Admissions and Confessions in Evidence Act
Admissions and Confessions in Evidence Law
Overview
Admissions and confessions are key concepts in the law of evidence, particularly in criminal and civil proceedings. They are statements made by parties involved that can be used to prove the truth of the matters asserted.
1. Admissions
Definition:
An admission is a statement, oral or written, made by a party to a case which is against their own interest and is relevant to the case. It does not necessarily imply guilt, especially in civil matters.
Admissions can be express (explicit statements) or implied (conduct suggesting acknowledgment).
Admissions may relate to facts, intentions, opinions, or knowledge.
Generally, admissions are not conclusive evidence but are prima facie evidence against the person making them.
Legal Position:
Admissions are admissible in evidence against the person making them.
They need not be made voluntarily or be against penal interest.
They help to prove facts in dispute.
Example:
In a contract dispute, if one party admits the existence of a contract, that admission can be used to establish part of the case.
2. Confessions
Definition:
A confession is a specific type of admission where an accused person admits to having committed a crime, fully or partly.
A confession is voluntary statement acknowledging guilt.
It must be made without coercion, inducement, threat, or promise.
Confessions have a stronger probative value than admissions because they relate directly to the guilt of the accused.
Legal Position:
Confessions are admissible as evidence against the accused.
If a confession is obtained by coercion, threat, or promise, it is inadmissible.
The court must ensure the confession was made voluntarily before it can be used.
Key Differences Between Admission and Confession
| Feature | Admission | Confession |
|---|---|---|
| Definition | Statement against interest in civil or criminal case | Statement admitting guilt in a criminal case |
| Requires Voluntariness | Not necessarily voluntary | Must be voluntary |
| Relation to Crime | May or may not relate to crime | Always relates to crime |
| Effect | Prima facie evidence | Strong evidence of guilt |
Relevant Sections of Evidence Act (Example: Indian Evidence Act, 1872)
Section 17: Confession
Section 18: Confession to police officer
Section 19: Confession made after arrest
Section 21: Admissions by party to proceeding or agent
Section 23: Admissions as to matters of common intention
Important Case Law
1. R v. Bedingfield (1879) 13 Cox CC 239
Principle: For a confession to be admissible, it must be voluntarily made.
Significance: The court held that any confession made under threat, coercion, or inducement is inadmissible.
2. King Emperor v. Raghubir Singh AIR 1932 PC 147
Principle: Confession made by an accused is admissible only if it is voluntary.
Significance: Established that even slight inducements or promises may render a confession inadmissible.
3. Narayan Govind Patil v. The State of Maharashtra (1981)
Principle: An admission made by a party is admissible even if made in ignorance or under a mistake.
Significance: Admission need not be deliberate or intentional to be admissible.
4. R v. Ibrahim (1914)
Principle: Confession made to a police officer is generally inadmissible.
Significance: Protects accused from coercion by police during interrogation.
Important Judicial Principles
Voluntariness: Confession must be free from threats, promises, or coercion.
Corroboration: Confession alone, especially if made to police, is insufficient; corroborative evidence is preferred.
Right to Silence: No person can be compelled to confess.
Admissions vs. Evidence: Admissions can be used in civil and criminal cases; confessions relate mainly to criminal guilt.
Practical Implications
Courts scrutinize the circumstances under which admissions and confessions are made.
Improperly obtained confessions can lead to miscarriage of justice.
Legal safeguards exist to protect accused persons against abuse.
Summary
Admission is a statement adverse to the party making it, admissible as evidence.
Confession is an admission of guilt in a criminal case, admissible only if voluntary.
Courts require confessions to be voluntary to prevent coercion.
The Evidence Act outlines when and how these statements can be admitted.
Case law has developed clear rules on the admissibility and weight of admissions and confessions.
RELATED Blog
0 comments