Instant Payment System Anomalies .

INSTANT PAYMENT SYSTEM ANOMALIES – DETAILED EXPLANATION WITH CASE LAWS

Spanish Banking Law, EU Payment Services Regulation and Financial Technology Compliance

1. Introduction

Instant Payment System Anomalies refer to unusual, irregular, suspicious or technically incorrect activities occurring during the processing, transmission, authorisation, settlement or completion of instant electronic payment transactions.

Instant payment systems allow customers to transfer funds between bank accounts within seconds, generally operating continuously, including weekends and public holidays.

Unlike traditional bank transfers, instant payment systems require financial institutions to process transactions within very short timeframes. This creates particular challenges involving fraud detection, cybersecurity, transaction monitoring, operational resilience and consumer protection.

In Spain, instant payments are particularly relevant to banks, electronic money institutions, payment service providers (PSPs), fintech companies and digital banking platforms.

Instant payment anomalies may include:

Unauthorised instant transfers.

Duplicate payment transactions.

Incorrect beneficiary information.

Suspicious transaction patterns.

Account takeover fraud.

Manipulation of payment instructions.

Technical settlement failures.

Money laundering through rapid transfers.

Fraudulent payment confirmations.

System outages and processing errors.

The legal framework governing these matters includes Spanish banking legislation, EU payment services legislation, the SEPA payment framework, data protection requirements and cybersecurity regulations.

2. Legal Framework Governing Instant Payments in Spain

A. Regulation (EU) 2024/886 – Instant Payments Regulation

Regulation (EU) 2024/886 amended the existing SEPA regulatory framework to promote instant euro credit transfers.

Its principal objectives include:

Increasing the availability of instant euro payments.

Improving payment accessibility.

Ensuring transparent pricing.

Strengthening fraud prevention.

Introducing verification of payee requirements.

Improving consumer confidence in instant payments.

The Regulation introduced obligations for payment service providers concerning the sending and receiving of instant credit transfers in euro.

It also introduced verification of payee requirements, which help customers establish whether the beneficiary name corresponds to the supplied account identifier.

The Regulation provides an important legal foundation for addressing payment anomalies arising from incorrect beneficiary details and fraudulent payment instructions.

B. Directive (EU) 2015/2366 – Payment Services Directive 2 (PSD2)

PSD2 establishes the principal EU framework governing payment services.

Important provisions include:

Article 64: Consent and withdrawal of consent for payment transactions.

Article 72: Evidence on authentication and execution of payment transactions.

Article 73: Payment service provider liability for unauthorised payment transactions.

Article 74: Payer liability for unauthorised payment transactions.

Article 89: Liability for non-execution, defective or late execution of payment transactions.

Article 97: Strong customer authentication requirements.

Article 98: Regulatory technical standards concerning strong customer authentication and secure communication.

These provisions are important when instant payment anomalies involve unauthorised transactions, defective execution or inadequate authentication.

C. Spanish Royal Decree-Law 19/2018

Royal Decree-Law 19/2018 on payment services and other urgent financial measures implements the PSD2 framework in Spain.

It establishes obligations concerning:

Authorisation of payment transactions.

Payment service provider liability.

Customer authentication.

Execution of payment orders.

Refunds for unauthorised transactions.

Customer complaints and dispute resolution.

Spanish payment institutions must comply with the applicable statutory obligations when handling instant payment irregularities.

D. Regulation (EU) 2022/2554 – Digital Operational Resilience Act (DORA)

DORA establishes operational resilience requirements for financial entities.

It addresses:

ICT risk management.

Cybersecurity incidents.

Operational continuity.

ICT third-party risk.

Incident classification and reporting.

Resilience testing.

Management accountability.

Instant payment systems are particularly exposed to operational and technological risks because they operate continuously and require rapid transaction processing.

E. Regulation (EU) 2016/679 – General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR)

GDPR becomes relevant when instant payment anomalies involve personal data breaches, unauthorised access to customer information or unlawful processing of transaction data.

Articles 5, 24, 32, 33 and 34 are particularly relevant.

3. Types of Instant Payment System Anomalies

A. Unauthorised Payment Transactions

An unauthorised transaction occurs when money is transferred without valid consent from the account holder.

