Instant Payment Fraud Reimbursement Spain Sepa Rules .

INSTANT PAYMENT FRAUD REIMBURSEMENT IN SPAIN – SEPA RULES

Detailed Explanation with Case Laws

1. Introduction

Instant payment fraud reimbursement refers to the legal obligation of banks and payment service providers to restore money to customers who suffer financial losses through fraudulent or unauthorised instant payment transactions.

Instant payments allow customers to transfer money electronically within seconds, generally operating 24 hours a day, including weekends and public holidays.

In Spain, instant payment services are widely used through SEPA (Single Euro Payments Area), mobile banking applications, online banking platforms and payment systems such as Bizum.

Although instant payments provide speed and convenience, they also create risks involving:

Phishing attacks.

Identity theft.

Account takeover.

SIM swapping.

Fake bank representatives.

Authorised push payment (APP) scams.

Fraudulent payment instructions.

Manipulation of payment beneficiaries.

Social engineering.

Cybersecurity breaches.

The principal legal question is whether a bank must reimburse a customer when an instant payment is made fraudulently.

The answer depends on whether the transaction was unauthorised, authorised through deception, incorrectly executed, or facilitated by a failure of the bank's legal or regulatory obligations.

Spain applies European payment services legislation, particularly Directive (EU) 2015/2366 (PSD2), Royal Decree-Law 19/2018 and the SEPA Instant Payments Regulation, Regulation (EU) 2024/886.

2. Legal Framework Governing Instant Payment Fraud in Spain

Several European and Spanish legal instruments regulate instant payment transactions and reimbursement obligations.

A. Directive (EU) 2015/2366 – Payment Services Directive 2 (PSD2)

PSD2 establishes the principal legal framework governing payment services throughout the European Union.

Important provisions include:

Article 64 – Consent to Payment Transactions

A payment transaction is considered authorised only where the payer has given consent to its execution.

Consent may be provided in the form agreed between the payer and payment service provider.

Article 69 – Obligations of the Payment Service User

The payment service user must:

Use payment instruments in accordance with contractual conditions.

Take reasonable steps to protect personalised security credentials.

Notify the provider without undue delay upon becoming aware of loss, theft or unauthorised use.

Article 72 – Evidence on Authentication and Execution

Where a payment service user denies having authorised a payment transaction, the payment service provider must demonstrate that the transaction was authenticated, accurately recorded and entered in its accounts.

The mere fact that a payment instrument was used does not necessarily establish that the payer authorised the transaction or acted fraudulently or with gross negligence.

Article 73 – Payment Service Provider's Liability for Unauthorised Payment Transactions

Where an unauthorised payment transaction occurs, the payer's payment service provider must generally refund the transaction amount immediately and, at the latest, by the end of the following business day after becoming aware of or being notified of the transaction.

There are limited exceptions, including reasonable grounds for suspecting fraud by the payer and communication of those grounds to the competent national authority as required by law.

Article 74 – Payer's Liability for Unauthorised Payment Transactions

This provision establishes the circumstances in which a payer may bear financial responsibility for losses resulting from an unauthorised payment transaction.

Liability may arise where the payer has acted fraudulently or intentionally or with gross negligence failed to fulfil relevant security obligations.

Article 89 – Liability for Non-Execution, Defective or Late Execution

This provision addresses liability where payment transactions are not executed or are incorrectly or belatedly executed.

It is particularly relevant where the bank processes an instant payment contrary to the payment order or applicable execution requirements.

B. Royal Decree-Law 19/2018 – Spanish Payment Services Law

Royal Decree-Law 19/2018 transposes the PSD2 framework into Spanish law.

It regulates:

Authorisation of payment transactions.

Unauthorised payment transactions.

Authentication requirements.

Liability of payment service providers.

Customer notification obligations.

Payment execution.

Reimbursement procedures.

Complaints and dispute resolution.

The provisions concerning unauthorised transactions, particularly Articles 41–46, are important when determining reimbursement obligations.

