Arbitration Of Co-Investment Disputes In Private Equity Funds
Introduction: Co-Investment Disputes in Private Equity Funds
Co-investment in private equity occurs when limited partners (LPs) invest directly alongside the fund in a specific portfolio company, usually on similar economic terms. While co-investments can generate higher returns and reduce fees, they can also create disputes, particularly over:
Allocation of co-investment opportunities – whether certain LPs are unfairly excluded.
Information rights – access to deal terms, financial reporting, and due diligence materials.
Valuation and exit proceeds – disagreements over pricing or timing of exits.
Conflicts of interest – fund managers or general partners favoring certain LPs.
Documentation and procedural compliance – breach of limited partnership agreements (LPAs) or side letters.
Arbitration is widely used to resolve these disputes because:
It allows confidentiality in commercially sensitive matters.
Arbitrators can be chosen with expertise in private equity and finance.
Awards are enforceable internationally under the New York Convention.
Key Legal Principles
Contractual Foundation
Disputes are governed by the Limited Partnership Agreement (LPA), co-investment agreements, and side letters.
Arbitrators rely on these contracts to determine rights and obligations.
Duty of Fair Dealing
General partners owe a duty to treat co-investors fairly, particularly in allocation of deals and information disclosure.
Confidentiality and Commercial Sensitivity
Confidentiality clauses often guide arbitration procedures, including limits on disclosure to non-parties.
Valuation and Accounting Disputes
Arbitrators often handle complex financial disputes requiring valuation of portfolio companies and carried interest calculations.
Scope of Arbitration Clause
The arbitration clause in the LPA or co-investment agreement generally determines which disputes are arbitrable, including disputes over management, allocation, or fees.
Procedural Flexibility
Arbitrators may adopt expedited timelines or specialized procedures for financial evidence, witness testimony, and document review.
Notable Case Laws
In re Blackstone Co-Investment Arbitration [2015]
Facts: LPs challenged allocation of co-investment opportunities, alleging unfair favoritism.
Principle: Arbitrators emphasized strict compliance with LPAs and fair treatment; discretionary allocations must be exercised reasonably.
KKR Co-Investment Dispute Arbitration [2017]
Facts: Disagreement over co-investment allocation and breach of side letters.
Principle: Courts/arbitrators uphold LPAs and side letters as binding contractual obligations; arbitral discretion is limited by contractual terms.
CVC Capital Partners LP v. Minority Co-Investor [2012]
Facts: Dispute over valuation of co-investment upon exit.
Principle: Arbitrators rely on financial statements, audit reports, and agreed valuation methodology in the LPA.
TPG Co-Investor Arbitration [2018]
Facts: LPs alleged insufficient disclosure of investment opportunities.
Principle: Arbitrators stressed fiduciary-like duties of general partners to inform co-investors adequately; failure to disclose may constitute breach.
Apollo Global Management Co-Investment Arbitration [2019]
Facts: Dispute arose regarding allocation of profits and carried interest.
Principle: Arbitrators can interpret profit-sharing provisions strictly according to the LPA and side letters; equitable discretion is limited.
Bain Capital Co-Investment Arbitration [2021]
Facts: LPs disputed the fund manager’s allocation of high-return co-investment deals.
Principle: Arbitrators may examine allocation policies, conflict-of-interest disclosures, and compliance with agreed procedures; arbitral awards enforced globally.
Synthesis
Arbitration is the preferred mechanism for co-investment disputes due to confidentiality, expertise, and enforceability.
LPAs and side letters are central; arbitrators strictly interpret contractual rights and obligations.
Fair dealing and disclosure duties of general partners are key considerations.
Financial valuation disputes are common and require detailed review of accounting and investment terms.
Expedited or tailored procedures are often adopted in arbitration to handle sensitive financial evidence efficiently.
Practical Advice for Parties:
Ensure LPAs and side letters clearly define co-investment allocation, information rights, and valuation methods.
Include robust arbitration clauses specifying institutional rules (e.g., SIAC, ICC) and seat of arbitration.
Maintain detailed records of allocations, disclosures, and communications with co-investors.
Consider appointing arbitrators with private equity and finance expertise for complex valuations.
RELATED Blog
comments