Property Law in Western Sahara
Property Law in Western Sahara is complex due to the region's unique and politically sensitive status. The territory is largely disputed, with Morocco and the Polisario Front both claiming sovereignty over the region. Western Sahara is considered a non-self-governing territory by the United Nations (UN), and its legal framework for property ownership is influenced by the political situation.
1. Political Status and Legal Context
Western Sahara is a disputed region, with two main political entities involved:
Moroccan Control: Morocco controls most of Western Sahara, including its urban areas and resources. Morocco has applied its national laws, including property laws, in the areas it administers.
Polisario Front: The Polisario Front, which claims independence for the region, controls the Tindouf camps in Algeria, where refugees from Western Sahara live. The Polisario Front advocates for self-determination and has declared the Sahrawi Arab Democratic Republic (SADR) as the legitimate government of Western Sahara.
The UN's position is that Western Sahara is a non-self-governing territory, and its future should be determined through a referendum on self-determination, which has not been held yet. This political uncertainty significantly affects the property rights in the region.
2. Land Ownership under Moroccan Law
In areas controlled by Morocco, Moroccan law governs property rights. Under Moroccan law, land ownership and real estate transactions are primarily regulated by:
- The Moroccan Civil Code (Dahir No. 1-74-447 of 1974) governs property transactions and ownership, including land use, leases, and mortgages.
- Land Ownership: In Morocco, land ownership can be private or state-owned. Private property can be bought and sold, while state land is controlled by the government, and access to it may be limited.
For Western Sahara, Moroccan authorities have implemented Moroccan property laws, including granting land ownership to both Moroccan citizens and foreign investors in the region. In practice, this has led to the settlement of Moroccan nationals in the disputed areas and the development of infrastructure and natural resources.
3. Land Ownership under Polisario Front Control
In areas controlled by the Polisario Front (primarily the Tindouf refugee camps), the legal framework is less formalized and largely based on customary law and SADR declarations. The Polisario Front has declared sovereignty over Western Sahara, and its government administers land under its control according to principles of collective ownership and resource management.
The Sahrawi Arab Democratic Republic (SADR), proclaimed by the Polisario Front, has not been internationally recognized as a sovereign state. As such, land rights in these areas are based on the policies of the Polisario and are influenced by the broader national aspirations for self-determination. Property rights in these areas are often related to land use and collective land ownership rather than individual private ownership.
4. Land Ownership for Foreigners
In Moroccan-controlled areas of Western Sahara, the Moroccan government has encouraged foreign investment, particularly in mining, agriculture, and real estate. Foreigners are allowed to buy and develop property under certain conditions, similar to Morocco's general investment laws.
However, foreign ownership of property in Polisario-controlled areas is more complicated, as the region is not internationally recognized as a sovereign state. The Polisario Front generally advocates for land as a collective resource, and property ownership is not as formalized as in Moroccan-controlled areas.
5. Real Estate Transactions
In Moroccan-Controlled Areas: Real estate transactions in Moroccan-controlled Western Sahara follow the processes established by Moroccan law. This includes property sales, leases, and development rights, all of which are regulated under Moroccan civil law. Transactions must be registered with the Moroccan land registry to be valid, and a notary's involvement is required for many property transactions.
In Polisario-Controlled Areas: The legal framework for real estate transactions in Polisario-controlled areas is more informal and centered around customary land use practices. Property rights are often granted on a communal or collective basis, and any formal transfer of land or property is less developed than in Morocco.
6. Land Disputes
Land disputes in Western Sahara are common due to the territorial conflict between Morocco and the Polisario Front. Key issues include:
Moroccan Settlers vs. Indigenous Sahrawis: Moroccan settlers, who have been encouraged to move to Western Sahara by the Moroccan government, often face disputes with the indigenous Sahrawi people, who claim that these settlements are illegal and violate their right to self-determination.
Land Expropriation and Resettlement: There have been cases of land being expropriated by the Moroccan government for various projects, including resource extraction and infrastructure development, often leading to protests and calls for compensation from local Sahrawis.
Resource Extraction: The extraction of natural resources in Western Sahara, particularly phosphates and fisheries, has led to disputes between Morocco and the Polisario Front. The exploitation of these resources is controversial, with Morocco arguing that it has the right to develop the region's resources and the Polisario Front asserting that such activities are illegal under international law.
7. Expropriation and Eminent Domain
Expropriation in Moroccan-controlled Western Sahara follows Moroccan laws, under which the government can take land for public purposes (e.g., infrastructure, development). Compensation is generally provided, but the process can be contentious, particularly when it involves land owned or used by Sahrawi people.
In Polisario-controlled areas, there is no formal expropriation mechanism, as land is collectively managed according to the principles of the Polisario Front. Land use is generally governed by the needs of the community and the ongoing struggle for self-determination.
8. International Law and Property Rights
The status of Western Sahara is a subject of significant international debate. The United Nations recognizes the right of the Sahrawi people to self-determination, which includes the right to determine the status of their land and resources. The International Court of Justice (ICJ) has issued advisory opinions stating that Morocco does not have sovereignty over Western Sahara and that the people of Western Sahara should determine their own political status.
As a result, any property rights in Western Sahara, especially those concerning the exploitation of natural resources or land claims in the region, remain highly contentious and are often seen as illegitimate under international law by some parties, particularly the Polisario Front and its supporters.
9. Property in the Context of the Conflict
The ongoing conflict significantly impacts property law in the region. Land ownership, development, and resource exploitation are often intertwined with political claims and the broader struggle for independence. Any property transactions or developments that take place are likely to be viewed through a political lens, and these activities may be contested by one side or the other.
Conclusion
Property law in Western Sahara is shaped by the ongoing territorial conflict between Morocco and the Polisario Front. In Moroccan-controlled areas, property laws are largely governed by Moroccan civil law, with the state encouraging settlement and development. In contrast, in Polisario-controlled areas, customary law governs property, and formal land ownership structures are less developed. The political status of the region remains unresolved, and the property rights of the Sahrawi people are a key issue in the broader conflict. Until a resolution is reached on the territory’s status, property law in Western Sahara will continue to be influenced by this complex political and legal environment.
RELATED Blog
0 comments