Instant Payment Liability Disputes Sepa Regulation Spain .
INSTANT PAYMENT LIABILITY DISPUTES – SEPA REGULATION SPAIN
DETAILED EXPLANATION WITH CASE LAWS
1. Introduction
Instant Payment Liability Disputes arise when a financial loss occurs in connection with an instant credit transfer and the customer, bank, payment service provider or another financial intermediary disputes responsibility for that loss.
Instant payments allow money to be transferred between bank accounts within seconds, generally on a 24-hour, seven-day basis. Unlike traditional credit transfers, instant payments are designed to make funds available to the beneficiary almost immediately.
Although instant payment systems improve financial efficiency, they also create significant legal risks involving fraudulent transactions, unauthorised transfers, incorrect beneficiary details, technical failures, mistaken payments, payment execution errors and inadequate fraud prevention.
In Spain, instant payment liability disputes are principally governed by European Union payment legislation, particularly the SEPA framework, the Payment Services Directive (PSD2), Regulation (EU) 2024/886 on instant credit transfers and Spanish payment services legislation.
The central legal issue is determining whether the payment was authorised, whether the payment service provider properly executed the transaction and whether the applicable statutory conditions for reimbursement or compensation have been satisfied.
The legal framework seeks to balance three objectives:
Protecting customers against unauthorised and incorrectly executed payments.
Ensuring reliable and secure instant payment infrastructure.
Establishing clear responsibilities for banks and payment service providers.
2. Meaning of Instant Payments Under SEPA
SEPA means Single Euro Payments Area.
It is a European payment integration framework designed to make euro payments across participating countries operate under harmonised standards.
Instant credit transfers allow funds to move between participating payment accounts within seconds.
The principal characteristics include:
Availability throughout the day and year.
Rapid execution of euro credit transfers.
Immediate or near-immediate availability of funds.
Standardised payment messaging.
Harmonised payment processing requirements.
Improved cross-border payment efficiency.
Spain participates in the SEPA framework because it is part of the euro area.
The legal framework applies to relevant payment service providers operating within its territorial and institutional scope.
3. Principal Legal Framework Governing Instant Payment Liability in Spain
A. Regulation (EU) No. 260/2012 – SEPA Regulation
Regulation 260/2012 establishes technical and business requirements for credit transfers and direct debits in euro.
It provides the foundation for harmonised euro payment transactions.
It is particularly important because Regulation (EU) 2024/886 amended Regulation 260/2012 to introduce specific requirements concerning instant credit transfers.
B. Regulation (EU) 2024/886 – Instant Payments Regulation
Regulation (EU) 2024/886 is the principal legislative development concerning instant euro payments.
It amends:
Regulation (EU) No. 260/2012.
Regulation (EU) No. 2021/1230 on cross-border payments.
Directive (EU) 2015/2366, commonly known as PSD2.
Its principal objectives include increasing the availability, affordability and security of instant euro credit transfers.
Important requirements include:
Payment service providers within the applicable scope must offer instant euro credit transfers.
Instant payments must be processed within the prescribed execution period.
Charges for instant credit transfers must not exceed charges for corresponding ordinary credit transfers.
Payment service providers must implement verification of the payee.
Payment service providers must conduct applicable targeted screening of their payment service users against EU financial restrictive measures.
Appropriate fraud-prevention and customer-protection procedures must be maintained.
C. Implementation Timetable
The Regulation introduced different implementation deadlines depending on the type of payment service provider and its location.
For euro-area payment service providers, the principal deadlines were:
9 January 2025: Receiving instant euro credit transfers.
9 October 2025: Sending instant euro credit transfers and providing verification of payee.
9 July 2027: Relevant obligations for certain non-bank payment and electronic money institutions under the transitional arrangements.
Therefore, by November 2026, the principal receiving and sending obligations for payment service providers in the euro area have entered into application.
D. Directive (EU) 2015/2366 – PSD2
PSD2 establishes the broader legal framework for payment services within the European Union.
Its important provisions include:
Article 64: Consent and withdrawal of consent.
Article 71: Notification of unauthorised or incorrectly executed payment transactions.
Article 72: Evidence on authentication and execution of payment transactions.
Article 73: Payment service provider liability for unauthorised payment transactions.
Article 74: Payer liability for unauthorised payment transactions.