Article 45 is particularly relevant to the refund of unauthorised payment transactions.

The Spanish legal framework generally requires reimbursement without undue delay and no later than the end of the following business day, subject to the statutory exceptions.

C. Regulation (EU) 2024/886 – SEPA Instant Payments Regulation

Regulation (EU) 2024/886 amends the existing SEPA framework to improve the availability, security and affordability of instant credit transfers.

It introduces important requirements concerning:

Receiving and sending instant credit transfers.

Charges for instant transfers.

Verification of the payee.

Sanctions screening.

Fraud prevention.

Protection against erroneous or fraudulent transfers.

For euro-area payment service providers, the principal implementation dates were:

9 January 2025: Requirements concerning receiving instant credit transfers and related charges.

9 October 2025: Requirements concerning sending instant credit transfers, verification of payee and related charges.

The Regulation is particularly important because it strengthens fraud prevention before money is transferred.

However, it does not establish an automatic reimbursement obligation for every scam in which the customer personally authorises a transfer.

D. Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) 2018/389

This regulation establishes regulatory technical standards for strong customer authentication (SCA) and secure communication under PSD2.

Banks must apply appropriate authentication procedures to payment transactions.

These requirements are relevant to preventing account takeover, unauthorised transfers and payment fraud.

E. Regulation (EU) 260/2012 – SEPA Credit Transfer Framework

Regulation 260/2012, as amended by Regulation 2024/886, establishes technical and business requirements for euro credit transfers and direct debits.

It provides the wider legal framework within which ordinary and instant SEPA credit transfers operate.

3. Meaning of Instant Payment Fraud

Instant payment fraud occurs when money is transferred through an electronic payment system as a consequence of fraudulent activity.

There are several legally distinct categories.

A. Unauthorised Instant Payment Fraud

An unauthorised transaction occurs when a payment is executed without the customer's consent.

Example:

A criminal obtains a customer's banking credentials through phishing and transfers €8,000 from the customer's account without the customer's knowledge.

The customer discovers the transaction and immediately reports it to the bank.

Under PSD2 and Royal Decree-Law 19/2018, the bank generally has a statutory reimbursement obligation unless a recognised exception applies.

B. Authorised Push Payment (APP) Fraud

APP fraud occurs when the customer personally initiates and authorises a payment after being deceived by a fraudster.

Example:

A criminal impersonates a bank employee and tells the customer that the bank account is under attack.

The criminal instructs the customer to transfer €5,000 to a supposedly secure account.

The customer personally authorises the transfer, but the beneficiary account belongs to the criminal.

This creates a more complicated legal situation.

Under the traditional PSD2 framework, the transaction may be treated as authorised because the customer consented to the payment.

Therefore, the statutory refund rules for unauthorised transactions do not automatically apply.

However, the bank may still incur liability where it breached applicable contractual, regulatory, security or professional obligations.

C. Account Takeover Fraud

Account takeover occurs when criminals gain control of a customer's banking account.

They may use:

Stolen passwords.

Malware.

SIM swapping.

Compromised mobile devices.

Stolen authentication codes.

Where the customer did not consent to the resulting payment, the transaction will generally fall within the unauthorised payment framework.

D. Beneficiary Manipulation Fraud

This occurs when criminals manipulate payment details, invoices or beneficiary information.

For example, a criminal intercepts an invoice and substitutes the legitimate supplier's bank account with a fraudulent account.

The legal outcome depends on whether the customer authorised the payment to the substituted beneficiary and whether the bank fulfilled its applicable verification and execution duties.

4. Verification of Payee Under SEPA Instant Payment Rules

One of the most significant developments under Regulation (EU) 2024/886 is the introduction of Verification of Payee (VoP).

Verification of Payee is designed to help customers identify discrepancies between the name of the intended beneficiary and the account identifier (IBAN).

Before the payer authorises a credit transfer, the payment service provider must offer the required verification service.

The verification may produce results such as:

A. Match

The beneficiary name corresponds to the account holder information.

