Case law on delegated legislation in India
⚖️ Delegated Legislation in India
🧠 I. What is Delegated Legislation?
Delegated Legislation refers to:
Legislation made by an authority other than the legislature, under powers given to it by an act of the legislature.
In India, Parliament or a State Legislature may delegate law-making powers to the executive or a statutory body through enabling provisions in a parent statute.
✅ Why is it needed?
Legislature can’t foresee all contingencies.
Complex modern governance requires technical rules and quick decisions.
Parliament focuses on policy, executive on details.
⚠️ Limits on Delegated Legislation
Delegation must not override essential legislative functions, such as:
Determining policy
Laying down principles
Providing guidelines
The Constitution of India restricts excessive or uncontrolled delegation.
🧑⚖️ II. Landmark Indian Case Laws on Delegated Legislation
Here are six landmark cases with detailed explanations showing the evolution and control of delegated legislation in India:
1. In re: Delhi Laws Act, 1951 (AIR 1951 SC 332)
🔹 First major case on delegated legislation in India
Facts:
The President referred the validity of Section 2 of the Delhi Laws Act, which allowed the Central Government to extend laws to Delhi.
Held:
The Supreme Court upheld conditional legislation (laws taking effect upon satisfaction of a condition).
It laid down that:
Parliament can delegate powers, but cannot delegate essential legislative functions.
Significance:
Established the doctrine of permissible delegation.
Legislative policy and framework must be laid down in the parent act.
2. D.S. Gerewal v. State of Punjab (AIR 1959 SC 512)
Facts:
Challenge to a provision allowing the Punjab Government to make rules for managing schools.
Held:
Delegation is valid if the parent statute lays down standards and policy.
A lack of guidelines would render the delegation invalid.
Significance:
Reinforced that delegated authority cannot act arbitrarily.
Delegation should not result in abdication of legislative responsibility.
3. A.K. Roy v. Union of India (1982) 1 SCC 271
Facts:
Challenge to preventive detention rules under the National Security Act, which were made by the executive.
Held:
The Supreme Court upheld the delegation but observed that:
Delegated legislation must conform to constitutional limitations, such as fundamental rights.
Significance:
Introduced judicial review of delegated legislation if it violates the Constitution.
4. Municipal Corporation of Delhi v. Birla Cotton Spinning and Weaving Mills (AIR 1968 SC 1232)
Facts:
The MCD was empowered to impose taxes through delegated legislation.
Held:
The power to fix rate of tax can be delegated if the levy and incidence are defined by the statute.
Legislature must prescribe policy and framework.
Significance:
Upheld delegation for tax matters but reiterated the need for legislative guidance.
5. Hamdard Dawakhana v. Union of India (AIR 1960 SC 554)
Facts:
Under the Drugs and Magic Remedies Act, the government could ban advertisements deemed objectionable.
Held:
This was unconstitutional because:
The delegation gave arbitrary discretion to the executive with no guiding principles.
Significance:
Clear message that "uncontrolled and unguided" discretion to the executive is invalid.
6. Vasu Dev Singh v. Union of India (2006) 12 SCC 753
Facts:
Concerned delegated powers given to authorities under the Railways Act to fix passenger fares.
Held:
The Court upheld the delegation since the parent act provided sufficient framework and guidelines.
Significance:
Reaffirmed the principle that detailed rule-making can be delegated, but not policy-making.
🧩 III. Key Doctrines and Tests from Case Law
| Doctrine/Test | Explanation | Leading Case |
|---|---|---|
| Essential Legislative Function Test | Only non-essential functions can be delegated | In re: Delhi Laws Act |
| Guidelines and Policy Requirement | Parent act must guide the delegate | D.S. Gerewal, Hamdard Dawakhana |
| Judicial Review | Delegated legislation can be struck down for unconstitutionality | A.K. Roy |
| Taxation Limits | Levy of tax is legislative; rate-setting can be delegated | Birla Cotton |
| No Arbitrariness | Discretion must be guided and limited | Hamdard Dawakhana |
⚖️ IV. Types of Delegated Legislation
| Type | Description |
|---|---|
| Statutory Rules | Rules framed under authority of a statute |
| By-laws | Local or specialized laws by bodies like municipalities |
| Notifications | Executive announcements to implement provisions |
| Orders/Regulations | Used in technical or administrative matters |
✅ V. Conclusion
Delegated legislation is an essential feature of modern governance, especially in a welfare state like India. However, checks and balances are necessary to:
Prevent executive overreach
Protect fundamental rights
Ensure legislative accountability
The Indian judiciary has consistently upheld valid delegation while striking down arbitrary or excessive delegations that lack policy or safeguards.
RELATED Blog
0 comments