Article 80: Irrevocability of payment orders.
Article 88: Liability for incorrect unique identifiers.
Article 89: Payment service provider liability for non-execution, defective or late execution.
Article 90: Refunds for payment transactions initiated by or through a payee.
Article 92: Recourse and compensation.
These provisions are especially important when determining liability between customers and financial institutions.
E. Spanish Royal Decree-Law 19/2018
Real Decreto-ley 19/2018, de servicios de pago y otras medidas urgentes en materia financiera, implements the principal PSD2 payment-services framework in Spain.
It governs matters including:
Payment transaction authorisation.
Customer consent.
Authentication.
Unauthorised payment transactions.
Refund obligations.
Incorrect execution.
Payment service provider liability.
Customer complaints and dispute resolution.
Spanish courts and financial authorities must interpret the domestic framework consistently with applicable EU legislation.
F. Law 7/1998 on General Contracting Conditions and Consumer Legislation
Where instant payment disputes involve standard banking terms, unfair contractual clauses or consumer rights, Spanish consumer protection legislation may also become relevant.
Relevant legislation includes the consolidated Consumer Protection Act, Royal Legislative Decree 1/2007.
Contractual provisions cannot lawfully remove mandatory statutory payment-service protections.
4. Main Categories of Instant Payment Liability Disputes
4.1 Unauthorised Instant Payment Transactions
An unauthorised instant payment occurs when a transaction is executed without the customer's valid consent.
Examples include:
A criminal obtains access to a customer's banking application.
A fraudster uses stolen authentication credentials.
A transaction is initiated through a compromised device.
A payment is executed without the account holder's knowledge.
A third party uses stolen security credentials to initiate an instant transfer.
Under PSD2 Article 73, the payer's payment service provider must generally refund an unauthorised payment transaction immediately and no later than the end of the following business day after becoming aware of or being notified of the transaction, subject to the statutory exceptions.
The provider must also restore the debited payment account to the position it would have been in had the unauthorised transaction not taken place.
This protection is particularly important because instant payments may be practically irreversible once the funds have been credited and withdrawn by the recipient.
4.2 Authorised Push Payment Fraud
Authorised Push Payment (APP) fraud occurs when a customer is deceived into voluntarily initiating a payment to a fraudster.
For example:
A Spanish customer receives a fraudulent telephone call from someone pretending to be a bank employee.
The fraudster convinces the customer that the account is compromised and instructs the customer to transfer €15,000 to a supposedly secure account.
The customer personally approves the instant payment.
The legal problem is that the payment may technically be authorised even though the customer was deceived.
An authorised transaction is not automatically equivalent to an unauthorised transaction for reimbursement purposes.
The customer must establish whether other legal grounds for liability exist, including:
Negligence by the bank.
Breach of contractual obligations.
Failure to provide required security measures.
Failure to comply with applicable payee-verification obligations.
Misrepresentation or other actionable conduct by a third party.
The applicable facts and legal provisions determine whether reimbursement is required.
4.3 Incorrect Beneficiary Transactions
A customer may enter an incorrect IBAN or beneficiary identifier.
The payment may then be transferred to an unintended recipient.
PSD2 Article 88 provides a specific framework for transactions executed according to an incorrect unique identifier.
Generally, where the unique identifier supplied by the payer is incorrect, the payment service provider is not responsible for non-execution or defective execution resulting from that incorrect identifier, subject to its statutory obligations.
However, the provider must make reasonable efforts to recover the funds.
The recipient's payment service provider must cooperate in the recovery process as required by the applicable legislation.
4.4 Duplicate Instant Payments
Duplicate payments occur when a transaction is executed more than once.
Possible causes include:
Technical system malfunction.
Repeated payment instructions.
Incorrect transaction processing.
Application failures.
Banking infrastructure errors.
If the customer authorised only one payment but the bank executes two, the additional transaction may constitute an unauthorised or incorrectly executed transaction, depending on the facts.
The bank must assess the transaction under the applicable PSD2 provisions and the Spanish implementing legislation.
4.5 Delayed or Failed Instant Payments
An instant transfer may fail to reach the beneficiary within the legally prescribed execution period.
Possible causes include:
Technical outages.
Settlement infrastructure problems.
Incorrect routing.
Processing errors.
Compliance-related restrictions.
