Judgment Reviews Law at Saba (Netherlands)
Saba, a small island in the Caribbean Netherlands, operates under a civil law system influenced by Dutch legal principles. While the Joint Court of Justice of Aruba, Curaçao, Sint Maarten, and of Bonaire, Sint Eustatius, and Saba serves as the primary judicial body for these territories, Saba does not have a dedicated court registry. Instead, court sessions are held monthly at the government administration building in The Bottom, Saba's capital
Judicial Review in the Netherlands
The Dutch Constitution prohibits courts from reviewing the constitutionality of Acts of Parliament. However, courts are obligated to assess whether statutory regulations align with international treaties. This means that while Dutch courts cannot invalidate laws based on constitutional grounds, they can examine their compatibility with international human rights obligations n
In April 2024, the Dutch government proposed extending equal treatment legislation to the Caribbean parts of the Netherlands, including Saba. This legislation aims to ensure that residents of Saba have the right to challenge discrimination on various grounds, such as gender, age, origin, religion, disability, and sexual orientation. The bill, which is scheduled to enter into force in 2025, includes provisions for anti-discrimination facilities and legal assistance
Recent Legal Developments
A notable case involved William Stanley Johnson, a resident of Saba, who challenged the disparity in pension benefits between the Caribbean Netherlands and the European Netherlands. The UN Human Rights Committee found that the lower pension amount in Saba violated the principle of non-discrimination under the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights. This case highlights the application of international human rights standards in the Caribbean Netherlands residents can seek judicial review through the Joint Court of Justice and, if necessary, appeal to the Supreme Court of the Netherlands. Additionally, the proposed equal treatment legislation and international human rights mechanisms provide avenues for addressing legal grievances and ensuring the protection of rights on the island.
RELATED Blog
0 comments