Tort law at Ukraine
Tort law in Ukraine is primarily governed by the Civil Code of Ukraine and follows the civil law system, which is rooted in the Roman-Germanic legal tradition. Ukraine's tort law is designed to provide remedies for harm caused by wrongful acts, whether intentional or negligent, and includes both personal injury and property damage.
Legal Framework for Tort Law in Ukraine
Civil Code of Ukraine (2004): The Civil Code is the primary source of law for tort claims in Ukraine. It addresses both contractual and extracontractual liability, with Part 3 specifically dealing with extracontractual (tort) liability.
Other Relevant Legislation:
The Law of Ukraine on the Protection of Consumers' Rights: Addresses torts related to product liability and consumer protection.
The Law of Ukraine on Environmental Protection: Governs torts related to environmental damage.
Constitution of Ukraine (1996): The Constitution guarantees the protection of individual rights, which can form the basis of certain tort claims (e.g., personal injuries, defamation, and unlawful detention).
Judicial Precedents and Case Law: Court decisions in Ukraine also shape the interpretation of tort law, and judicial precedents are important for understanding how laws are applied in specific circumstances.
Key Principles of Tort Law in Ukraine
To establish liability in a tort claim in Ukraine, the plaintiff generally needs to prove the following elements:
Wrongful Act (Неправомірний вчинок): The defendant must have committed an unlawful act (either an intentional or negligent action) that causes harm to the plaintiff.
Damage (Шкода): The plaintiff must show that they suffered actual harm or damage (material or moral) due to the defendant's actions.
Causality (Причинний зв’язок): There must be a direct causal connection between the defendant's wrongful act and the harm suffered by the plaintiff.
Fault (Вина): Tort law generally requires the defendant to be at fault for the wrongful act, either by acting negligently or intentionally. However, in some cases, strict liability applies, meaning the defendant may be liable even without proof of fault.
Types of Torts Recognized in Ukraine
1. Negligence (Невиконання обов'язків)
Negligence is one of the most common bases for tort claims in Ukraine.
A claim for negligence requires proof that the defendant failed to exercise the appropriate level of care and that this failure directly caused harm to the plaintiff.
Example: Road accidents, medical malpractice, or accidents on property.
2. Defamation (Наклеп або образа)
Defamation claims (both libel and slander) are recognized in Ukrainian tort law.
A person can claim damages for reputational harm caused by false statements made by another.
The defendant can defend themselves by proving that the statement was true or protected by privilege (e.g., fair comment or public interest).
3. Trespass (Втручання в майно або особисту свободу)
Trespass to land: Entering someone’s land without permission is a tort in Ukraine. A property owner can claim damages if someone unlawfully enters their land or damages their property.
Trespass to person: This includes assault, battery, and false imprisonment. Claims for battery or assault can be made when a person is physically harmed or threatened with harm.
4. Nuisance (Неправомірне використання майна)
Nuisance occurs when a defendant’s actions interfere with another’s enjoyment of their property or their right to live peacefully.
Examples include excessive noise, pollution, or other disturbances that affect the quality of life of others.
5. Strict Liability (Об'єктивна відповідальність)
Certain activities carry strict liability, meaning that a person or company may be liable for harm even if they were not negligent.
For example, businesses handling dangerous substances, or activities that pose a significant risk to others (like industrial activities), may be held strictly liable for any resulting harm.
6. Environmental Torts (Екологічні збитки)
Ukraine has laws that allow for tort claims related to environmental harm, such as pollution or degradation of natural resources.
These claims can be made against individuals or companies responsible for causing environmental damage.
Damages in Tort Cases
In Ukraine, the remedy for a tort typically involves monetary compensation, which can include:
Material Damages (матеріальні збитки): These are damages for actual, quantifiable financial loss resulting from the wrongful act, such as medical expenses, lost wages, or the cost of repairing damaged property.
Moral Damages (моральна шкода): Compensation for non-material harm such as emotional distress, pain and suffering, or damage to a person’s dignity or reputation. In Ukraine, claims for moral damages are recognized and can be awarded in addition to material damages.
Punitive Damages: Unlike some common law systems, punitive or exemplary damages are not typically awarded under Ukrainian tort law. The primary focus is on compensatory damages.
Defenses to Tort Claims in Ukraine
Several defenses may be available to defendants in tort claims in Ukraine, including:
Consent (Згода): If the plaintiff consented to the defendant’s actions, the defendant may be able to use this as a defense. For example, in sports-related injuries, a player’s consent to the risks of the game may prevent a tort claim.
Self-Defense (Самооборона): A defendant may be excused from liability if they were acting in self-defense to protect themselves or others from harm.
Force Majeure (Надзвичайна ситуація): A defendant may be excused from liability if the damage was caused by an unforeseen and unavoidable event, such as a natural disaster.
Contributory Negligence (Спільна вина): If the plaintiff's own negligence contributed to the damage, their compensation may be reduced.
Recent Developments in Tort Law in Ukraine
Environmental Protection: Ukraine is increasingly focusing on environmental protection laws, and claims related to environmental damage (such as pollution or ecological harm) are becoming more common in Ukrainian tort law.
Consumer Protection: Tort claims related to product liability and consumer protection are also gaining importance in Ukraine. The Law on Consumer Protection has been adapted to allow for tort claims in cases of defective products causing harm to consumers.
Constitutional Torts: With the Constitution of Ukraine protecting fundamental rights (such as the right to life, personal freedom, and dignity), there has been an increased focus on constitutional torts, especially related to the unlawful actions of government authorities.
Conclusion
Tort law in Ukraine is based on the Civil Code of Ukraine and follows the civil law tradition. It covers a wide range of wrongful acts, including negligence, defamation, trespass, nuisance, and strict liability. Victims of torts can seek material damages and moral damages. Environmental torts are becoming more prominent, and consumer protection laws are also evolving to allow for tort claims.
RELATED Blog
0 comments