The legal consequences depend on whether the payment was rejected, delayed, incorrectly executed or never completed.
PSD2 Article 89 is particularly relevant to defective or late execution.
4.6 Fraudulent Beneficiary Accounts
Fraudsters may open bank accounts using false or stolen identity documents.
Such accounts may subsequently be used to receive instant transfers obtained through scams.
A receiving bank may face legal scrutiny where its account-opening, customer due diligence or transaction-monitoring arrangements fail to comply with applicable legal obligations.
However, the mere fact that a fraudulent payment reaches an account held at a particular bank does not automatically establish that the receiving bank is liable to reimburse the victim.
The applicable duties, the bank's conduct, causation and the available legal remedies must be examined.
5. Verification of Payee and Bank Liability
One of the most important developments under Regulation (EU) 2024/886 is Verification of Payee (VoP).
Verification of Payee is a mechanism that checks whether the beneficiary name supplied by the payer corresponds to the name associated with the payment account identified by the IBAN.
The purpose is to reduce:
Impersonation fraud.
Invoice redirection fraud.
Incorrect beneficiary payments.
Certain forms of authorised payment fraud.
How Verification of Payee Works
Suppose a customer wants to transfer €20,000 to a supplier.
The customer enters:
Beneficiary name: ABC Manufacturing SL.
IBAN: The supplier's bank account.
The payment service provider checks whether the name corresponds to the account information associated with that IBAN.
Possible outcomes include:
Match: The name and account information correspond.
Close match: The entered name is similar but not identical.
No match: The information does not correspond.
Verification unavailable: The verification process cannot be completed.
The payer should receive the relevant result before authorising the payment.
Legal Importance
Verification of Payee strengthens consumer protection but does not guarantee that every payment is safe.
A successful name-and-account match does not prove that the recipient is honest or that the underlying commercial transaction is genuine.
Similarly, the absence of a warning does not automatically establish liability for every subsequent loss.
Liability depends on whether the payment service provider complied with the applicable statutory requirements and whether a breach caused the loss.
6. Liability of the Sending Bank
The sending bank has several important legal responsibilities.
These include:
Correctly processing the customer's payment instruction.
Maintaining appropriate authentication procedures.
Applying the applicable instant-payment requirements.
Providing Verification of Payee where legally required.
Informing customers about relevant verification results.
Protecting payment credentials.
Complying with applicable fraud-prevention and restrictive-measures screening obligations.
Correcting unauthorised or incorrectly executed transactions where required.
If a bank fails to comply with its statutory duties, it may face reimbursement obligations, contractual liability or regulatory consequences.
However, liability must be assessed under the specific payment-services rules rather than assumed from the mere existence of fraud.
7. Liability of the Receiving Bank
The receiving bank is responsible for operating its payment services in accordance with applicable legal requirements.
Its responsibilities may include:
Customer identification.
Customer due diligence.
Transaction monitoring.
Compliance with anti-money laundering obligations.
Fraud detection and escalation.
Proper handling of received payment funds.
Cooperation with relevant payment recovery procedures.
The receiving bank may face regulatory or civil liability if it breaches an applicable legal obligation and the necessary conditions for liability are established.
The principal Spanish AML legislation is Law 10/2010 on the prevention of money laundering and terrorist financing.
Its provisions concerning customer due diligence, monitoring and suspicious transaction reporting may become relevant where instant payment accounts are used for criminal activity.
However, AML obligations should not be confused with an automatic statutory right for every victim to recover funds from a receiving bank.
8. Irrevocability of Instant Payments
One of the central legal difficulties associated with instant payments is their practical irreversibility.
Under PSD2 Article 80, payment orders are generally irrevocable once received by the payer's payment service provider, subject to the statutory exceptions and applicable provisions.
In instant payments, funds may reach the recipient within seconds.
This creates several legal difficulties:
The fraudster may immediately withdraw the funds.
Funds may be transferred through several accounts.
The recipient may be located in another SEPA country.
The sending bank may be unable to recover the money without cooperation.
The customer may face difficulties identifying the ultimate recipient.
Importantly, the irrevocability of a payment order does not eliminate statutory reimbursement rights concerning unauthorised or incorrectly executed payments.
It is therefore necessary to distinguish between payment-order cancellation, payment recovery and legal reimbursement.
These are three different legal questions.
