Tort law at Portugal
Tort law in Portugal is primarily governed by the Civil Code of 1966, particularly the provisions under Book III, which deals with obligations and civil liability. The structure of tort law in Portugal is influenced by continental European legal traditions, with a strong emphasis on civil law principles.
Here’s an overview of the key elements of tort law in Portugal:
1. General Principles of Tort Law in Portugal
Tort law in Portugal addresses civil wrongs that cause harm to a person’s physical integrity, property, or rights. The core principle in Portuguese tort law is that anyone who causes harm to another, either intentionally or negligently, should compensate the injured party for the damages caused.
2. Sources of Tort Law
Portuguese Civil Code (Código Civil): The primary source of tort law in Portugal.
Case Law: Portuguese courts interpret and apply the Civil Code, and judicial decisions help refine the law in practice.
European Union Law: As a member state of the EU, Portuguese law also incorporates European legal principles, especially concerning consumer protection and environmental harm.
3. Types of Torts in Portugal
A. Civil Liability (Responsabilidade Civil)
Portuguese tort law revolves around civil liability, which is the obligation to repair the damage caused by unlawful acts. This can be either contractual or extracontractual (non-contractual), the latter being the most relevant for torts.
B. Non-Contractual Liability (Responsabilidade Extracontratual)
This is the core of tort law in Portugal and refers to situations where a party causes harm to another outside of any contractual relationship. There are several categories of non-contractual liability:
Fault-based Liability (Responsabilidade por Culpa)
Negligence: Liability arises when an individual causes harm to another by failing to exercise reasonable care.
Intentional Acts: Liability is imposed for intentional wrongdoing (e.g., assault, defamation).
The injured party must prove that the defendant was at fault, and that the fault caused the harm.
Strict Liability (Responsabilidade Objetiva)
In some cases, a person can be held liable even without fault (e.g., in the case of certain dangerous activities or accidents involving animals).
For example, the use of certain machinery, or harm caused by defective products, can trigger strict liability.
C. Harm to Property
Liability for damage caused to someone else's property is a key component of tort law in Portugal. This includes trespass, vandalism, or any other form of interference with someone’s rights to enjoy their property.
D. Defamation
Defamation in Portugal involves both libel (written defamation) and slander (spoken defamation). If someone’s reputation is harmed by a false statement, they may sue for damages.
E. Nuisance
Nuisance in Portugal generally falls under the category of disturbance of rights, where harm is caused by interference with a person’s enjoyment of their property, often caused by noise, pollution, or other disruptive activities.
4. Key Legal Elements in Tort Liability
To successfully claim damages under tort law in Portugal, the injured party must generally prove the following:
Unlawful Act: The defendant must have committed an unlawful act (whether through negligence, intentional conduct, or strict liability).
Causation: The defendant's conduct must have directly caused the harm or damage suffered by the plaintiff.
Damage: There must be real, tangible damage. This can include physical injury, property damage, or non-material damage (e.g., emotional distress).
Fault or Responsibility: The defendant must either be at fault or, in some cases, strictly liable for the harm.
5. Remedies in Tort Law
In tort cases, the primary remedy is compensation (usually in the form of monetary damages), which aims to restore the injured party to the position they would have been in had the harm not occurred.
Possible remedies include:
Actual damages: Compensation for loss or harm.
Moral damages: Compensation for non-material damages, such as emotional distress or harm to reputation.
Punitive damages: While rare in civil law systems, punitive damages can be awarded in exceptional cases, especially if the defendant's behavior was extremely reckless or harmful.
6. Statute of Limitations
In Portugal, claims for torts generally have a limitation period of 3 years from the date of the damage or the moment it is discovered. However, the period can vary depending on the nature of the tort.
7. Consumer Protection and Tort Law
Portugal is bound by European Union consumer protection laws, which sometimes provide additional remedies for consumers who suffer harm from defective products or services. For instance, the Directive on Product Liability (85/374/EEC) imposes strict liability on manufacturers for harm caused by defective products.
8. Case Law and Judicial Precedents
Portuguese courts have developed a body of case law that influences the application of tort law. For example, the Supreme Court of Justice (Supremo Tribunal de Justiça) has issued important rulings that clarify concepts of fault and causation in tort claims.
9. Challenges in Tort Law
Proving Fault: In fault-based liability, the burden of proof can be challenging, especially in cases involving negligence.
Compensation: While damages are a key remedy, the calculation of fair compensation, especially for non-material damage, can be subjective.
Delay in Proceedings: The Portuguese legal system can sometimes suffer from delays in civil litigation, making timely compensation challenging.
RELATED Blog
0 comments