Juvenile Laws at Monaco
Monaco's juvenile justice system is designed to address offenses committed by minors with a focus on both accountability and rehabilitation.
Legal Framework
Age of Criminal Responsibility: In Monaco, the age of criminal responsibility is set at 13. Minors under this age are presumed incapable of committing criminal offenses. However, recent amendments to the Penal Procedure Code have raised concerns, as they allow children under 13 to be placed in preventive detention, which may not align with international standards.
Criminal Procedure Code: Monaco's Criminal Procedure Code includes provisions for proceedings involving juvenile offenders. The code emphasizes a balance between punitive measures and educational interventions, aiming to reintegrate minors into society. Notably, the code allows for the exemption of juveniles from criminal sanctions in favor of educational measures.
Judicial Bodies and Procedures
Guardianship Judge: The Guardianship Judge oversees matters concerning minors, including protection and custody issues. In criminal cases involving juveniles, this judge replaces the Examining Judge and has the authority to implement various measures such as inquiries, supervised monitoring, or, in some cases, dismissal of charges.
Criminal Court: When cases involving minors proceed to trial, the Criminal Court convenes with a panel that includes both professional judges and lay jurors. Proceedings are generally public, but the court has the discretion to conduct closed sessions, especially when dealing with minors, to protect their privacy and uphold public morals.
Children's Rights and Legal Representation
Legal Representation: Children in Monaco are represented in court by their legal representatives, typically their parents. In situations where there is a conflict of interest between the child and their parents, an ad hoc administrator may be appointed to represent the child's interests. Additionally, the concept of a "child's lawyer" exists, though its legal framework is not fully developed, leading to some uncertainties regarding appointment procedures.
Voice of the Child: Monaco's legal system acknowledges the right of children capable of forming their own views to express those views freely in matters affecting them. Judges may hear the child's views directly or through appointed representatives, ensuring that the child's perspective is considered in legal proceedings.
Recent Observations and Recommendations
The Committee on the Rights of the Child has expressed concerns that Monaco's Penal Procedure Code may not fully align with international standards. Recommendations include raising the age of criminal responsibility above 13 and reconsidering amendments that permit preventive detention for younger children. The committee also advocates for alternative measures to the justice system, such as diversion, probation, mediation, counseling, or community service, and emphasizes the need for specialized training for the judiciary in juvenile justice matters.
In summary, Monaco's juvenile justice system strives to balance the need for accountability with the rehabilitation and protection of minors. While legal frameworks and procedures are in place, ongoing efforts are needed to ensure that Monaco's practices align with international standards and fully uphold the rights of children involved in the justice system.
RELATED Blog
0 comments