B. Close Match

The entered name is similar but not identical to the registered beneficiary name.

The customer may receive the correct or suggested beneficiary name, subject to applicable data protection requirements.

C. No Match

The entered beneficiary name does not correspond to the account holder information.

D. Verification Not Possible

The verification service cannot provide a reliable result.

The customer must be informed of the result before proceeding.

Legal Importance

Verification of Payee is an important fraud-prevention mechanism.

If a bank fails to provide the legally required verification service, or provides an incorrect verification result due to a failure attributable to it, liability may arise under the applicable SEPA and payment services framework.

Where the bank correctly provides a warning but the customer nevertheless proceeds with the transfer, reimbursement is not automatically guaranteed.

The circumstances of the transaction, applicable liability rules and any independent bank negligence must be examined.

5. Bank's Legal Obligation to Reimburse Fraudulent Instant Payments

The reimbursement obligation depends on the legal classification of the transaction.

A. Unauthorised Transactions

Under Article 73 PSD2 and the corresponding Spanish implementing provisions, the bank must generally reimburse an unauthorised transaction immediately and no later than the end of the following business day after becoming aware of or being notified of it.

The bank must also restore the payment account to the position it would have been in had the unauthorised transaction not occurred.

The bank may avoid immediate reimbursement only in the limited circumstances permitted by the legislation.

B. Transactions Resulting from Customer Gross Negligence

A bank may seek to hold the customer responsible where the customer has intentionally or through gross negligence breached relevant security obligations.

However, ordinary carelessness should not automatically be treated as gross negligence.

The assessment must consider:

The nature of the fraud.

The sophistication of the deception.

The security information disclosed.

The warnings provided.

The customer's conduct.

The bank's authentication systems.

The applicable statutory requirements.

The burden of establishing the legally relevant facts cannot simply be transferred to the customer.

C. APP Fraud

Where the customer personally authorised the transfer, the automatic reimbursement rules for unauthorised transactions generally do not apply.

Nevertheless, the bank may be liable if it:

Failed to implement required fraud-prevention measures.

Failed to provide required Verification of Payee.

Incorrectly executed the payment order.

Ignored relevant warning indicators in circumstances creating a legal duty to intervene.

Breached contractual or regulatory obligations.

Failed to comply with applicable security requirements.

A bank's liability must be established on the applicable legal basis rather than assumed merely because the customer was deceived.

6. Strong Customer Authentication and Instant Payment Fraud

Strong Customer Authentication (SCA) is a major fraud-prevention requirement under PSD2.

It generally requires authentication using at least two independent elements from the following categories:

Knowledge – something the customer knows, such as a password.

Possession – something the customer possesses, such as a registered mobile device.

Inherence – something the customer is, such as a biometric characteristic.

For remote electronic payments, additional dynamic linking requirements apply where relevant.

The authentication process must link the transaction to a specific amount and payee.

This is important because a fraudster should not be able to alter the beneficiary or payment amount without the required authentication.

However, successful SCA does not automatically establish customer consent or prove gross negligence.

A customer may have been manipulated into approving a fraudulent payment even though the authentication requirements were technically completed.

7. Liability of Banks Under SEPA Instant Payment Rules

Banks and payment service providers may face liability in several situations.

A. Failure to Authenticate Properly

If the bank processes a payment without complying with applicable authentication requirements, liability may arise.

B. Failure to Apply Verification of Payee

Failure to comply with the new verification requirements may expose the provider to liability under Regulation 2024/886.

C. Incorrect Execution

Where the bank executes a transfer using an incorrect account identifier contrary to the payment order, liability may arise under the payment services framework.

D. Failure to Follow Payment Security Requirements

A bank may face regulatory consequences for inadequate transaction monitoring, security controls or fraud-prevention arrangements.

E. Failure to Process a Fraud Report Properly

A bank must comply with applicable customer notification, investigation and reimbursement obligations.

It should not reject a legitimate reimbursement request merely by stating that the transaction was authenticated.

