Prospectus and Misstatement in a Prospectus
📘 Topic: Prospectus and Misstatement in a Prospectus
Relevant Law: Companies Act, 2013 (Earlier: Companies Act, 1956)
🔍 What is a Prospectus?
📜 Definition (Section 2(70) of the Companies Act, 2013):
A prospectus is any document described or issued as a prospectus, including any notice, circular, advertisement, or other document inviting offers from the public for the subscription or purchase of any securities of a company.
✅ Key Features of a Prospectus:
Issued to the Public – Must invite public subscription.
Issued by or on behalf of a company – Generally by public companies intending to raise capital.
Invitation to Subscribe – For shares, debentures, or other securities.
Information Disclosure – Must contain material information about the company, its promoters, financial status, risk factors, and objectives.
📘 Types of Prospectus:
| Type | Explanation |
|---|---|
| Red Herring Prospectus | Preliminary prospectus without complete details (Section 32). |
| Shelf Prospectus | Used for multiple issues over a period (Section 31). |
| Deemed Prospectus | Offer for sale by intermediaries is treated as a prospectus. |
| Abridged Prospectus | Summary version provided with application forms. |
⚠️ What is a Misstatement in a Prospectus?
A misstatement refers to:
Untrue Statement – A statement that is false or misleading in form or content.
Omission of Material Facts – Failure to disclose important information, making other statements misleading.
📌 Relevant Provision:
🔹 Section 34 – Criminal liability for misstatements.
If a prospectus includes any untrue or misleading statement, every person who authorized its issue is liable for punishment.
🔹 Section 35 – Civil liability for misstatements.
Investors who suffer a loss due to misstatements may sue for compensation.
🔹 Section 36 – Punishment for fraudulently inducing persons to invest money.
🧑⚖️ Key Elements to Prove Misstatement:
There was a misstatement or material omission.
It was included in the prospectus.
The investor relied on the prospectus.
The investor suffered loss or damage.
⚖️ Legal Consequences of Misstatement:
| Liability Type | Against Whom | Penalty |
|---|---|---|
| Civil Liability (Section 35) | Directors, promoters, experts | Compensation for loss |
| Criminal Liability (Section 34) | Persons authorising the issue | Imprisonment up to 10 years + Fine |
| Rescission of Contract | By allottees/investors | Cancellation of share contract |
📚 Case Law:
1. New Brunswick and Canada Railway Co. v. Muggeridge (1860)
Principle: A company must not mislead investors by withholding material facts.
Holding: Persons who issue a prospectus are bound to state everything material; silence may also mislead.
2. Rex v. Kylsant and Otrs. (1932)
A director was convicted for misleading statements in a prospectus that concealed the company’s losses.
Court’s View: Even if literal statements are true, intentional concealment of material facts is fraud.
3. Peek v. Gurney (1873)
Prospectus failed to disclose liabilities.
The Court held the directors liable because omission of liabilities misled the public.
Laid down the principle that omission of material facts amounts to fraud.
4. Derry v. Peek (1889)
Introduced the requirement of fraudulent intent for establishing liability in deceit.
Held that honest belief in a false statement does not amount to fraud.
📝 Example:
Suppose a prospectus states that a company is entering the electric vehicle (EV) market and shows projected high profits, but fails to mention that its key regulatory approval was denied, this omission can be a material misstatement, making the directors liable.
🏁 Summary Table:
| Concept | Explanation |
|---|---|
| Prospectus | Public invitation to invest in securities, containing key company information |
| Misstatement | False or misleading statements or material omissions in the prospectus |
| Civil Liability | Compensation to affected investors (Section 35) |
| Criminal Liability | Punishment for fraudulent misstatements (Section 34) |
| Remedies | Rescission of allotment, damages, prosecution |
✅ Conclusion:
A prospectus is a powerful tool for a company to raise capital but must be issued with full honesty and disclosure. Misstatements—whether by untrue declarations or omissions—can result in severe civil and criminal liabilities under the Companies Act and common law principles.
RELATED Blog
0 comments