Challenges to Corporate Governance in India
Challenges to Corporate Governance in India
India has made significant progress in developing corporate governance frameworks, especially after high-profile corporate scandals (like Satyam in 2009) and reforms such as the Companies Act 2013. However, several challenges remain that hinder the effective implementation of good governance practices.
1. Weak Enforcement of Laws and Regulations
Although India has comprehensive corporate laws (Companies Act 2013, SEBI regulations), enforcement is often weak due to slow judicial processes and regulatory limitations.
Delays in resolving disputes and prosecuting offenders reduce deterrence for corporate misconduct.
2. Dominance of Promoter-Driven Companies
Many Indian companies are family-controlled with promoters holding large stakes.
This concentration of ownership can lead to conflicts of interest, lack of board independence, and minority shareholder oppression.
It often results in weak monitoring of management and related-party transactions.
3. Inadequate Board Independence
Boards often lack a sufficient number of truly independent directors.
Independent directors may not always act independently due to close ties with promoters or lack of expertise.
This reduces effective oversight of management decisions.
4. Lack of Transparency and Disclosure
Despite regulatory requirements, some companies still provide insufficient or delayed disclosure of financials and related-party transactions.
Non-transparent practices affect investor confidence and market integrity.
5. Related Party Transactions and Conflict of Interest
Related-party dealings are widespread and sometimes not conducted at arm’s length.
Such transactions may be used to siphon off resources, harming minority shareholders and the company’s health.
6. Insider Trading and Market Manipulation
Insider trading remains a concern despite SEBI’s vigilance.
Manipulative practices can distort market prices and erode trust.
7. Weak Shareholder Activism
Indian shareholders, especially retail investors, are often passive due to lack of awareness or power.
Institutional investors like mutual funds and foreign investors have more influence but still limited involvement in governance activism.
8. Limited Role of Auditors and External Professionals
The auditing profession has faced credibility issues (e.g., Satyam scandal).
Audit committees may lack independence or expertise to challenge management.
Over-reliance on auditors without robust checks can reduce governance effectiveness.
9. Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) Challenges
Although CSR spending is mandated under the Companies Act, implementation and impact measurement are inconsistent.
Sometimes CSR is treated as a compliance exercise rather than a strategic governance component.
10. Cultural and Ethical Issues
Indian business culture may sometimes prioritize relationships and informal dealings over formal governance structures.
Ethical lapses and corruption at various levels affect governance quality.
11. Regulatory Complexity and Overlap
Overlapping jurisdictions among regulators (SEBI, MCA, RBI) can create confusion.
Compliance burden can be high, especially for smaller companies.
Summary
Despite improvements, Indian corporate governance faces challenges mainly related to enforcement, promoter dominance, board independence, transparency, and shareholder activism. Strengthening regulatory enforcement, improving board quality, encouraging shareholder engagement, and fostering an ethical culture are key steps for better governance in India.
Do write to us if you need any further assistance.
RELATED Blog
0 comments