Controlling Attorneys' Fees under Personal Injury
1. Contingency Fee Agreements
Definition:
In most personal injury cases, attorneys work on a contingency fee basis, meaning they receive a percentage of the client’s recovery (whether via settlement or verdict). If the client recovers nothing, the attorney gets nothing.
Standard Percentages:
Typically ranges from 33.33% to 40%.
The percentage may vary depending on the stage at which the case is resolved (e.g., pre-trial vs. after trial or appeal).
Requirements:
Must be in writing.
Must clearly explain how fees are calculated.
Must specify whether expenses (e.g., filing fees, expert witness costs) are deducted before or after the fee is calculated.
2. Ethical Rules and Professional Responsibility
ABA Model Rules:
Rule 1.5 of the ABA Model Rules of Professional Conduct states:
“A lawyer shall not make an agreement for, charge, or collect an unreasonable fee.”
Factors considered in determining whether a fee is reasonable include:
Time and labor required.
Complexity of the case.
The fee customarily charged in the locality.
The amount involved and the results obtained.
The experience, reputation, and ability of the lawyer.
⚖️ Case Law:
In re Cooperman, 633 N.E.2d 1069 (N.Y. 1994) – The court held that nonrefundable retainer fees were unethical when used to limit a client’s right to terminate the attorney-client relationship.
3. Judicial Oversight of Fees
Courts have inherent power to review contingency fee agreements for fairness and reasonableness, especially when minors or incapacitated persons are involved.
⚖️ Case Law:
Gair v. Peck, 6 N.Y.2d 97 (1959) – The New York Court of Appeals upheld the regulation of contingent fees and recognized the court’s authority to oversee such agreements to prevent excessive legal fees.
King v. Fox, 7 N.Y.3d 181 (2006) – The court found that even where a contingency fee was agreed upon, a court could modify or reject a fee that was unconscionable or unreasonable under the circumstances.
4. Statutory Caps on Fees
Some jurisdictions have enacted laws capping attorneys' fees in personal injury or medical malpractice cases.
Example: New York Judiciary Law § 474-a
Caps attorney fees in medical malpractice cases on a sliding scale:
30% of the first $250,000
25% of the next $250,000
20% of the next $500,000
15% of the next $250,000
10% of any amount over $1.25 million
⚖️ Case Law:
Matter of Lawrence, 24 N.Y.3d 320 (2014) – The Court of Appeals of New York reaffirmed that courts must ensure fees are fair and reasonable even if based on a written agreement, especially when they involve fiduciary relationships.
5. Special Protections for Certain Plaintiffs
When a minor, ward, or incapacitated person is the plaintiff, courts often require approval of any settlement and any fees to be paid from that settlement.
⚖️ Case Law:
Pearl v. Methodist Hosp., 120 Misc.2d 494 (N.Y. Sup. Ct. 1983) – A court reduced attorney's fees in a minor’s personal injury case, finding the original contingency agreement unreasonable.
6. Fee Disputes and Resolution
Clients have the right to dispute fees, and many jurisdictions require mandatory fee arbitration before litigation.
Example: California’s Mandatory Fee Arbitration Act (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6200)
Provides an informal, non-binding arbitration process for fee disputes between attorneys and clients.
7. Unconscionability and Public Policy
Courts will not enforce a fee agreement that is unconscionable or violates public policy.
⚖️ Case Law:
Hayes v. Secretary of Health and Human Services, 923 F.2d 418 (6th Cir. 1990) – The court held that contingency fees exceeding statutory limits in social security cases are unenforceable, as they violate public policy.
Summary
| Mechanism | Role |
|---|---|
| Written Agreement | Ensures transparency and clarity |
| Ethical Rules | Prevents excessive or unreasonable fees |
| Judicial Oversight | Allows courts to modify or reject unfair fees |
| Statutory Caps | Legally limits fees in certain cases |
| Special Plaintiff Protections | Courts supervise fees in cases involving minors or incompetents |
| Fee Dispute Resolution | Provides arbitration to resolve conflicts |
RELATED Blog
0 comments