Difference Between Guardianship and Custody
Guardianship vs. Custody
Though both guardianship and custody relate to the care and control of a child, they are legally distinct concepts with different implications, rights, and responsibilities.
1. Guardianship
Definition:
Guardianship is a legal relationship where a person (the guardian) is appointed by law or court to take care of a minor’s person and property until the child attains majority (18 years in India).
Scope:
The guardian has comprehensive control and responsibility over the child’s welfare, including:
Managing the child’s property and finances,
Making decisions related to education, health, and upbringing,
Protecting the child’s legal rights.
Legal Basis:
Guardianship is governed primarily by:
Guardian and Wards Act, 1890 (secular law applicable to all except Muslims),
Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act, 1956 (for Hindus),
Other personal laws as applicable.
Appointment:
Guardians may be:
Natural guardians (usually parents),
Appointed by the court,
Or by will or testament in some cases.
Duration:
Guardianship continues until the child reaches the age of majority (18 years).
2. Custody
Definition:
Custody refers to the actual physical possession and care of the child. It determines with whom the child will live after separation or divorce.
Scope:
Custody mainly involves:
The day-to-day care and supervision of the child,
Deciding where the child resides,
Providing for the child’s emotional and physical needs.
Legal Basis:
Custody is primarily governed by:
Section 25 of the Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act, 1956 (for Hindus),
Court orders under family law during divorce or separation proceedings.
Appointment:
Custody is usually decided by the court during matrimonial disputes or child welfare cases.
Duration:
Custody orders can be temporary or permanent, and they can change based on the child’s best interests.
Key Differences
| Aspect | Guardianship | Custody |
|---|---|---|
| Nature | Legal authority over person & property | Physical care and control of the child |
| Scope | Comprehensive: financial, legal, personal | Day-to-day care, residence, supervision |
| Governing Law | Guardian and Wards Act, Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act | Family law, divorce laws |
| Who holds it? | Natural guardian or court-appointed guardian | Usually one parent or person the court deems fit |
| Duration | Until child attains majority (18 years) | Can be temporary or permanent |
| Rights Included | Managing property, legal decisions, welfare | Right to have child live with custodian, day-to-day care |
| Court's primary concern | Welfare & protection of child’s property and future | Welfare & best interest regarding child's upbringing and living arrangement |
Relevant Case Laws
1. Githa Hariharan v. Reserve Bank of India, AIR 1999 SC 1149
The Supreme Court clarified that both parents are natural guardians of a Hindu minor and that guardianship extends beyond custody.
It was held that the mother is also a natural guardian, giving her equal rights over the child’s person and property.
2. Sujata vs. State of Haryana, AIR 2015 SC 2826
The Court emphasized that custody must be awarded keeping the child’s welfare and best interest as paramount.
Custody rights can be granted or withdrawn based on the child's well-being, irrespective of biological parentage.
3. Smt. Manju Devi v. State of Bihar, AIR 1989 SC 1690
The Supreme Court observed that guardianship includes custody, but custody alone does not confer guardianship rights.
Custody is about physical possession, guardianship involves broader rights and responsibilities.
4. Vishal Jeet v. Union of India, AIR 2010 SC 1011
The Court highlighted the difference between guardianship and custody in the context of the child's welfare and property management.
Summary Table
| Feature | Guardianship | Custody |
|---|---|---|
| Control over property | Yes | No |
| Control over person | Yes | Limited to daily care |
| Legal rights | Yes | Mostly physical possession |
| Parental authority | Yes | No |
| Governed by | Guardianship laws | Family and divorce laws |
| Duration | Until majority (18 years) | Can be temporary or permanent |
| Who can be appointed? | Parents or court-appointed guardian | Usually one parent or court-appointed custodian |
Conclusion
Guardianship is a broader, legal relationship involving both care and control of the minor's person and property until they reach majority.
Custody is limited to the care, supervision, and control of the child’s person and residence, usually decided in family law disputes.
Courts always prioritize the best interests and welfare of the child in both guardianship and custody matters.
RELATED Blog
0 comments