Arbitration Law in Cuba
Arbitration Law in Cuba
Cuba has developed a legal framework for arbitration that is consistent with international standards, particularly in the context of resolving commercial disputes. The country has taken steps to modernize its legal system, including embracing arbitration, particularly for foreign investment and international commercial disputes. While the Cuban legal system still operates with some level of government oversight, arbitration is gaining recognition as an effective mechanism for dispute resolution.
1. Legal Framework for Arbitration in Cuba
Cuba’s arbitration laws are based on both domestic statutes and international conventions. The primary sources of arbitration law include:
Civil Procedure Code (Código de Procedimiento Civil, 1977):
The Cuban Civil Procedure Code has provisions related to arbitration, including its recognition, enforcement, and the procedures for challenging arbitral awards. This law provides the procedural framework for arbitration within the country and regulates aspects such as the enforcement of arbitral awards and the jurisdiction of Cuban courts in relation to arbitration.
Arbitration Law (Law No. 107 of 2013):
In 2013, Cuba enacted Law No. 107, which specifically regulates commercial arbitration in Cuba. This law is intended to support the growing need for alternative dispute resolution mechanisms, especially in the context of international commercial contracts and foreign investments.
International Treaties:
Cuba has signed several international treaties that facilitate the recognition and enforcement of arbitral awards, particularly those relating to international commercial arbitration:
- The New York Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards (1958): Cuba is a party to the New York Convention, which provides for the recognition and enforcement of foreign arbitral awards in Cuba and vice versa.
- Inter-American Convention on International Commercial Arbitration (1975): Cuba is also a signatory to this convention, further supporting international arbitration among American states.
2. Arbitration Agreement and Procedure
Arbitration Agreement
To initiate arbitration in Cuba, the parties must agree to arbitrate. This agreement must be in writing and is generally included as an arbitration clause in contracts. Cuban law recognizes both domestic and international arbitration agreements. The arbitration agreement should specify:
- The seat of the arbitration (i.e., the jurisdiction).
- The rules under which arbitration will proceed.
- The arbitral institution (if any) or whether the proceedings will be ad hoc.
- The number of arbitrators (whether one or three).
Arbitration Procedure
Cuban arbitration law provides flexibility in how arbitration proceedings are conducted. Key features of the arbitration procedure include:
- Tribunal Composition: The parties can agree on the number of arbitrators (typically one or three). If they cannot agree, the Arbitration Law provides for a process of selection, often involving a court or an arbitral institution.
- Language: The parties can agree on the language of the proceedings. If the parties do not agree, the arbitral tribunal determines the language.
- Arbitration Rules: The parties can select the rules under which the arbitration will be conducted. Common choices include UNCITRAL Rules, ICC Rules, or Cuban-specific institutional rules if applicable. In the absence of agreement, the tribunal can establish the procedure.
3. Judicial Intervention in Arbitration
Limited Judicial Intervention
Cuban law aims to minimize the intervention of courts in the arbitration process. Courts will only get involved in specific circumstances:
- Compelling Arbitration: If a party refuses to abide by an arbitration agreement, the other party can seek a court order to compel arbitration.
- Appointment of Arbitrators: If the parties cannot agree on arbitrators, the court can step in and appoint them.
- Interim Measures: Courts may grant interim measures to preserve evidence or protect the rights of the parties during the arbitration process.
Setting Aside an Award
In Cuba, an arbitral award can be challenged on limited grounds, similar to other jurisdictions. Grounds for setting aside an award include:
- If the arbitration agreement is deemed invalid.
- If the tribunal exceeds its jurisdiction or makes a decision beyond the scope of the agreement.
- If the award violates public policy in Cuba.
- If due process or fairness principles are violated in the arbitration proceedings.
4. Enforcement of Arbitral Awards
Domestic Awards
Arbitral awards made in Cuba are generally enforceable within the country, unless the award is successfully challenged by a party. The Civil Procedure Code provides the framework for enforcement, and the Cuban courts will generally support the enforcement of an arbitral award.
Foreign Arbitral Awards
As a party to the New York Convention, Cuba has committed to recognizing and enforcing foreign arbitral awards. Foreign arbitral awards can be enforced in Cuba following a procedure established under the New York Convention. The process typically involves submitting a request to the court, which will verify the validity of the award and the arbitration agreement.
- Recognition Process: To enforce a foreign award in Cuba, the party seeking enforcement must provide the original or a certified copy of the award, along with the arbitration agreement. If the award meets the requirements of the New York Convention, it will be enforced unless one of the exceptions applies, such as violations of public policy.
5. Arbitration Institutions in Cuba
Cuba has established various institutions to facilitate both domestic and international arbitration:
Cuban Chamber of Commerce (Cámara de Comercio de la República de Cuba):
The Cuban Chamber of Commerce is one of the main arbitration institutions in Cuba. It offers services for commercial arbitration and is particularly well-suited for resolving disputes related to international trade and foreign investments.
Cuban Arbitration Center (Centro de Arbitraje de la Cámara de Comercio de la República de Cuba):
The Cuban Arbitration Center is a key institution for conducting arbitration under Cuban law. It provides a forum for the resolution of disputes, including those involving foreign investors, and applies both Cuban rules and international arbitration rules (e.g., UNCITRAL).
International Arbitration Institutions:
In addition to local institutions, Cuban businesses and individuals involved in international disputes often choose well-known international arbitration institutions. Some prominent ones include:
- International Chamber of Commerce (ICC).
- London Court of International Arbitration (LCIA).
- International Centre for Dispute Resolution (ICDR).
- Permanent Court of Arbitration (PCA).
These institutions provide global arbitration services and are often chosen for high-profile or cross-border disputes.
6. Advantages of Arbitration in Cuba
International Recognition and Enforcement:
Cuba's commitment to the New York Convention ensures that foreign arbitral awards are recognized and enforceable within the country, making it an attractive jurisdiction for international arbitration.
Legal Modernization:
With the Arbitration Law (Law No. 107) and membership in international conventions, Cuba has modernized its legal framework to support the growing use of arbitration in commercial disputes, especially in the context of foreign trade and investment.
Neutral Venue for International Disputes:
As a country that is strategically located in the Caribbean, Cuba offers a neutral venue for arbitration, particularly for disputes involving businesses in the region.
Flexibility in Arbitration Process:
Cuban law offers significant flexibility in designing the arbitration process, including selecting arbitrators, the rules, and the seat of arbitration.
7. Challenges and Considerations
Political and Economic Climate:
Given Cuba's unique political and economic environment, some international businesses may be hesitant to engage in arbitration within the country due to concerns about the legal and regulatory system.
Limited Arbitration Infrastructure:
While Cuba has made strides in developing arbitration, the number of local arbitration practitioners and institutions is still relatively small compared to other jurisdictions. This could impact the availability of specialized arbitrators or expertise for certain types of disputes.
Costs of International Arbitration:
The costs associated with arbitration, especially in international forums, may be a consideration for businesses in Cuba, particularly for smaller companies.
Conclusion
Cuba has taken significant steps to establish a legal framework that supports arbitration as a means of resolving commercial disputes. With the Arbitration Law (Law No. 107) and membership in international conventions such as the New York Convention, Cuba has positioned itself as a potential venue for international arbitration, particularly for disputes related to foreign trade and investment. While there are challenges regarding infrastructure and the political environment, Cuba’s efforts to modernize its legal system make it an increasingly attractive option for arbitration, especially for disputes involving Caribbean and Latin American businesses.
RELATED Blog
0 comments