Wrongful Death under Personal Injury
Wrongful Death Under Personal Injury Law
Wrongful death is a type of personal injury claim that arises when a person dies due to the negligence, recklessness, or intentional act of another. It allows the deceased person's survivors or estate to seek compensation for the loss suffered as a result of the death.
What is Wrongful Death?
Definition: Wrongful death occurs when a person dies due to the wrongful act or omission of another party.
It is a civil action distinct from criminal prosecution, where family members or representatives sue for damages.
The claim seeks to compensate for the losses caused by the death, not to punish the wrongdoer (which is criminal law’s role).
Who Can Bring a Wrongful Death Claim?
Typically, close family members such as spouses, children, or parents.
Sometimes extended family or dependents, depending on the jurisdiction.
The claim is usually filed by a personal representative or executor of the deceased’s estate.
Types of Wrongful Death Cases
Car accidents caused by negligence.
Medical malpractice leading to death.
Workplace accidents where safety laws were violated.
Defective products causing fatal injuries.
Criminal acts (such as homicide) that result in death.
Key Elements to Prove in a Wrongful Death Claim
Duty of Care: The defendant owed a legal duty to the deceased.
Breach of Duty: The defendant failed to meet that duty (negligence or intentional wrongdoing).
Causation: The defendant’s breach caused the death.
Damages: The plaintiff suffered quantifiable losses due to the death.
Damages Recoverable in Wrongful Death Cases
Damages aim to compensate survivors for:
Economic damages: Loss of financial support, lost future earnings, medical and funeral expenses.
Non-economic damages: Loss of companionship, emotional distress, pain and suffering.
Punitive damages: In some cases, awarded to punish especially egregious conduct.
Wrongful Death vs. Survival Actions
Wrongful death claim: Compensates survivors for their losses caused by the death.
Survival action: Claims that belong to the deceased’s estate for injuries suffered before death (e.g., pain and suffering).
Both claims can sometimes be filed simultaneously depending on jurisdiction.
Important Case Law Examples
1. Amaya v. Home Ice, Fuel & Supply Co. (Cal. 1963)
Facts: The plaintiff’s husband died due to the defendant’s negligent actions.
Issue: Whether damages could include loss of love and companionship.
Decision: The court held that wrongful death damages could include both economic and non-economic losses, like loss of consortium and emotional suffering.
Significance: Established that wrongful death damages go beyond financial loss to include intangible losses.
2. Moragne v. States Marine Lines, Inc. (1970)
Facts: The plaintiff sought wrongful death damages under general maritime law.
Issue: Whether there is a cause of action for wrongful death under general maritime law.
Decision: The U.S. Supreme Court recognized a federal cause of action for wrongful death in maritime cases.
Significance: Expanded wrongful death claims beyond state law to include federal maritime law.
3. Ortiz v. Jordan (2014)
Facts: In a case involving multiple defendants, the issue was about allocation of fault in wrongful death.
Issue: How damages should be allocated among multiple tortfeasors.
Decision: Courts can apportion liability proportionally among multiple defendants.
Significance: Clarified that wrongful death damages can be divided based on fault, preventing a single defendant from bearing full financial burden unfairly.
4. Heck v. Humphrey (1994) (Indirectly related)
While not a wrongful death case per se, it’s important in wrongful death law when the death results from alleged misconduct by government officials or police.
The Supreme Court ruled that claims that would undermine a criminal conviction are barred, which impacts wrongful death claims linked to wrongful convictions or police misconduct.
Procedural Aspects
Wrongful death claims must be filed within a statute of limitations, which varies by jurisdiction but is usually shorter than other civil claims.
Claims often require detailed proof, including medical records, expert testimony on causation, and evidence of damages.
Settlements and verdicts in wrongful death cases can involve substantial sums due to the gravity of loss.
Summary
Wrongful death is a personal injury claim for death caused by negligence or wrongful acts.
It provides compensation to survivors for their economic and emotional losses.
Requires proof of duty, breach, causation, and damages.
Case law has established important principles about the types of damages and the scope of wrongful death claims.
Differentiated from survival actions and governed by specific procedural rules.
RELATED Blog
0 comments