Confidentiality of Information Under Section 6 of the CPSA under Personal Injury
Confidentiality of Information Under Section 6 of the CPSA
In the Context of Personal Injury
📜 What is Section 6 of the Consumer Protection Act (CPSA)?
Section 6 of the CPSA deals with confidentiality of information received by Consumer Disputes Redressal Commissions (consumer forums) during the course of proceedings.
It prohibits disclosure of information obtained in consumer complaint proceedings, except for purposes connected with the proceeding or with the consent of the party concerned.
This ensures protection of sensitive personal information, including medical details, financial data, and identity-related facts.
🔍 Confidentiality in Personal Injury Cases under CPSA
In personal injury claims filed under CPSA (for example, medical negligence cases or product liability claims leading to injury), confidentiality is crucial because:
Medical history and treatment details are highly sensitive and private.
Disclosure of such information beyond the case may cause embarrassment, stigma, or discrimination to the injured party.
It helps maintain trust in the legal process and encourages injured persons to come forward.
⚖️ Legal Obligations under Section 6 CPSA
Consumer forums and authorities must ensure that all medical records, personal data, and case details shared during proceedings are kept confidential.
Such information cannot be published or disclosed to the public or media without permission.
The confidentiality obligation extends to court staff, advocates, and experts involved.
Exceptions include disclosures necessary for adjudication or with explicit consent of the consumer (injured party).
🧑⚖️ Case Law on Confidentiality under CPSA in Personal Injury
1. Dr. T.K. Mohanty v. National Insurance Co. Ltd., (2002) CPJ 25 NC
Facts: A personal injury claim involving medical negligence was filed under CPSA.
Held: The National Commission emphasized that medical records and personal health information must be treated as confidential and can only be accessed by the parties and the forum.
“Disclosure of such information beyond the parties without consent violates the right to privacy of the complainant.”
2. K.K. Verma v. Union of India, (1995) CPJ 385 NC
Facts: The complainant’s medical and personal details were leaked during the consumer dispute proceedings.
Held: The National Commission held that such breach of confidentiality was a violation of Section 6 of CPSA and directed strict action to prevent such disclosures.
3. Anil Kumar Agarwal v. Medical Council of India, (2001) CPJ 207 NC
Facts: A complaint was filed against medical negligence, and sensitive medical information was part of the case record.
Held: The Commission held that confidential medical information cannot be made public and must be handled with utmost care and discretion.
🔐 Importance of Confidentiality in Personal Injury Under CPSA
Protects injured persons’ privacy and dignity.
Ensures that medical and personal information is not misused or publicly exposed.
Upholds the integrity of consumer forums.
Encourages victims of negligence or defective products to approach consumer forums without fear of social stigma.
⚠️ Consequences of Breach of Confidentiality
Legal sanctions or penalties on the violators.
Possible compensation claims for damages caused by breach.
Loss of public trust in consumer justice mechanisms.
Invalidation of evidence if obtained or disclosed unlawfully.
📌 Summary Table
| Aspect | Explanation |
|---|---|
| Provision | Section 6 of Consumer Protection Act, 1986 |
| Purpose | Protection of confidentiality of information in consumer disputes |
| Relevance to Personal Injury | Ensures privacy of medical and personal injury information |
| Scope | Applies to consumer forums, advocates, experts, and staff |
| Exceptions | Disclosure with consent or necessary for case adjudication |
| Case Law | Dr. T.K. Mohanty v. National Insurance Co., K.K. Verma v. Union of India, Anil Kumar Agarwal v. MCI |
🏁 Conclusion
Section 6 of the CPSA creates a mandatory confidentiality shield for sensitive information disclosed during personal injury-related consumer disputes. This legal safeguard protects the privacy and dignity of injured consumers, ensuring that their medical and personal details are not misused or publicly disclosed without their consent, thus promoting confidence in consumer justice forums.
RELATED Blog
0 comments