Instant Payment Ecosystem Issues .

INSTANT PAYMENT ECOSYSTEM ISSUES – SPANISH BANKING LAW

Detailed Legal Explanation With Case Laws

1. Introduction

The instant payment ecosystem refers to the network of financial institutions, payment service providers, payment systems, digital platforms, technology infrastructure and regulatory authorities that facilitate the immediate transfer of money between bank accounts.

Unlike traditional bank transfers, which may take several hours or business days, instant payments allow funds to become available to the recipient within seconds, generally operating continuously, including weekends and public holidays.

In Spain, instant payments form an important part of the European Single Euro Payments Area (SEPA) payment infrastructure.

The development of instant payment systems has improved financial accessibility, commercial efficiency and digital banking services. However, it has also created significant legal and regulatory challenges involving:

Payment fraud and authorised push payment scams.

Cybersecurity and operational resilience.

Incorrect beneficiary identification.

Unauthorised payment transactions.

Money laundering and terrorist financing.

Consumer protection.

Data protection and privacy.

Payment system interoperability.

Liability between participating banks.

Cross-border payment disputes.

The Spanish banking sector must comply with European Union payment legislation, Spanish financial regulations and applicable supervisory requirements.

2. Legal and Regulatory Framework in Spain

The instant payment ecosystem in Spain is primarily governed by European Union legislation and its implementation within the Spanish legal system.

A. Regulation (EU) 2024/886 – Instant Payments Regulation

The Instant Payments Regulation is one of the most important legislative developments in European payment services.

It amends the SEPA Regulation, the Cross-Border Payments Regulation and the Second Payment Services Directive.

Its principal objective is to make euro instant credit transfers more accessible, affordable and secure throughout the European Union.

Important requirements include:

Receiving instant credit transfers.

Sending instant credit transfers.

Verification of the payee.

Equal pricing requirements.

Sanctions screening arrangements.

Measures against payment fraud.

Operational availability of instant payment services.

The regulation requires payment service providers within its scope to comply with specific implementation deadlines.

For euro-area payment service providers, the principal receiving deadline was 9 January 2025, while the sending deadline was 9 October 2025, subject to the regulation's specific scope and exceptions.

B. Directive (EU) 2015/2366 – PSD2

The Second Payment Services Directive establishes the legal framework for payment services throughout the European Union.

Its important provisions include:

Article 64: Consent and withdrawal of consent.

Article 71: Notification of unauthorised or incorrectly executed payment transactions.

Article 72: Evidence on authentication and execution.

Article 73: Payment service provider liability for unauthorised transactions.

Article 74: Payer liability for unauthorised transactions.

Article 76: Refunds for payment transactions initiated by or through a payee.

Article 89: Liability for non-execution, defective or late execution.

These provisions are particularly relevant when instant payments are executed incorrectly, without authorisation or as a result of fraud.

C. Royal Decree-Law 19/2018, on Payment Services and Other Urgent Financial Measures

Spain implemented the PSD2 framework through Royal Decree-Law 19/2018.

It establishes important obligations concerning payment service providers, payment authorisation, execution of transactions, consumer protection and liability for payment errors.

It is a central piece of Spanish legislation for disputes involving instant payments.

D. Regulation (EU) 2022/2554 – Digital Operational Resilience Act (DORA)

DORA establishes a common framework for digital operational resilience in the financial sector.

It addresses:

ICT risk management.

Cybersecurity.

Incident reporting.

Digital operational resilience testing.

Third-party technology-provider risks.

Information-sharing arrangements.

Business continuity and recovery.

Since 17 January 2025, DORA has applied to financial entities within its scope.

Instant payment providers must maintain appropriate operational safeguards against system failures, cyberattacks and technological disruptions.

E. General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR)

Regulation (EU) 2016/679 applies to personal data processed through instant payment systems.

Important provisions include:

Article 5: Principles relating to personal data processing.

Article 6: Lawfulness of processing.

Article 25: Data protection by design and by default.

Article 32: Security of processing.

Article 33: Notification of personal data breaches.

Article 35: Data protection impact assessments.

Payment institutions must ensure that customer information, beneficiary details and transaction records are processed lawfully and securely.