9. Customer Liability and Negligence
PSD2 Article 74 governs the payer's liability for unauthorised payment transactions.
Under the general framework, the payer may bear limited losses arising from certain unauthorised transactions involving lost, stolen or misappropriated payment instruments, subject to the statutory conditions and exceptions.
The customer may face broader liability where the customer acted fraudulently or intentionally or with gross negligence failed to fulfil applicable payment-instrument security obligations.
The bank cannot automatically establish gross negligence simply because the customer disclosed information or approved a payment.
The relevant circumstances must be examined.
Important considerations include:
Whether the customer received security warnings.
Whether the bank's authentication process was compromised.
Whether the customer disclosed credentials.
Whether the customer acted under deception.
Whether the bank complied with applicable security requirements.
Whether the payment was genuinely authorised.
Whether the bank has satisfied its evidentiary obligations.
10. Evidence and Burden of Proof
PSD2 Article 72 establishes important evidentiary rules.
Where a customer denies having authorised a payment, the payment service provider must demonstrate that the payment transaction was authenticated, accurately recorded and entered in its accounts and was not affected by a technical breakdown or other deficiency.
The mere fact that the bank recorded the use of a payment instrument is not necessarily sufficient to prove that the payer authorised the transaction or acted fraudulently or with gross negligence.
Evidence may include:
Authentication logs.
IP addresses and device information.
Transaction timestamps.
Customer notifications.
Payment approval records.
Strong customer authentication records.
Verification of Payee results.
Fraud monitoring alerts.
Communications between the bank and customer.
Technical incident reports.
Courts must assess this evidence in accordance with the applicable legal standards.
11. Important Case Laws
The following cases provide important judicial principles concerning payment execution, authentication, liability and consumer protection. Not all concern instant SEPA transfers specifically; their relevance is based on the broader payment-services framework.
CASE 1: Tecnoservice Int. Srl v Poste Italiane SpA
Court: Court of Justice of the European Union.
Case: C-245/18.
Judgment: 11 April 2019.
Legal Principle:
The case concerned the execution of a payment order using an incorrect unique identifier and the allocation of responsibility under the EU payment-services framework.
The Court considered the significance of the unique identifier supplied by the payer and the payment service provider's obligations.
Relevance to Instant Payment Liability:
This judgment is important in disputes involving incorrect IBANs and mistaken instant payments.
It supports the principle that the payment service provider's responsibility must be assessed in accordance with the statutory rules governing unique identifiers.
A customer who supplies an incorrect identifier may not automatically obtain reimbursement from the sending bank.
However, statutory obligations concerning recovery and cooperation remain relevant.
CASE 2: DenizBank AG v Verein für Konsumenteninformation
Court: Court of Justice of the European Union.
Case: C-287/19.
Judgment: 11 November 2020.
Legal Principle:
The Court considered the application of payment-services rules to contactless payment instruments and the extent to which certain transactions could fall within exemptions from strong customer authentication requirements.
Relevance to Instant Payment Liability:
The decision demonstrates that authentication requirements must be examined in the context of the specific payment instrument and applicable statutory exemptions.
It is relevant when determining whether a payment service provider complied with its authentication obligations.
It also illustrates the importance of distinguishing between a payment instrument's technical operation and the legal question of customer consent.
CASE 3: DM and LR v?
A specific case citation should not be supplied without verification. It is preferable to rely on the identified CJEU authorities above rather than attribute an uncertain judgment to the instant-payment framework.
CASE 4: Banco Español de Crédito SA v Joaquín Calderón Camino
Court: Court of Justice of the European Union.
Case: C-618/10.
Judgment: 14 June 2012.
Legal Principle:
The Court examined consumer protection and unfair contractual terms in consumer credit agreements.
It held that national procedural rules must ensure effective protection against unfair contractual terms under EU consumer law.
Relevance to Instant Payment Liability:
The decision provides broader consumer-protection principles relevant to standard banking contracts.
A bank cannot rely on an unfair contractual clause to defeat mandatory consumer rights under applicable EU and Spanish legislation.
CASE 5: Aziz v Caixa d'Estalvis de Catalunya, Tarragona i Manresa (Catalunyacaixa)
Court: Court of Justice of the European Union.
Case: C-415/11.
Judgment: 14 March 2013.
Legal Principle:
The Court examined the protection of consumers against unfair contractual terms in mortgage arrangements.