8. Reporting and Complaint Procedure in Spain

A customer who experiences instant payment fraud should act immediately.

The following procedure is particularly important.

Step 1: Notify the Bank

The customer should report the fraudulent transaction immediately through the bank's official fraud-reporting channel.

Step 2: Request Blocking Measures

The customer should request the blocking of compromised payment instruments, credentials or access to online banking where necessary.

Step 3: Request Payment Recall

The customer should request that the bank initiate the appropriate recall or recovery process.

Instant payments are generally difficult to reverse after execution, and a recall does not guarantee recovery.

Step 4: Submit a Written Reimbursement Claim

The complaint should identify:

Transaction date and time.

Transaction amount.

Beneficiary IBAN.

Transaction reference.

Nature of the fraud.

Date of notification.

Evidence of unauthorised access or deception.

Requested reimbursement.

Step 5: File a Police Complaint

Where criminal fraud is suspected, the customer may report the matter to the Policía Nacional or Guardia Civil.

Step 6: Complain to the Banco de España

If the bank rejects the complaint or fails to respond within the applicable period, the customer may submit a complaint to the Banco de España's Market Conduct and Claims Department, subject to the relevant admissibility requirements.

For payment services complaints, the applicable response period is generally 15 business days, with an exceptional extension to 35 business days in circumstances permitted by law.

The Banco de España's complaint procedure provides supervisory and dispute-resolution assistance, but its reports are generally not equivalent to binding judicial judgments.

Step 7: Judicial Proceedings

Where reimbursement remains disputed, the customer may pursue the appropriate civil proceedings before the competent Spanish court.

Criminal proceedings may also be relevant where fraudsters have committed offences.

9. Case Laws Relating to Instant Payment Fraud and Bank Reimbursement

There is an important distinction between direct instant-payment fraud judgments and broader European payment-services decisions.

The following cases provide relevant legal principles. They should not be misrepresented as judgments establishing a universal reimbursement rule for all instant payment scams.

Case 1: Tecnoservice Int. Srl v Poste Italiane SpA

Case C-245/18, Court of Justice of the European Union, Judgment of 11 April 2019.

Facts:

The dispute concerned the execution of a payment order where the beneficiary's account identifier was relevant to determining whether the payment had been correctly processed.

Legal Issue:

Whether a payment service provider could be held responsible for executing a payment based on the unique identifier supplied in the payment order.

Judgment:

The Court interpreted the payment services framework concerning execution by reference to the unique identifier.

It confirmed the importance of the account identifier in determining the payment service provider's execution obligations.

Legal Principle:

Where a payment order is executed in accordance with the unique identifier supplied by the payer, the payment service provider's responsibility must be assessed under the applicable statutory rules concerning unique identifiers.

Relevance to Spain:

This judgment is important in cases involving fraudulent substitution of IBAN details and mistaken beneficiary transfers.

It also demonstrates why Verification of Payee under Regulation 2024/886 is a significant additional protection.

Case 2: DenizBank AG v Verein für Konsumenteninformation

Case C-287/19, Court of Justice of the European Union, Judgment of 11 November 2020.

Facts:

The case concerned contactless payment instruments and the interpretation of PSD2 provisions governing payment instruments and customer consent.

Legal Issue:

The Court considered the application of payment services rules to contactless payment transactions and contractual arrangements.

Judgment:

The Court examined the relevant PSD2 provisions and clarified the treatment of certain contactless payment instruments and associated legal requirements.

Legal Principle:

The legal treatment of a payment transaction depends on the applicable payment services rules, including the nature of the payment instrument and the consent arrangements.

Relevance to Spain:

The case is useful when analysing consent, payment instruments and the distinction between authorised and unauthorised payment transactions.

Case 3: Landeskreditbank Baden-Württemberg v European Central Bank

Case C-450/17 P, Court of Justice of the European Union, Judgment of 8 May 2019.

Facts:

Landeskreditbank challenged the ECB's classification of the institution as significant under the Single Supervisory Mechanism.

