Patient Abandonment or Premature Discharge — Can You Sue for Medical Malpractice Under the Law? under Personal Injury
⚖️ Patient Abandonment or Premature Discharge as Medical Malpractice
📌 Definition
Patient abandonment occurs when a healthcare provider unilaterally terminates the physician-patient relationship without reasonable notice or opportunity for the patient to secure alternative care, resulting in harm.
Premature discharge refers to releasing a patient from medical care too early, before it is medically safe to do so, resulting in exacerbated injury or death.
Both can constitute medical malpractice if they violate the provider’s duty of care.
✅ Legal Elements for a Successful Claim
To sue for medical malpractice due to abandonment or premature discharge, the plaintiff must prove:
Existence of a provider-patient relationship
(establishing a duty of care)
Breach of that duty
(via abandonment or unsafe discharge)
Injury or harm
(e.g., worsening of condition, death, complications)
Causation
(the harm must be directly caused by the premature termination of care)
🚫 Patient Abandonment
🔹 Common Scenarios:
A doctor or hospital discharges a patient knowing they have no access to follow-up care.
A provider discontinues treatment without arranging an appropriate transfer.
A provider fails to respond to a patient's request for care during a critical period.
🔹 Standard of Care:
A physician must not abandon a patient without reasonable notice and must ensure continuity of care until treatment is no longer needed or care is transferred.
🧑⚖️ Case Law:
Payton v. Weaver, 131 Cal. App. 3d 38 (1982)
Facts: A physician attempted to terminate treatment of a dialysis patient without ensuring alternate care.
Ruling: The court ruled that a physician cannot unilaterally end care for a chronically ill patient without proper notice and arrangements. Doing so may constitute patient abandonment.
🔹 Significance: Establishes that physicians have a continuing duty and cannot terminate care abruptly, especially in life-threatening situations.
🚪 Premature Discharge
🔹 Common Scenarios:
Hospital discharges a patient too early for insurance or administrative reasons.
Emergency department releases a patient who later suffers complications or death.
Discharge without adequate evaluation, medication, instructions, or referrals.
🧑⚖️ Case Law:
Estate of Lagano v. Bergen Regional Medical Center (N.J. App. Div. 2015)
Facts: A patient with multiple conditions was discharged from a psychiatric facility and later died.
Ruling: The court allowed a wrongful death and malpractice claim, emphasizing the duty to ensure discharge is medically appropriate and reasonably safe.
🔹 Significance: Highlights that hospitals can be liable for negligent discharge that leads to foreseeable harm.
Henderson v. Knoxville Community Hospital, Inc., 866 S.W.2d 194 (Tenn. Ct. App. 1993)
Facts: A patient was discharged from the ER despite showing signs of serious illness and later died.
Ruling: The hospital was found negligent for discharging the patient prematurely, establishing clear grounds for malpractice.
⚠️ When Abandonment or Discharge Is NOT Malpractice
If the patient voluntarily leaves against medical advice (AMA)
If appropriate notice and referrals were given
If no injury occurred (no damages = no case)
If the decision to discharge was reasonable and medically justified, even if later complications arose
💰 Damages You Can Claim
If abandonment or premature discharge results in harm, the patient or their family may seek:
Medical expenses
Pain and suffering
Lost wages
Wrongful death damages (if applicable)
Punitive damages (in cases of gross negligence)
🏥 Hospitals and Institutional Liability
Hospitals can also be held liable under:
Vicarious liability for staff negligence
Corporate negligence for unsafe discharge policies or inadequate staffing
EMTALA violations (Emergency Medical Treatment and Labor Act) for improper discharge from emergency departments
EMTALA Example: Discharging a patient from the ER without stabilizing them may also trigger federal liability.
🔚 Conclusion
Yes, you can sue for medical malpractice based on patient abandonment or premature discharge, but success depends on showing:
A valid provider-patient relationship
An unjustified termination of care
A resulting injury
No reasonable opportunity for the patient to obtain substitute care
🧾 Summary Table
| Legal Issue | Applies When | Key Case |
|---|---|---|
| Patient Abandonment | Unilateral termination of care without notice | Payton v. Weaver |
| Premature Discharge | Patient released before it is medically safe | Estate of Lagano v. Bergen |
| EMTALA Violation | ER discharge without stabilization | EMTALA enforcement cases |
| No Malpractice | Voluntary departure, no injury, or proper transition | N/A |
RELATED Blog
0 comments