F. Spanish Anti-Money Laundering Legislation

Law 10/2010 on the Prevention of Money Laundering and Terrorist Financing establishes customer due diligence, monitoring, reporting and record-keeping obligations.

It is particularly important because instant payment systems can be exploited for rapid movement of illicit funds.

3. Meaning and Structure of the Instant Payment Ecosystem

The instant payment ecosystem consists of several interconnected participants.

A. Payment Service Users

These include individuals, businesses, merchants and other entities initiating or receiving instant payments.

B. Payment Service Providers

Banks, electronic money institutions and other authorised payment service providers facilitate payment transactions.

C. Payment Clearing and Settlement Systems

These systems process payment instructions and facilitate the settlement of funds between participating institutions.

Examples include:

SEPA Instant Credit Transfer (SCT Inst).

TARGET Instant Payment Settlement (TIPS).

Clearing arrangements operated by payment infrastructure providers.

D. European Central Bank

The European Central Bank plays an important role in payment-system oversight and operates TARGET Services, including TIPS.

E. Banco de España

Banco de España participates in the Eurosystem payment infrastructure and exercises relevant supervisory and oversight responsibilities under the applicable European and Spanish frameworks.

F. Technology Providers

These include cloud service providers, cybersecurity companies, authentication providers and payment-processing technology companies.

The involvement of third-party technology providers creates additional operational and contractual risks.

4. Major Legal Issues in the Instant Payment Ecosystem

A. Payment Fraud and Authorised Push Payment Scams

One of the most serious challenges is authorised push payment fraud.

This occurs when a customer is deceived into voluntarily initiating a payment to a fraudster's account.

Examples include:

Fake investment opportunities.

Impersonation of bank employees.

Business email compromise.

Fake supplier invoices.

Romance scams.

Fraudulent online marketplaces.

The principal legal difficulty is distinguishing between a payment that was genuinely authorised by the customer and one that was executed without valid authorisation.

Under PSD2, a payment transaction generally requires payer consent.

Where the customer genuinely authorised the transfer, the automatic refund regime for unauthorised transactions does not necessarily apply.

However, a bank may still have contractual, statutory or other legal responsibilities depending on the circumstances and the applicable rules.

The Verification of Payee requirement under Regulation (EU) 2024/886 is an important safeguard against certain impersonation and misdirection scams.

B. Incorrect Beneficiary Identification

Instant payments are particularly vulnerable to errors involving incorrect beneficiary details.

A payer may enter an incorrect IBAN or transfer money to an unintended recipient.

The Verification of Payee mechanism requires the relevant verification of the payee's name against the identified account information before authorisation, in accordance with the applicable regulatory requirements.

The system is designed to provide information about whether the beneficiary name matches the account identifier.

Its purpose is to reduce fraud and payment errors.

However, verification does not guarantee that the beneficiary is honest or that the underlying commercial transaction is legitimate.

C. Unauthorised Transactions

An instant payment may be executed through:

Stolen banking credentials.

Compromised mobile devices.

Identity theft.

Phishing attacks.

Account takeover.

Fraudulent authentication.

Under PSD2 Articles 72 and 73, the payment service provider must establish the relevant authentication and execution evidence, and must generally refund an unauthorised transaction immediately, subject to the statutory conditions and exceptions.

The payer's liability must be assessed under Article 74.

In Spain, Royal Decree-Law 19/2018 provides the domestic legal framework for these obligations.

D. Operational and Technical Failures

Instant payments depend on continuous technical availability.

System failures may result in:

Delayed payment processing.

Duplicate transactions.

Incorrect transaction execution.

Failed settlement.

Unavailable banking applications.

Cybersecurity incidents.

These failures may create contractual liability and regulatory consequences.

DORA requires financial entities within its scope to maintain appropriate ICT risk management, incident handling, testing and operational resilience arrangements.

E. Money Laundering and Terrorist Financing

The rapid movement of funds creates significant anti-money laundering challenges.

Criminals may exploit instant payment systems to move funds through multiple accounts before suspicious activity is detected.

Common methods include:

Money mule accounts.

Layering transactions.

Rapid movement between different banks.

Fraudulent business accounts.