Examples include:

Stolen banking credentials.

Account takeover.

Compromised mobile banking applications.

Fraudulent authentication.

Malware-based payment manipulation.

Under PSD2 and Spanish implementing legislation, the payment service provider generally bears responsibility for refunding unauthorised transactions, subject to the applicable statutory exceptions.

B. Duplicate Payment Transactions

Duplicate payments occur when the same payment instruction is processed more than once.

Example:

A customer initiates a transfer of €5,000. Due to a technical processing error, the system executes the payment twice.

The customer suffers a financial loss of €5,000.

The bank must investigate the processing records, transaction identifiers and settlement information to establish the cause.

C. Incorrect Beneficiary Payments

An instant transfer may be sent to an unintended beneficiary because of incorrect account details or manipulation of payment information.

Such cases may involve:

Customer input errors.

Fraudulent substitution of beneficiary details.

Invoice redirection fraud.

Incorrect beneficiary identification.

The legal consequences depend on whether the payment was authorised, whether the payment was executed according to the supplied identifier and whether the bank complied with applicable verification and execution requirements.

D. Account Takeover Fraud

Account takeover occurs when criminals obtain control of a customer's banking account and initiate fraudulent instant transfers.

Common techniques include:

Phishing.

SIM swapping.

Credential theft.

Social engineering.

Malware.

Compromised devices.

Financial institutions must maintain appropriate authentication and fraud-monitoring mechanisms.

E. Transaction Velocity Anomalies

Transaction velocity anomalies occur when an account suddenly initiates numerous transfers within a short period.

For example:

An account normally making two transfers per week suddenly initiates 30 instant payments within ten minutes.

This may indicate account compromise, money laundering or fraudulent activity.

However, unusual transaction frequency does not automatically establish criminal conduct.

F. Payment Routing Anomalies

Routing anomalies occur when payment instructions are transmitted through incorrect, unexpected or unauthorised payment channels.

Possible causes include:

Technical routing errors.

Payment gateway manipulation.

Intermediary bank failures.

Incorrect payment configuration.

Cyberattacks.

G. Settlement Failures

Instant payment systems depend on rapid settlement arrangements.

Settlement anomalies may arise from:

Insufficient settlement liquidity.

Technical infrastructure failures.

Incorrect settlement messages.

Reconciliation errors.

Connectivity interruptions.

These issues can create financial exposure for payment service providers and participating institutions.

4. Legal Responsibilities of Spanish Banks

Spanish banks and payment service providers have several important legal responsibilities.

A. Authentication of Payment Transactions

Banks must apply strong customer authentication where required under PSD2 and the applicable regulatory technical standards.

Authentication mechanisms may include:

Passwords.

Biometric verification.

One-time authentication codes.

Device-based authentication.

Multi-factor authentication.

B. Fraud Monitoring

Banks should maintain appropriate monitoring systems to identify suspicious payment activity.

Monitoring may consider:

Unusual transaction amounts.

Changes in beneficiary details.

Unexpected transaction frequency.

New device registrations.

Suspicious geographical patterns.

Unusual account access.

Multiple transfers to newly added beneficiaries.

C. Timely Investigation

When a customer reports an unauthorised transaction, the payment service provider must investigate the complaint and apply the relevant statutory refund rules.

D. Operational Security

Banks must implement suitable technological and organisational controls to protect payment systems against operational disruption and cyberattacks.

E. Customer Notification

Where required by applicable law, banks must provide customers with relevant information concerning payment execution, transaction failures and security incidents.

5. Verification of Payee and Instant Payment Fraud

One of the most important developments under Regulation (EU) 2024/886 is the introduction of verification of payee obligations.

Verification of payee is designed to check whether the beneficiary's name corresponds to the account identifier supplied by the payer.

For example:

A customer intends to transfer €10,000 to a Spanish supplier.

However, a fraudster sends an invoice containing a substituted IBAN.

The verification system may identify a mismatch between the beneficiary name and the account holder information.

This gives the payer an opportunity to reconsider the payment before authorising it.

The mechanism is particularly relevant to business email compromise and invoice redirection fraud.

Verification of payee does not guarantee that the beneficiary is trustworthy or eliminate all forms of payment fraud.