It clarified the importance of effective judicial protection where contractual terms create a significant imbalance to the consumer's detriment.
Relevance to Instant Payment Liability:
Although this was not an instant payment dispute, the judgment is relevant to examining unfair standard banking clauses.
Contractual provisions cannot lawfully undermine mandatory statutory protections applicable to payment service users.
CASE 6: Zulfikarpašić v Gajer
Court: Court of Justice of the European Union.
Case: C-484/15.
Judgment: 9 March 2017.
Legal Principle:
The judgment concerned the interpretation of the EU framework governing cross-border enforcement and the meaning of a court or tribunal in the relevant legal context.
Relevance:
It is not a direct instant-payment liability decision and should not be treated as establishing a bank reimbursement rule.
Its relevance to this subject is limited to the wider EU framework of cross-border legal enforcement.
12. Spanish Banking Complaints and Dispute Resolution
Customers in Spain who experience instant payment losses may use several complaint mechanisms.
A. Internal Bank Complaint
The customer should first submit a formal complaint to the bank's customer service or customer ombudsman, where applicable.
The complaint should include:
Transaction reference.
Date and time.
Amount transferred.
Beneficiary details.
Explanation of the disputed transaction.
Available fraud evidence.
Request for reimbursement or investigation.
B. Banco de España
If the dispute concerns banking conduct or compliance with applicable financial regulations, the customer may submit a complaint to the Banco de España after following the required prior complaint procedure.
The Banco de España's complaints service can assess issues within its competence.
However, its complaint reports are generally not equivalent to binding judicial judgments and do not themselves constitute an enforceable compensation award.
C. Judicial Proceedings
Where the dispute cannot be resolved through banking complaint procedures, the customer may consider civil proceedings.
Possible legal grounds include:
PSD2-based statutory rights.
Royal Decree-Law 19/2018.
Contractual liability under Article 1101 of the Spanish Civil Code.
Non-contractual liability under Article 1902.
Consumer protection legislation, where applicable.
D. Criminal Proceedings
Where a payment is obtained through fraud, identity theft, phishing or other criminal conduct, the victim may report the matter to the competent Spanish law enforcement authorities.
Criminal proceedings against the fraudster are separate from the customer's potential civil or payment-services claim against the bank.
13. Practical Example: Instant Payment Fraud in Spain
Assume that a customer maintains an account with a Spanish bank.
The customer receives an email that appears to come from a genuine supplier.
The email states that the supplier has changed its bank account details.
The customer initiates an instant payment of €25,000 to the new IBAN.
The money reaches a fraudulent account within seconds.
The genuine supplier later confirms that it never requested a change of bank details.
The customer immediately contacts the sending bank.
Legal Questions
Was the payment authorised?
Was the customer deceived into approving the transfer?
Did the bank provide the required Verification of Payee service?
Did the verification process identify a mismatch?
Did the customer receive and understand the relevant warning?
Did the sending bank comply with applicable fraud-prevention obligations?
Did the receiving bank comply with its AML obligations?
Can the funds be recovered?
Does the customer have a statutory reimbursement right?
Possible Legal Outcomes
Scenario A: Unauthorised payment
If the payment was executed without the customer's consent, the statutory reimbursement framework under PSD2 Articles 72–74 becomes relevant.
Scenario B: Authorised payment with a beneficiary mismatch
If the customer personally approved the payment despite a mismatch warning, the legal assessment must consider the applicable Verification of Payee rules and the circumstances of the customer's decision.
Scenario C: Bank failed to provide required verification
If the payment service provider failed to comply with its mandatory Verification of Payee obligations, the statutory consequences under the amended SEPA framework must be examined.
Scenario D: Receiving bank negligently operated a fraudulent account
If the receiving bank breached an applicable legal obligation and that breach caused compensable loss, potential regulatory or civil liability may arise.
The mere receipt of fraudulent funds does not automatically make the receiving bank liable.
14. Fraud Prevention and Regulatory Compliance Requirements
Financial institutions operating in Spain must establish appropriate systems to manage instant payment risks.
Important compliance measures include:
A. Strong Customer Authentication
Banks must apply strong customer authentication where required under PSD2 and the applicable regulatory technical standards.
B. Verification of Payee
Payment service providers must implement the applicable beneficiary verification requirements.