Structuring multiple transactions.

Cross-border movement of criminal proceeds.

Spanish banks must comply with Law 10/2010 and applicable EU anti-money laundering requirements.

They must apply risk-based customer due diligence, monitor transactions and report suspicious activities to SEPBLAC where the statutory conditions are met.

F. Cross-Border Payment Interoperability

The SEPA instant payment ecosystem requires participating institutions to process payments across different national banking systems.

Legal and technical challenges arise where:

Payment providers use incompatible technical systems.

Beneficiary information is inconsistent.

Sanctions screening produces delays.

Cross-border fraud investigations involve multiple jurisdictions.

Settlement infrastructure experiences disruption.

Regulation (EU) 2024/886 seeks to improve accessibility and interoperability throughout the SEPA area.

G. Data Protection and Customer Privacy

Instant payments generate substantial volumes of personal and financial information.

Such information may include:

Customer identity.

IBAN details.

Beneficiary information.

Transaction amounts.

Transaction timestamps.

Payment references.

Device and authentication information.

Banks must comply with GDPR principles, including purpose limitation, data minimisation, accuracy, storage limitation and security.

The processing of information for fraud prevention and sanctions compliance must have an appropriate legal basis.

H. Liability Between Participating Banks

An instant payment may involve multiple financial institutions.

A dispute may arise concerning which institution is responsible for:

Incorrect payment execution.

Authentication failures.

Fraudulent account activity.

Failure to comply with applicable verification requirements.

Delayed settlement.

Failure to process a payment instruction properly.

The applicable allocation of liability depends on the transaction, the contractual relationships and the relevant statutory provisions.

A customer should not automatically be required to resolve an internal dispute between participating payment service providers.

5. Verification of Payee: A Major Regulatory Development

Verification of Payee is an important component of the Instant Payments Regulation.

It aims to identify inconsistencies between the beneficiary's name and the account identifier before a payment is authorised.

The verification process may produce different outcomes:

A. Match

The beneficiary's name corresponds with the account information.

B. Close Match

The entered name is similar but not identical to the registered beneficiary name.

The customer may receive the correct beneficiary name or other appropriate information.

C. No Match

The beneficiary's name does not correspond with the account information.

D. Verification Not Possible

The verification service cannot complete the comparison.

The payment service provider must provide the applicable result in accordance with the regulation.

The mechanism is intended to reduce accidental transfers and certain forms of impersonation fraud.

However, it does not eliminate all payment fraud because a criminal may use an account held in their own name or control a legitimate beneficiary account.

6. Case Laws Relevant to Instant Payment Ecosystem Issues

There is no established body of Spanish Supreme Court or Court of Justice of the European Union judgments dealing exclusively with the modern instant payment ecosystem.

Nevertheless, several European and comparative judgments establish important legal principles concerning electronic payment transactions, beneficiary identification, authentication and bank liability.

Case 1: Tecnoservice Int. Srl v Poste Italiane SpA, Case C-245/18

Court: Court of Justice of the European Union.

Legal principle:

The case concerned the execution of payment transactions and the significance of the unique identifier supplied by the payment service user.

The Court examined the legal consequences of executing a payment order using the relevant unique identifier.

Relevance to instant payments:

The judgment is important because instant payment systems rely heavily on accurate account identifiers, particularly IBANs.

It demonstrates why the legal responsibility for incorrect payment instructions must be assessed by reference to the applicable payment-services rules.

Case 2: DenizBank AG v Verein für Konsumenteninformation, Case C-287/19

Court: Court of Justice of the European Union, judgment of 11 November 2020.

Legal principle:

The Court considered aspects of contactless payment instruments and the application of PSD2 rules.

The decision addressed the legal treatment of contactless payment functionality and relevant payment-services requirements.

Relevance:

The judgment is important for understanding how modern electronic payment technologies interact with statutory payment authorisation and consumer protection rules.

Its principles are relevant when analysing digital payment authentication and the allocation of responsibilities between payment service providers and customers.

Case 3: T-Mobile Austria GmbH v Verein für Konsumenteninformation, Case C-616/11

Court: Court of Justice of the European Union, judgment of 11 April 2013.

