Economic damages refer to the monetary losses
Economic Damages: Detailed Explanation under Personal Injury Law
I. What are Economic Damages?
Economic damages refer to monetary losses that can be calculated objectively and compensated with a specific dollar amount. They are meant to reimburse the plaintiff for actual financial losses incurred due to injury.
Unlike non-economic damages (which compensate for pain, suffering, or emotional distress), economic damages have a tangible, quantifiable value.
II. Types of Economic Damages
Medical Expenses
Costs for hospital stays, surgeries, doctor visits, medications, physical therapy, medical equipment, and rehabilitation.
Can include past and future medical costs.
Lost Wages
Compensation for income lost due to inability to work after the injury.
Includes both past lost wages and future lost earning capacity if the injury affects the ability to work long-term.
Property Damage
Costs to repair or replace damaged property, such as vehicles, clothing, or personal belongings.
Other Out-of-Pocket Expenses
Transportation costs for medical treatment.
Home care or assistance expenses.
Costs related to modifications necessary due to injury (e.g., wheelchair ramps).
III. Legal Standards for Economic Damages
Plaintiff must prove the amount and causation of damages with reasonable certainty.
Losses must be directly attributable to the defendant's wrongful conduct.
Courts require documentation, such as medical bills, pay stubs, tax returns, and expert testimony to establish future losses.
IV. Case Law Illustrating Economic Damages
1. Evans v. Bayer, 684 S.W.2d 792 (Mo. Ct. App. 1985)
Facts: Plaintiff suffered injuries in a car accident and claimed lost wages and medical expenses.
Holding: The court allowed recovery of lost wages as long as they were proven with reasonable certainty, not speculation.
Principle: Economic damages must be supported by evidence such as employment records or expert testimony estimating future earnings.
2. Mattingly v. Mount Zion Hospital, 15 Ill. App. 3d 1072 (1973)
Facts: Plaintiff sued for medical expenses after a malpractice incident.
Holding: The court recognized past and future medical expenses as recoverable economic damages, emphasizing the need for credible proof (medical bills, doctor testimony).
Principle: Future medical expenses require expert testimony to establish necessity and cost.
3. Fisher v. Shamburg, 34 Wash. App. 775 (1983)
Facts: Plaintiff sought compensation for property damage and medical expenses after an accident.
Holding: The court ruled that the plaintiff must show actual loss and causation to recover economic damages.
Principle: Property damage claims must be supported by proof of value or repair costs.
V. Calculating Economic Damages
Medical Expenses: Receipts, invoices, hospital billing statements.
Lost Wages: Employer statements, tax returns, pay stubs, or vocational expert analysis.
Future Lost Earnings: Economists or vocational experts often calculate based on age, occupation, education, and life expectancy.
Property Damage: Repair estimates or appraisals.
VI. Economic Damages vs. Non-Economic Damages
| Aspect | Economic Damages | Non-Economic Damages |
|---|---|---|
| Nature | Tangible financial losses | Intangible losses (pain, suffering, emotional distress) |
| Proof Required | Objective documentation (bills, pay stubs) | Subjective testimony, often expert opinions |
| Recoverable Items | Medical bills, lost wages, property damage | Pain and suffering, loss of consortium |
VII. Summary
Economic damages are a critical part of personal injury compensation.
They require clear evidence and are often the easiest to quantify.
Courts emphasize proof of causation and certainty.
Expert testimony can be crucial for future damages.
The goal is to restore the plaintiff financially to the position before the injury.
RELATED Blog
0 comments