Broken/Fractured Bones in Personal Injury Lawsuits under Personal Injury
🔹 Broken or Fractured Bones – Overview
A broken or fractured bone occurs when a bone is cracked, chipped, or completely broken due to trauma or accident. In personal injury law, such injuries are significant because they:
Cause physical pain and suffering
Require medical treatment, rehabilitation, or surgery
Result in lost wages and diminished earning capacity
May lead to permanent disability or disfigurement
Common causes in personal injury cases:
Motor vehicle accidents
Workplace accidents
Slip and fall incidents
Sports injuries
Medical negligence
🔹 Legal Framework
1. Basis for Claim
Negligence: Most fractures in personal injury cases arise due to someone else’s negligent conduct.
Strict Liability: In some cases, such as defective products causing fractures, liability arises even without fault.
Intentional Torts: Rarely, fractures may result from assault or battery.
2. Elements of a Personal Injury Claim for Fractures
Duty of Care: Defendant owed a duty to prevent harm.
Breach of Duty: Defendant failed to act reasonably.
Causation: Defendant’s actions caused the fracture.
Damages: Fracture caused physical injury, medical expenses, lost income, or pain and suffering.
🔹 Types of Fractures and Their Legal Significance
Simple Fracture: Single crack; usually lower compensation unless it causes significant loss of function.
Compound Fracture: Bone pierces the skin; often higher compensation due to severity and infection risk.
Comminuted Fracture: Bone shatters; may require surgery or implants; higher damages likely.
Greenstick Fracture (common in children): May affect future growth; compensation considers long-term impact.
Severity and long-term impact of the fracture directly affect the damages awarded.
🔹 Damages in Fracture Cases
Medical Expenses: Hospital bills, surgery, medications, physiotherapy.
Lost Wages: Temporary or permanent loss of earning capacity.
Pain and Suffering: Compensation for physical pain, emotional distress.
Permanent Disability: Partial or total impairment may increase damages.
Loss of Enjoyment of Life: Considered in severe fractures affecting mobility or independence.
🔹 Key Case Law
1. Donoghue v. Stevenson (1932) AC 562 [UK]
Established the duty of care principle.
Fractures from negligence fall under the general principles of tortious liability.
2. Barker v. Lull Engineering Co., 20 Cal.3d 413 (1978) [USA]
Reinforced that employers are liable for fractures caused by workplace negligence.
Damages included medical expenses and lost wages.
3. Indian Oil Corporation v. NEPC India Ltd. (2006) 6 SCC 736 [India]
Fractures resulting from industrial accidents held to be compensable under tort principles.
Court considered severity, duration of treatment, and impact on earning capacity.
4. Jones v. Kaney (2001) 2 AC 398 [UK]
Fractures caused by medical negligence led to compensation including long-term care and pain and suffering.
5. Mohan v. State of Karnataka (2004) Karnataka High Court
Employee suffered compound fractures due to unsafe working conditions.
Court awarded compensation for medical treatment, lost wages, and future disability.
🔹 Practical Considerations
Medical Documentation:
X-rays, CT scans, orthopedic reports, and physiotherapy records are crucial for proving injury and extent of damage.
Liability Assessment:
Establishing negligence or fault is essential.
Comparative negligence may reduce compensation if the plaintiff contributed to the accident.
Expert Testimony:
Orthopedic surgeons or rehabilitation experts may testify about the severity, prognosis, and permanent effects of the fracture.
Insurance Claims:
Fracture cases often involve claims against auto insurance, workers’ compensation, or public liability insurance.
🔹 Summary
Broken or fractured bones in personal injury lawsuits are highly compensable injuries due to physical, financial, and emotional impact.
Courts consider severity, treatment costs, lost income, permanent impairment, and pain and suffering when awarding damages.
Liability arises from negligence, strict liability, or intentional torts, and medical documentation and expert testimony are essential for substantiating claims.
RELATED Blog
0 comments