Legal principle:

The Court considered payment-related charges and the interpretation of payment-services legislation.

Relevance:

The decision provides useful guidance on the regulatory treatment of payment services and the relationship between payment service providers and consumers.

It is relevant when assessing pricing transparency and charges associated with digital and instant payment services, although it predates the modern instant payment framework.

Case 4: Peter Paul and Others v Bundesrepublik Deutschland, Case C-222/02

Court: Court of Justice of the European Union, judgment of 12 October 2004.

Legal principle:

The Court examined the responsibilities of national authorities in the banking supervisory framework and the limits of liability for alleged supervisory failures.

Relevance:

The decision is useful when considering the distinction between the regulatory responsibilities of banking supervisory authorities and the contractual responsibilities of individual financial institutions.

It should not be interpreted as establishing a specific liability rule for instant payment failures.

Case 5: SIB v MIB, Case C-191/17

This case should not be relied upon as an authority on instant payments. It is important to distinguish genuinely relevant payment-services judgments from unrelated banking cases when preparing legal submissions.

7. Bank Liability Under Spanish Payment Services Law

Bank liability is a central issue in instant payment disputes.

The legal position depends on whether the payment was authorised, incorrectly executed or affected by fraud.

A. Unauthorised Payment

Where a payment is unauthorised, the payment service provider generally has a statutory obligation to refund the amount under the applicable PSD2 framework.

Article 73 establishes the refund obligation, subject to the applicable legal requirements.

B. Incorrectly Executed Payment

Where a payment service provider is responsible for non-execution, defective execution or late execution, Article 89 PSD2 establishes the relevant liability framework.

C. Customer Negligence

Article 74 addresses the circumstances in which a payer may bear losses arising from an unauthorised payment, including cases involving fraud or intentional or grossly negligent failure to comply with relevant security obligations.

A bank cannot automatically attribute every fraudulent payment to customer negligence.

D. Bank's Failure to Comply With Legal Duties

Where a bank fails to fulfil applicable statutory, contractual or regulatory obligations, it may face liability depending on the facts and the applicable legal provisions.

E. Authorised Fraudulent Payments

Where a customer personally authorises an instant transfer after being deceived, the transaction is not automatically treated as unauthorised.

The possibility of recovery depends on the applicable legal framework, the bank's conduct, the transaction circumstances and any relevant contractual or regulatory obligations.

8. Role of Banco de España and European Supervisory Authorities

Banco de España performs important functions within the Spanish banking regulatory and supervisory framework.

Its relevant responsibilities include:

Supervisory functions concerning payment institutions within its legal competence.

Oversight of payment systems within the applicable framework.

Monitoring compliance with relevant financial legislation.

Receiving and handling customer complaints under its procedures.

Promoting payment-system security and financial stability.

The European Central Bank also has important responsibilities concerning payment-system oversight and the operation of Eurosystem payment infrastructure.

The European Banking Authority contributes to the development of supervisory standards, technical guidance and regulatory convergence.

SEPBLAC is the Spanish financial intelligence authority responsible for receiving and analysing suspicious transaction information under the Spanish AML framework.

9. Consumer Protection in Instant Payment Transactions

Consumer protection is particularly important because instant transfers are often irreversible in practical terms once successfully executed.

Important consumer safeguards include:

1. Clear Payment Information

Consumers must receive appropriate information about payment services, charges and transaction conditions.

2. Authentication Security

Payment service providers must comply with applicable authentication requirements.

3. Fraud Prevention

Banks should maintain appropriate systems for detecting suspicious transactions.

4. Refund Rights

Consumers must receive statutory protection in qualifying unauthorised payment cases.

5. Complaint Mechanisms

Customers should have access to effective internal complaints procedures and applicable external dispute resolution channels.

6. Payee Verification

Customers benefit from beneficiary verification under Regulation (EU) 2024/886.

10. Cybersecurity and Digital Operational Resilience

Instant payment systems operate continuously, making cybersecurity and operational resilience essential.

Banks must establish appropriate controls against:

Distributed denial-of-service attacks.

Malware infections.

Phishing.

Account takeover.

API vulnerabilities.

Cloud service disruption.

