Inevitable Accident: A Defence against Torts
Inevitable Accident: A Defence Against Torts
What is Inevitable Accident?
An Inevitable Accident occurs when an injury or damage happens without any fault or negligence on the part of the defendant and could not have been prevented by any amount of care, skill, or foresight. It means that despite taking all reasonable precautions, the accident was unavoidable.
In tort law, if the defendant successfully proves that the injury was caused by an inevitable accident, then the defendant is not liable for the damage or harm caused. This is a complete defense.
Key Characteristics of Inevitable Accident:
No Negligence or Fault:
The defendant did everything reasonably possible to prevent the accident.
Unavoidable Event:
The accident happened due to circumstances beyond anyone's control.
No Breach of Duty:
The defendant did not breach any duty of care owed to the plaintiff.
Accident Must Be Truly Inevitable:
The event could not have been foreseen or guarded against.
Explanation with an Example
Suppose a driver loses control of their vehicle because a sudden, unforeseeable mechanical failure occurs—like the steering suddenly breaking down despite regular maintenance. If this leads to an accident, the driver may claim inevitable accident as a defense because the accident was not caused by negligence but by an unforeseeable event.
Case Law Illustration:
Ashby v. White (Simplified Explanation for Inevitable Accident Concept)
(This is an example, but will explain the principle in terms of accident and fault)
In this case, the defendant was held liable for damages because the injury occurred due to negligence.
Contrast this with a situation where the defendant had done all they could to avoid the injury, but the injury happened due to a sudden, unavoidable cause (like an accident caused by a natural calamity), the defense of inevitable accident would apply.
Actual case illustrating inevitable accident:
Cases Illustrating Inevitable Accident
1. Scott v. Shepherd (1773)
In this case, the defendant threw a firecracker into a crowded market which led to injury.
The court discussed whether the defendant was liable when the injury was indirectly caused.
If the defendant had no control over the chain of events or had taken all precautions, the defense of inevitable accident could apply.
2. Harvey v. The Minister of Transport (Hypothetical explanation)
Suppose a driver’s vehicle suffers an unforeseeable mechanical failure despite regular servicing.
If an accident occurs and the driver took all possible care, this is an inevitable accident.
The driver will not be liable for damages caused.
When is Inevitable Accident NOT a Valid Defense?
If the accident occurred due to negligence, carelessness, or breach of duty.
If the defendant failed to take reasonable precautions.
If the event was foreseeable and preventable.
Summary Table:
| Element | Description |
|---|---|
| Fault or Negligence | None; defendant exercised reasonable care and skill. |
| Nature of Accident | Unavoidable, unforeseen event beyond anyone’s control. |
| Liability | No liability on defendant; complete defense in tort. |
| Example | Mechanical failure despite regular maintenance. |
Conclusion
Inevitable accident is a complete defense in tort law that protects a defendant from liability when an accident causing injury or damage could not have been avoided despite reasonable care and foresight.
The defendant must show that the accident was truly unavoidable and not due to any fault or negligence on their part.
RELATED Blog
0 comments