Legal Issue:

The dispute concerned the ECB's supervisory competence and the allocation of responsibilities between European and national banking authorities.

Judgment:

The Court confirmed the ECB's supervisory role under the SSM framework.

Legal Principle:

European banking supervision operates through an integrated structure involving the ECB and national competent authorities.

Relevance to Spain:

This case is relevant to identifying the competent supervisory authority when payment fraud involves broader prudential or regulatory failures by a Spanish credit institution.

It does not establish a private customer's right to reimbursement.

Case 4: Berlusconi and Fininvest

Case C-219/17, Court of Justice of the European Union, Judgment of 19 December 2018.

Facts:

The dispute involved the ECB's powers concerning the assessment of qualifying holdings in credit institutions.

Legal Issue:

The Court considered the division of jurisdiction between national authorities and EU institutions when a national preparatory procedure culminated in an ECB decision.

Judgment:

The Court clarified that the EU courts have jurisdiction over the legality of the final ECB decision, including relevant defects in national preparatory acts forming an integral part of the process.

Legal Principle:

Supervisory decisions within the ECB's exclusive competence are subject to the appropriate EU judicial review framework.

Relevance to Spain:

This decision is useful for determining the proper judicial route when a payment-related dispute also involves an ECB supervisory decision.

Case 5: Société Colas Est and Others v France

Application No. 37971/97, European Court of Human Rights, Judgment of 16 April 2002.

Facts:

The case concerned searches conducted by authorities at company premises.

Legal Issue:

Whether intrusive investigations of corporate premises could violate Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights.

Judgment:

The Court recognised that corporate premises could receive protection under Article 8 and found that the searches violated the Convention due to inadequate safeguards.

Legal Principle:

Investigative powers must be exercised with appropriate safeguards against arbitrary interference.

Relevance to Spain:

This decision provides a broader legal framework for evaluating regulatory investigations into banks following large-scale payment fraud.

10. Distinction Between Unauthorised Fraud and Authorised APP Fraud

The distinction is central to reimbursement disputes.

Legal issueUnauthorised paymentAuthorised APP fraud
Customer consentAbsentGenerally present
PSD2 Article 73 refundGenerally applicableNot automatically applicable
AuthenticationMay have been compromisedMay have been properly completed
Gross negligence defenceRelevant under statutory conditionsNot the same statutory reimbursement test
Bank liabilitySubject to unauthorised payment rulesDepends on applicable duties and breach
Automatic reimbursementGenerally required, subject to exceptionsGenerally not guaranteed

The legal classification must be based on the actual facts rather than the bank's description of the transaction.

11. Practical Legal Example

Assume that a Spanish customer maintains a bank account with a Spanish commercial bank.

The customer receives a fraudulent telephone call from a person impersonating a bank security officer.

The fraudster claims that the customer's account has been compromised and instructs the customer to transfer €12,000 to a supposedly protected account.

The customer initiates the instant payment through the banking application.

The transfer is completed within seconds.

The customer subsequently discovers that the beneficiary account belongs to a criminal.

Legal Analysis:

First, the bank must establish whether the transaction was authorised within the meaning of PSD2 and Spanish law.

Second, if the customer genuinely consented to the transfer but was deceived, the case may constitute APP fraud rather than an unauthorised transaction.

Third, the bank's compliance with Verification of Payee must be examined.

Fourth, the court may need to examine whether the bank complied with applicable contractual and regulatory duties.

Fifth, if the bank failed to provide a legally required verification service or committed an independent execution or security breach, this may support a claim for compensation.

Finally, the customer's conduct, the fraudster's deception and the causal relationship between the bank's conduct and the financial loss must be evaluated.

Conclusion: The customer does not automatically receive reimbursement merely because the transfer resulted from fraud. However, the bank cannot automatically reject the claim merely because the payment was authenticated.

12. Major Legal Challenges in Instant Payment Reimbursement

A. Irreversibility of Instant Payments

Instant payments are generally completed within seconds, making recovery difficult.

