Medical Neglect in Nursing Homes Under the Law under Personal Injury
1. Overview
Medical neglect in nursing homes occurs when a facility fails to provide adequate medical care, leading to harm or deterioration in a resident’s health. This form of neglect falls under personal injury law, specifically within the area of nursing home abuse and neglect. Victims (or their families) may pursue civil liability against the facility and responsible staff under tort law.
2. Legal Framework
Under personal injury law, nursing homes have a duty of care to residents, which includes:
Providing timely and appropriate medical care
Monitoring and responding to health issues
Administering medications correctly
Notifying physicians and families of health changes
A breach of this duty, resulting in harm, establishes grounds for a negligence claim.
Elements of a negligence claim in this context:
Duty: The nursing home owes a duty of care to the resident.
Breach: The home fails to meet the standard of care (e.g., delayed treatment, improper medication).
Causation: The breach directly caused injury or death.
Damages: The resident suffered harm (physical, emotional, or financial).
3. Federal and State Regulations
Federal Law: Under the Nursing Home Reform Act of 1987 (42 U.S.C. § 1395i-3), nursing homes must provide services to attain and maintain the highest practicable physical, mental, and psychosocial well-being of each resident.
State Laws: Each state has statutes and regulations governing nursing homes, often mirroring federal standards but with additional protections and causes of action.
4. Examples of Medical Neglect
Failure to treat infections (e.g., UTIs, bedsores)
Inadequate wound care
Medication errors (missed doses, overdoses)
Not calling for emergency care when required
Poor monitoring of chronic conditions (e.g., diabetes)
5. Case Law Examples
a. Estate of Smith v. ManorCare of Topeka, 2013 WL 3970216 (Kan. Ct. App.)
Facts: A nursing home failed to provide adequate care for a resident with diabetes, leading to severe infections and eventual death.
Held: The court upheld the negligence claim, finding that the facility failed to follow standard protocols for diabetic monitoring and wound care. The breach of care was a proximate cause of death.
Importance: Demonstrates liability when a nursing home fails to follow established medical procedures.
b. Thomas v. Hickman, 2006 WL 2868967 (E.D. Cal.)
Facts: Family sued for wrongful death after a resident developed infected bedsores due to neglect.
Held: The court allowed the case to proceed on the grounds of gross negligence and medical neglect. The facility's failure to reposition the patient or treat the sores adequately supported claims of elder abuse and medical malpractice.
Importance: Shows how neglect of basic nursing care can amount to actionable medical neglect.
c. Health & Hospital Corp. of Marion County v. Talevski, 599 U.S. 166 (2023)
Facts: A nursing home resident was chemically restrained and transferred without consent. The family sued under Section 1983, alleging violations of federal rights under the Nursing Home Reform Act.
Held: The U.S. Supreme Court held that certain rights under the Nursing Home Reform Act are enforceable under 42 U.S.C. § 1983.
Importance: Opens the door for federal civil rights lawsuits when nursing homes violate residents’ federally protected rights, including rights to medical care.
6. Legal Theories Commonly Used
Negligence: Most common – failure to provide adequate care.
Medical Malpractice: When a licensed medical provider fails to meet the standard of care.
Wrongful Death: Filed by the family if neglect results in death.
Elder Abuse (Civil or Criminal): Some states recognize neglect as elder abuse under both civil and criminal statutes.
Breach of Contract: When a facility fails to deliver promised care under an admission agreement.
7. Damages Recoverable
Economic Damages: Medical expenses, cost of care, funeral expenses
Non-Economic Damages: Pain and suffering, emotional distress, loss of companionship
Punitive Damages: In cases of gross negligence or recklessness
Attorney’s Fees: In some jurisdictions or under specific statutes (e.g., elder abuse statutes)
8. Proving Medical Neglect
Plaintiffs typically require:
Medical records showing neglect or deviation from care standards
Expert testimony to establish the standard of care and causation
Testimony from staff or witnesses (e.g., failure to treat or delays in care)
Documentation of complaints, inspections, or regulatory violations
9. Conclusion
Medical neglect in nursing homes is a serious breach of the duty owed to vulnerable residents and is actionable under personal injury law. Case law supports the right of residents and families to seek compensation and justice when facilities fail to provide adequate medical care. Courts have consistently held facilities accountable where neglect leads to injury or death, especially when systemic or repeated failures are involved.
RELATED Blog
0 comments