Data breaches.

Insider threats.

Under DORA, financial entities must establish appropriate ICT governance and risk-management arrangements.

They must also maintain incident management and business continuity procedures.

Third-party ICT providers are especially important because payment institutions increasingly depend on external cloud, software and technology infrastructure.

A failure affecting a critical service provider may disrupt several banks simultaneously.

11. Practical Example Under Spanish Banking Law

Assume that a customer of a Spanish bank initiates an instant payment of €25,000 to what the customer believes is a legitimate commercial supplier.

The payment is completed within seconds.

However, the customer subsequently discovers that the supplier's email account had been compromised and the beneficiary account belonged to a fraudster.

The customer immediately contacts the bank.

The legal analysis involves several questions:

First: Did the customer genuinely authorise the payment?

Second: Was the payment properly authenticated?

Third: Was Verification of Payee performed in accordance with the applicable regulatory requirements?

Fourth: Did the bank comply with its statutory fraud-prevention and payment-execution obligations?

Fifth: Was there any failure in the bank's security systems or transaction monitoring?

Sixth: Is the customer entitled to a refund under the unauthorised payment provisions, or does the dispute concern an authorised payment induced by deception?

The bank must investigate the circumstances and determine the applicable legal obligations.

If the payment was genuinely authorised, the automatic refund provisions for unauthorised transactions may not apply.

Nevertheless, the customer may have other legal remedies depending on the circumstances, including claims based on a breach of applicable contractual or statutory obligations.

12. Emerging Legal Challenges

The instant payment ecosystem faces several emerging legal challenges.

A. Artificial Intelligence Fraud Detection

Banks increasingly use artificial intelligence to identify suspicious transactions.

However, inaccurate algorithms may result in legitimate payments being incorrectly blocked.

B. Cross-Border Regulatory Cooperation

Fraud involving multiple jurisdictions requires cooperation between financial institutions, supervisory authorities and law enforcement agencies.

C. Digital Identity Risks

Stolen or manipulated digital identities can undermine customer authentication and beneficiary verification.

D. Third-Party Technology Liability

Cloud service failures and payment-processing disruptions create questions concerning contractual responsibility and operational resilience.

E. Cryptocurrency and Instant Payment Integration

The interaction between conventional bank transfers, digital wallets and cryptoasset platforms creates additional compliance and fraud risks.

F. Financial Inclusion

Instant payment services must remain accessible while maintaining appropriate security, affordability and consumer safeguards.

13. Recommendations for Spanish Banks

Spanish banks should adopt the following measures:

Implement effective Verification of Payee systems.

Maintain strong customer authentication controls.

Improve real-time transaction monitoring.

Establish effective fraud detection mechanisms.

Maintain DORA-compliant ICT risk-management systems.

Strengthen AML transaction monitoring.

Establish clear procedures for handling disputed payments.

Maintain effective cross-border cooperation arrangements.

Conduct regular cybersecurity testing.

Improve customer awareness of instant payment fraud.

Maintain reliable audit trails and transaction records.

Review third-party technology-provider risks.

14. Conclusion

The instant payment ecosystem represents a major development in modern Spanish and European banking law.

It provides rapid, convenient and continuous payment services but creates significant legal challenges involving fraud, unauthorised transactions, operational failures, cybersecurity, consumer protection and financial crime.

Regulation (EU) 2024/886 establishes the central legislative framework for improving euro instant payment accessibility and security.

PSD2 and Royal Decree-Law 19/2018 establish important rules concerning payment authorisation, authentication, execution and liability.

DORA strengthens digital operational resilience, while GDPR and Law 10/2010 address data protection and anti-money laundering obligations.

The CJEU decisions in Tecnoservice, DenizBank, T-Mobile Austria and Peter Paul provide useful legal principles concerning payment execution, electronic payment services and banking supervision.

Ultimately, the success of Spain's instant payment ecosystem depends on balancing payment speed with legal accountability, cybersecurity, financial stability and consumer protection.

LawGratis provides pro bono legal aid and resources to empower communities. Join us in making justice reachable for everyone! Follow our community on Instagram, YouTube, Facebook, and LinkedIn.

LEAVE A COMMENT