MARITAL RAPE – THE REALITY BEHIND THE CURTAIN OF MARRIAGE
Marital Rape – The Reality Behind the Curtain of Marriage
🔹 What is Marital Rape?
Marital Rape refers to non-consensual sexual intercourse by a husband with his wife without her consent. It challenges the traditional legal and social notion that marriage implies irrevocable consent to sexual relations.
🔹 Historical & Social Context
Historically, many legal systems operated under the "marital rape exemption", which presumed that a wife had given irrevocable consent to sexual intercourse upon marriage. This belief stems from patriarchal norms where wives were considered the property of their husbands.
The 19th-century British legal scholar Sir Matthew Hale famously stated that by marriage, a woman gave herself in irrevocable consent to her husband.
This doctrine was inherited by many legal systems, including India’s.
🔹 Legal Recognition and Debate
The recognition of marital rape as a crime varies worldwide. Some countries criminalize it, while others still exempt marital rape from their penal laws.
🔹 Marital Rape in Indian Law
Section 375 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) defines rape.
However, Exception 2 to Section 375 IPC states: "Sexual intercourse or sexual acts by a man with his own wife, the wife not being under fifteen years of age, is not rape."
This effectively exempts marital rape from prosecution if the wife is above 15 years.
🔹 Arguments Against Criminalizing Marital Rape in India
Marriage is a consensual contract involving mutual rights and duties.
Criminalizing marital rape may be misused in domestic disputes.
It is difficult to prove non-consent in a marital relationship.
🔹 Arguments For Criminalizing Marital Rape
It violates a woman’s bodily autonomy and dignity.
Consent is necessary irrespective of marital status.
Protects women from abuse and sexual violence within marriage.
Aligns with international human rights standards.
🔹 Important Case Laws and Judgments
1. Independent Thought v. Union of India (2017) – Supreme Court of India
Issue: Raised the minimum age of marriage for girls from 15 to 18 years.
Significance: Narrowed the scope of Exception 2 to Section 375 IPC by raising the age limit.
Outcome: Sexual intercourse with a wife under 18 years is now rape.
2. Rathinam v. Union of India (1994) – Madras High Court
Issue: Whether consent is necessary for sexual intercourse in marriage.
Held: The court controversially held that a wife cannot be raped by her husband, implying no marital rape.
Significance: Reinforced marital rape exemption at the time (later criticized and overturned in other jurisdictions).
3. D Velusamy v. D Patchaiammal (2010) – Supreme Court of India
Issue: Protection of women against domestic violence.
Held: Highlighted the importance of bodily integrity and privacy within marriage.
Significance: Supported wider interpretation of women's rights within marriage but did not directly address marital rape.
4. Brittany Levens v. John Levens (US, 2018)
Context: Illustrates criminal prosecution of marital rape in jurisdictions that recognize it.
Significance: Demonstrates global shift towards criminalizing marital rape.
🔹 International Perspective
The United Nations and other international bodies recognize marital rape as a human rights violation.
The Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women (CEDAW) calls for the criminalization of marital rape.
Countries like the UK, Australia, Canada, South Africa, and several others have criminalized marital rape.
🔹 Social and Psychological Reality
Many survivors face stigma, shame, and lack of support.
Marital rape often remains unreported due to fear of social ostracism or economic dependency.
It has severe psychological impacts including trauma, depression, and PTSD.
🔹 Challenges in Addressing Marital Rape
Lack of clear legal provisions criminalizing marital rape in some countries.
Difficulty in proving lack of consent in the marital context.
Deep-rooted patriarchal attitudes and cultural beliefs.
Police and judiciary may lack sensitivity in handling such cases.
🔹 The Way Forward
Legal Reform: Amend laws to remove marital rape exemptions.
Awareness: Educate society about consent within marriage.
Support Systems: Strengthen support for survivors (helplines, counseling).
Judicial Sensitization: Train law enforcement and judiciary to handle such cases fairly.
International Pressure: Align domestic laws with global human rights standards.
🔹 Conclusion
Marital rape is a hidden violation of human rights cloaked in the sanctity of marriage. It is imperative that legal systems and societies recognize sexual autonomy and consent within marriage to protect individuals, especially women, from abuse.
RELATED Blog
0 comments