) from either the Supreme Court or the Court of Appeal for other cases, particularly if they involve an important question of law or public interest. The Court of Appeal also has jurisdiction to hear appeals on questions of law in criminal cases, including appeals against conviction, sentence, and acquittal.
Appeals from the Land and Titles Court (LTC): Following the 2020 constitutional reforms, the LTC's decisions are no longer subject to review by the Supreme Court. The LTC now has its own internal appellate division. This has effectively created a separate and parallel judicial branch, and the decisions of the LTC are final within that system. This change has been criticized by various bodies for undermining the rule of law and human rights protections.
The Judicature Act 2020 of Samoa is a key piece of legislation that updates the laws governing the civil and criminal courts, detailing the procedures for appeals and the functions of the Supreme Court and Court of Appeal. It also affirms the concurrent administration of common law and equity, with the rules of equity prevailing in cases of conflict.
RELATED Blog
0 comments