Plea of Alibi in Evidence Act
Plea of Alibi in Indian Evidence Law
What is a Plea of Alibi?
The plea of alibi is a defense taken by an accused in a criminal trial, claiming that they were somewhere else (at a different place) at the time the alleged crime was committed and therefore could not have committed the offense.
The word "alibi" means "elsewhere" in Latin.
Legal Position of Plea of Alibi
The plea of alibi is a fact raised by the accused.
It is not just a mere denial of the charge but an assertion of an affirmative fact that, if proved, excludes the possibility of the accused being at the scene of the crime.
It is a form of negative defense — the accused denies the fact of being at the place of crime.
Burden of Proof in Alibi
The burden of proving the guilt of the accused lies upon the prosecution beyond reasonable doubt (Section 101 of the Indian Evidence Act).
When the accused raises the plea of alibi, the burden shifts to the accused to make out a prima facie case or produce some evidence to support the alibi.
However, the ultimate burden remains on the prosecution to prove the guilt of the accused beyond reasonable doubt.
The accused need not prove the alibi beyond reasonable doubt; he only needs to raise a reasonable doubt about his presence at the crime scene.
Plea of Alibi under the Indian Evidence Act
While the Indian Evidence Act does not explicitly mention "alibi" in a single section, the general principles of evidence apply:
Section 101: Burden of proof lies on the prosecution.
Section 102: Burden of proving fact especially within the knowledge of the accused.
Section 103: On whom burden lies when facts are especially within the knowledge of any person.
The plea of alibi usually relies on documentary evidence, witness testimony, or any other corroborative evidence to establish the accused’s presence elsewhere at the material time.
Important Points Regarding Plea of Alibi:
Must be supported by evidence: A mere assertion without evidence does not create doubt.
Corroboration needed: Independent corroborative evidence (e.g., witnesses, receipts, CCTV footage) strengthens the alibi.
Relevance and credibility: The alibi evidence is tested for credibility; contradictions may weaken it.
Not a complete defense if disproved: If the prosecution successfully disproves the alibi, the accused can still be convicted.
Key Case Laws on Plea of Alibi
1. Shivaji Sahabrao Bobade v. State of Maharashtra (1973) AIR 185
Facts: The accused raised an alibi, claiming to be elsewhere during the crime.
Held: The Supreme Court held that when an accused raises an alibi, the prosecution has to disprove the alibi beyond reasonable doubt. If the prosecution fails to disprove the alibi, the accused is entitled to acquittal.
Principle: The plea of alibi, if proved or not disproved, creates a reasonable doubt and benefits the accused.
2. Suresh v. State of Haryana (2007) 2 SCC 536
Held: The Court observed that when an alibi is raised, it is for the accused to make out a prima facie case by adducing some evidence to show that he was not present at the crime scene.
The prosecution then has to disprove the alibi by evidence to secure conviction.
3. Hussainara Khatoon v. State of Bihar (1979) AIR 1369
Emphasized the importance of raising a reasonable doubt through alibi evidence.
If the alibi evidence is credible and not disproved, the accused should be acquitted.
4. Ram Narain v. State of Uttar Pradesh (1969) AIR 1286
The Supreme Court stated that the alibi plea is generally regarded as the strongest of all defenses, and courts must scrutinize the prosecution evidence carefully when such plea is raised.
Summary of Legal Principles on Plea of Alibi
| Aspect | Explanation |
|---|---|
| What is it? | Claim that accused was elsewhere at time of crime |
| Burden of proof | Initially on prosecution, but accused must produce some evidence supporting alibi |
| Effect if alibi is true | Creates reasonable doubt → accused entitled to acquittal |
| Evidence required | Witness testimony, documents, records, CCTV, etc. |
| Prosecution’s duty | To disprove alibi beyond reasonable doubt |
| Legal position | Strong defense, scrutinized closely by courts |
Conclusion:
The plea of alibi is a vital defense in criminal law that can exonerate the accused if properly established or not effectively rebutted by the prosecution. It requires presenting evidence that the accused was at a different place than the crime scene at the relevant time, thereby creating reasonable doubt about their involvement.
RELATED Blog
0 comments