6. Money Laundering Risks Associated with Instant Payments

Instant payments can create opportunities for rapid movement of illegally obtained funds.

Criminals may exploit instant payment systems to:

Transfer money between multiple accounts.

Divide large amounts into smaller transactions.

Move funds through intermediary accounts.

Exploit newly opened accounts.

Transfer money across jurisdictions.

Move fraudulent proceeds before detection.

In Spain, the principal AML legislation includes Law 10/2010 on the prevention of money laundering and terrorist financing.

Relevant obligations include:

Customer due diligence.

Identification of beneficial owners.

Ongoing business relationship monitoring.

Detection of suspicious transactions.

Internal AML controls.

Reporting suspicious activity to SEPBLAC, where legally required.

Banks must distinguish between legitimate high-frequency payment activity and transactions that create reasonable grounds for suspicion.

7. Important Case Laws

The following Court of Justice of the European Union and other European authorities are particularly relevant to instant payment anomalies, unauthorised electronic transactions, authentication, banking liability and fraud.

Case 1: C-287/19, DenizBank AG v Verein für Konsumenteninformation (2020)

Legal principle: Payment services, contactless payments and customer consent.

The CJEU examined provisions of PSD2 concerning payment instruments and the regulatory treatment of contactless payment transactions.

Relevance:

The decision helps explain the legal distinction between payment authorisation, consent and the application of payment services rules.

It is relevant when evaluating whether a payment transaction was properly authorised.

Case 2: C-337/20, DM and LR v Banco Santander SA (2022)

Legal principle: Consumer protection and the limitation of liability for unauthorised payment transactions.

The CJEU considered the relationship between payment services legislation and consumer protection requirements.

Relevance:

The decision is useful when analysing the legal treatment of consumer financial disputes and the interaction between payment services rules and consumer rights.

Case 3: C-245/18, Tecnoservice Int. Srl v Poste Italiane SpA (2019)

Legal principle: Execution of payment orders and the use of unique identifiers.

The CJEU considered the consequences of executing a payment order using the unique identifier supplied by the payment service user.

Relevance:

The decision is important when an instant payment reaches an unintended beneficiary because an incorrect account identifier was provided.

It illustrates the importance of distinguishing between an error in the supplied identifier and a failure by the payment service provider to execute the payment correctly.

Case 4: C-409/22, EUROBANK BULGARIA AD (2024)

Legal principle: Payment services and liability arising from disputed transactions.

The case is relevant to the interpretation of payment services obligations and the allocation of responsibility in disputed banking transactions.

Its precise relevance must be assessed against the particular payment anomaly and the applicable statutory provisions.

Case 5: C-245/21, (payment services and consumer protection context)

Legal principle: Interpretation of EU financial services obligations.

EU payment services disputes require careful examination of the applicable statutory text and the precise issue decided by the court.

This reference should not be treated as a specific precedent on instant payment system anomalies without verification of the judgment.

Case 6: C-616/11, T-Mobile Austria GmbH v Verein für Konsumenteninformation (2013)

Legal principle: Consumer protection and electronic payment-related contractual practices.

The case concerns consumer protection within electronic communications and contractual practices rather than instant payment fraud directly.

Its relevance is comparative and limited to broader consumer protection principles.

Important: The strongest directly relevant authorities for instant payment disputes are the CJEU decisions interpreting PSD2, particularly the rules on consent, authentication, execution and unauthorised transactions. The above cases should not be represented as decisions establishing a general rule specifically for instant payment anomalies.

8. Liability for Unauthorised Instant Payments

Under Article 73 of PSD2 and the corresponding Spanish implementation, where a payment transaction is unauthorised, the payer's payment service provider generally must refund the amount of the unauthorised transaction immediately and no later than the end of the following business day after becoming aware of or being notified of the transaction.

There are statutory exceptions, including circumstances involving reasonable grounds to suspect fraud by the payer and notification to the competent national authority.

The payment service provider must also restore the relevant account position as required by law.

Under Article 74, the payer's liability is limited in specified circumstances.

For example, a payer may bear losses up to €50 in certain cases involving the use of a lost, stolen or misappropriated payment instrument, subject to statutory exceptions.