B. Difficulty in Distinguishing Authorised and Unauthorised Payments

Fraudsters frequently manipulate customers into approving payments themselves.

C. Customer Gross Negligence

Banks and customers may disagree about whether the customer failed to protect security credentials with gross negligence.

D. Verification of Payee Implementation

The new verification requirements create additional compliance responsibilities for payment service providers.

E. Cross-Border Fraud

Fraudulent beneficiary accounts may be located in different SEPA jurisdictions, creating difficulties involving jurisdiction and recovery.

F. Insufficient Fraud Detection

Banks must develop appropriate risk-based monitoring and security arrangements without treating every unusual transaction as automatically fraudulent.

13. Future Regulatory Developments and Consumer Protection

The European Union's approach to payment fraud is increasingly focused on prevention rather than relying exclusively on reimbursement after financial loss.

Important developments include:

Wider implementation of Verification of Payee.

Improved fraud monitoring.

Stronger authentication mechanisms.

Better cooperation between payment service providers.

Improved cross-border fraud reporting.

Greater transparency concerning payment execution.

More effective protection of consumers using instant payment systems.

Regulation (EU) 2024/886 represents an important development in this area.

It strengthens the preventive framework for SEPA instant credit transfers, although it should not be interpreted as creating a general EU-wide statutory reimbursement guarantee for all authorised APP scams.

14. Conclusion

Instant payment fraud reimbursement in Spain is governed by a combination of European payment services legislation, SEPA regulations and Spanish domestic law.

PSD2 establishes the principal distinction between authorised and unauthorised payment transactions. Under Article 73, unauthorised payments generally require prompt reimbursement, subject to the statutory exceptions.

Royal Decree-Law 19/2018 implements these protections in Spain.

Regulation (EU) 2024/886 strengthens the SEPA instant payment framework through mandatory verification of payees, improved payment infrastructure and additional fraud-prevention obligations.

However, authorised push payment fraud remains a particularly difficult legal issue because the customer may have personally consented to the payment despite being deceived.

The legal position therefore requires careful examination of customer consent, authentication, bank security obligations, Verification of Payee, transaction execution and possible negligence.

Ultimately, Spanish banking law seeks to balance consumer protection, bank accountability, payment-system security and the efficient operation of instant transfers.

15. Important Legislation and Judicial Authorities

Spanish Legislation

Royal Decree-Law 19/2018 on Payment Services and Other Urgent Financial Measures.

Law 7/1998 on General Contracting Conditions, where applicable.

Law 1/2000 on Civil Procedure.

Royal Legislative Decree 1/2007 on the General Law for the Protection of Consumers and Users, where applicable.

Law 10/2010 on the Prevention of Money Laundering and Terrorist Financing.

European Union Legislation

Directive (EU) 2015/2366 (PSD2).

Regulation (EU) 2024/886 – SEPA Instant Payments Regulation.

Regulation (EU) No. 260/2012 on SEPA credit transfers and direct debits, as amended.

Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) 2018/389 on Strong Customer Authentication.

Regulation (EU) 2016/679 – General Data Protection Regulation.

Important Judicial Authorities

Tecnoservice Int. Srl v Poste Italiane SpA, C-245/18 (2019).

DenizBank AG v Verein für Konsumenteninformation, C-287/19 (2020).

Landeskreditbank Baden-Württemberg v ECB, C-450/17 P (2019).

Berlusconi and Fininvest, C-219/17 (2018).

Société Colas Est and Others v France, Application No. 37971/97 (2002).

Final Academic Observation: The above judicial authorities address payment execution, payment instruments, banking supervision and procedural safeguards. They do not establish a general automatic reimbursement right for authorised APP fraud. That issue must be analysed separately under the applicable Spanish contractual, civil liability and payment services rules.

LawGratis provides pro bono legal aid and resources to empower communities. Join us in making justice reachable for everyone! Follow our community on Instagram, YouTube, Facebook, and LinkedIn.

LEAVE A COMMENT