Tort law at Costa Rica
Tort law at Costa RicaTort law in Costa Rica is governed primarily by the Civil Code (Código Civil de Costa Rica), which was adopted in 1888 and is still in effect, with some amendments over time. The Civil Code provides the foundation for both contractual and non-contractual (tort) liability, alongside specialized laws like the Consumer Protection Law and Environmental Law that impact tort claims in specific contexts.
In Costa Rica, tort law follows a civil law system, influenced by Spanish law, and focuses on providing compensation to victims of wrongful acts and ensuring liability for harm caused by another's actions.
Here’s a comprehensive overview of tort law in Costa Rica:
Key Legal Framework
The main legal provisions for torts in Costa Rica are found in Book 4 of the Civil Code, which deals with obligations (particularly the delictual (tort) obligations). Article 1054 of the Civil Code specifically governs civil liability for torts, and other related provisions further clarify the rules for different types of damages.
Article 1054: "The one who causes harm to another by an act or omission in breach of an obligation or the law is obligated to compensate for the damage."
This provision is the cornerstone of tort law in Costa Rica, establishing that anyone who causes harm to another person must provide compensation for the damage, whether the harm was caused by negligence or intentional actions.
Key Elements of Tort Liability
To establish a tort claim under Costa Rican law, three fundamental elements must be proven:
Unlawful Act (Illicit Act or Fault)
There must be an unlawful act or omission, such as negligence, intentional wrongdoing, or failure to meet a legal duty.
For example, if a person is injured by a defective product, the manufacturer may be held liable for failing to ensure the safety of the product.
Causation
There must be a direct link (causal relationship) between the wrongful act and the damage suffered.
If the act or omission is not the direct cause of the harm, there is no liability.
Damage
The victim must have suffered actual harm (material or moral damage).
Damages can include physical injury, property damage, or psychological harm (e.g., emotional distress or reputational harm).
Types of Torts in Costa Rica
Tort law in Costa Rica covers a broad range of acts and omissions, including:
Negligence (Negligencia)
When a person fails to exercise reasonable care, leading to harm to another person or their property.
Examples: A driver causes an accident because of reckless driving, or a property owner fails to maintain a safe environment, leading to injury.
Defamation (Difamación)
This involves making false statements about another person that harm their reputation.
Both slander (oral defamation) and libel (written defamation) are recognized as torts under Costa Rican law.
Trespass (Allanamiento)
Unauthorized entry onto another person’s property or interfering with their right to possess property.
This can include physical trespass as well as nuisance claims (e.g., disturbing another's peaceful enjoyment of their property).
Battery and Assault (Lesiones y Agresión)
Battery refers to physical harm inflicted on someone, while assault involves the threat of harm or an attempt to cause harm.
Product Liability (Responsabilidad por Productos)
Manufacturers, distributors, and sellers can be held liable for defects in products that cause harm to consumers.
Costa Rica has enacted specific consumer protection laws (such as the Consumer Protection Law, Law No. 7472) that address product liability.
Medical Malpractice (Responsabilidad Médica)
Healthcare professionals and institutions may be liable for harm caused by negligence or failure to provide the expected standard of care.
Environmental Damage (Dano Ambiental)
Environmental torts can arise from activities that harm the environment or public health.
Costa Rica is highly protective of the environment, and tort law may be invoked for actions that harm the environment, such as illegal deforestation, pollution, or damage to protected areas.
Damages in Costa Rican Tort Law
The damages awarded in tort claims in Costa Rica are generally categorized into two types:
Compensatory Damages (Daños y Perjuicios)
These damages are meant to compensate the victim for actual losses, including:
Material damages: Direct financial losses, medical costs, repair costs, etc.
Moral damages: Non-material harm, such as pain and suffering, emotional distress, or reputational damage.
Punitive Damages (Daños Punitivos)
Costa Rican law traditionally does not recognize punitive damages in the same way as common law jurisdictions, where the aim is to punish the wrongdoer.
However, courts may award higher moral damages in cases where the defendant’s conduct was particularly egregious or malicious (e.g., intentional harm or gross negligence).
Defenses to Tort Liability
Several defenses can be used by the defendant in tort cases in Costa Rica:
Consent
If the injured party consented to the act that caused harm, such as in the case of a contact sport or medical treatment, consent may serve as a defense.
Contributory Negligence
If the plaintiff contributed to their own harm through negligence, the damages may be reduced or eliminated depending on the degree of fault.
Justification
Some acts may be justified under the law, such as self-defense or actions taken to protect others or property.
Force Majeure (Fuerza Mayor)
Unforeseeable events or natural disasters (e.g., earthquakes, hurricanes) that make it impossible to prevent harm may absolve liability in certain situations.
Statute of Limitations
The general statute of limitations for tort claims in Costa Rica is three years, beginning from the date the injured party becomes aware of the damage and the identity of the person responsible. For certain types of claims, different limitation periods may apply, such as:
Five years for personal injury claims.
One year for defamation claims.
Example of Tort Case in Costa Rica
Case: Medical Malpractice
A patient undergoes a routine surgery at a hospital in Costa Rica. Due to negligence by the surgeon, the patient suffers serious complications that were preventable with proper care. The patient sues the hospital for medical malpractice under the Civil Code’s tort provisions, claiming material damages (medical bills, lost wages) and moral damages (pain and suffering).
Conclusion
Tort law in Costa Rica follows the general principles of civil law and is largely influenced by Spanish and French legal traditions, with a focus on compensating victims for harm caused by unlawful acts. Key elements in a tort claim include the unlawfulness of the act, fault, causation, and damages. Negligence, defamation, product liability, and environmental damage are some of the main areas of tort law in the country.
Costa Rican tort law ensures that victims can seek redress for personal injury, property damage, and moral harm, but also provides for several defenses, such as contributory negligence and consent.
RELATED Blog
0 comments