C. Transaction Monitoring
Banks should maintain risk-based monitoring systems capable of identifying suspicious payment patterns.
D. Anti-Money Laundering Controls
Law 10/2010 requires relevant institutions to implement customer due diligence and monitoring measures.
E. Sanctions Screening
Regulation (EU) 2024/886 introduces specific requirements concerning the verification of whether payment service users are subject to targeted financial restrictive measures.
F. Customer Notifications
Customers should receive appropriate transaction information and warnings in accordance with the applicable legal framework.
G. Incident Management
Banks should maintain procedures for reporting, investigating and resolving technical failures and fraud incidents.
15. Critical Legal Challenges in Instant Payment Liability Disputes
Several important challenges arise under the SEPA instant payment framework.
First, the distinction between authorised and unauthorised payments can be difficult where a customer is manipulated into approving a transfer.
Second, the speed of instant transfers creates practical problems for recovering funds.
Third, determining the liability of the sending bank and receiving bank requires a careful examination of their respective statutory obligations.
Fourth, Verification of Payee reduces certain risks but cannot eliminate all forms of fraud.
Fifth, banks must balance fraud prevention with payment speed and customer convenience.
Sixth, cross-border transactions may involve several financial institutions and different national procedural systems.
Seventh, the interpretation of gross negligence requires examination of the specific circumstances rather than automatic reliance on standard contractual language.
Finally, the development of instant payment fraud creates continuing challenges for supervisory authorities and consumer protection institutions.
16. Conclusion
Instant Payment Liability Disputes under the SEPA framework represent an important development in Spanish banking and financial law.
Regulation (EU) 2024/886 has strengthened the legal framework for instant euro credit transfers by introducing mandatory service requirements, Verification of Payee and specific fraud-prevention measures.
PSD2 and its Spanish implementation through Royal Decree-Law 19/2018 establish the central principles governing payment authorisation, authentication, reimbursement and liability for defective payment execution.
The sending bank may be responsible for unauthorised or incorrectly executed transactions where the statutory conditions are satisfied.
The receiving bank may also face regulatory or civil consequences where it breaches applicable legal obligations.
Customers are not automatically responsible for all losses simply because an instant payment was technically authenticated or approved.
Similarly, banks are not automatically liable for every fraudulent payment initiated by a customer.
The decisive legal considerations include authorisation, authentication, statutory compliance, causation, evidence and the applicable allocation of responsibility.
The overall objective of the SEPA framework is to ensure that instant payments remain fast, secure, transparent and legally accountable while maintaining effective protection for consumers and businesses.
17. Important Legislation and Judicial Authorities
European Union Legislation
Regulation (EU) No. 260/2012 – SEPA Regulation.
Regulation (EU) 2024/886 – Instant Payments Regulation.
Directive (EU) 2015/2366 – Payment Services Directive 2.
Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) 2018/389 – Regulatory Technical Standards on Strong Customer Authentication and Common and Secure Communication.
Regulation (EU) 2021/1230 – Cross-Border Payments Regulation.
Regulation (EU) 2016/679 – General Data Protection Regulation, where personal data processing is involved.
Spanish Legislation
Real Decreto-ley 19/2018 – Spanish Payment Services Law.
Ley 10/2010 – Prevention of Money Laundering and Terrorist Financing.
Real Decreto Legislativo 1/2007 – General Consumer and User Protection Act.
Ley 7/1998 – General Contracting Conditions.
Spanish Civil Code, Articles 1101, 1104 and 1902.
Spanish Civil Procedure Act, Ley 1/2000.
Important Judicial Decisions
Tecnoservice Int. Srl v Poste Italiane SpA, C-245/18, 11 April 2019.
DenizBank AG v Verein für Konsumenteninformation, C-287/19, 11 November 2020.
Banco Español de Crédito SA v Joaquín Calderón Camino, C-618/10, 14 June 2012.
Aziz v Catalunyacaixa, C-415/11, 14 March 2013.
Legal qualification: The cited CJEU decisions provide principles relevant to payment execution, authentication and banking consumer protection. They should not be represented as direct judgments establishing liability specifically for instant SEPA transfers. The precise outcome of an instant-payment dispute must be determined under the applicable version of the SEPA Regulation, PSD2, Spanish implementing law and the facts of the transaction.

comments