The payer may bear greater losses where the statutory conditions for fraud or intentional or grossly negligent failure to fulfil security obligations are established.

Importantly, merely proving that the correct authentication credentials were used does not necessarily establish that the transaction was authorised or that the customer acted fraudulently.

9. Technical and Operational Anomaly Detection

Spanish financial institutions should implement automated anomaly detection systems.

Important monitoring techniques include:

A. Real-Time Transaction Monitoring

Transactions are analysed while they are being processed.

B. Behavioural Analytics

The system compares current payment behaviour with established customer patterns.

C. Device Fingerprinting

Banks identify unusual devices, login patterns and changes in customer access behaviour.

D. Artificial Intelligence Fraud Detection

Machine-learning systems may identify unusual transaction combinations and suspicious payment behaviour.

E. Duplicate Transaction Detection

Payment systems use transaction identifiers, reconciliation mechanisms and idempotency controls to reduce duplicate processing.

F. Cybersecurity Monitoring

Banks monitor system access, unusual network activity, malware indicators and suspicious API requests.

Automated monitoring must also respect applicable data protection, security and fairness requirements.

10. Regulatory Supervision and Enforcement in Spain

The following authorities and institutions have important roles:

Banco de España

Supervises relevant payment institutions and monitors compliance with applicable banking and payment services requirements within its statutory responsibilities.

SEPBLAC

Receives and analyses suspicious transaction reports under Spain's AML framework.

European Central Bank

Exercises relevant supervisory responsibilities for significant credit institutions within the Single Supervisory Mechanism.

European Banking Authority

Develops regulatory standards and guidelines concerning payment services, authentication and operational risks.

Agencia Española de Protección de Datos (AEPD)

Supervises compliance with applicable personal data protection legislation.

11. Practical Case Study

A customer of a Spanish commercial bank initiates an instant transfer of €8,000 through a mobile banking application.

Within five minutes, three additional transfers of €8,000 are made to different beneficiaries.

The customer subsequently discovers that the mobile banking account was compromised.

The customer immediately reports the transactions to the bank.

Legal analysis:

First, the bank must establish whether the customer authorised the transactions.

Second, it must examine authentication records, device information, transaction timestamps and security logs.

Third, it must assess whether the transactions resulted from credential theft, account takeover or another fraudulent mechanism.

Fourth, the bank must apply the statutory refund rules governing unauthorised transactions.

Fifth, it should investigate whether the unusual transaction pattern should have triggered fraud controls.

Finally, where the circumstances create reasonable suspicion of money laundering or other criminal activity, applicable reporting and escalation requirements must be followed.

The bank cannot automatically reject the customer's claim merely because the transfers were successfully authenticated.

12. Compliance and Risk Management Recommendations

Spanish banks and fintech institutions should implement the following safeguards:

Real-time payment fraud detection.

Strong customer authentication.

Verification of payee.

Continuous transaction monitoring.

Duplicate payment prevention.

Secure API infrastructure.

Device and behavioural monitoring.

Immediate customer fraud-reporting channels.

Effective transaction investigation procedures.

DORA-compliant ICT risk management.

AML transaction monitoring.

Secure payment reconciliation.

Periodic cybersecurity assessments.

Staff training on social engineering fraud.

Transparent customer complaint mechanisms.

13. Conclusion

Instant Payment System Anomalies represent a significant legal, financial and technological challenge for modern banking institutions.

In Spain, instant payment transactions are governed by a combination of EU payment services legislation, Regulation (EU) 2024/886, PSD2, Royal Decree-Law 19/2018, DORA, GDPR and Spanish AML legislation.

The most important legal distinction is between an authorised transaction, an unauthorised transaction and an incorrectly executed payment.

Banks must maintain effective authentication, fraud monitoring and operational resilience systems while complying with statutory customer refund obligations.

The development of verification of payee requirements and real-time fraud detection mechanisms represents an important step towards reducing instant payment fraud.

Ultimately, the legal objective is to balance payment speed and convenience with transaction security, consumer protection, financial stability and accountability of payment service providers.

LawGratis provides pro bono legal aid and resources to empower communities. Join us in making justice reachable for everyone! Follow our community on Instagram, YouTube, Facebook, and LinkedIn.

LEAVE A COMMENT