Natural Guardian under Hindu Law
Natural Guardian Under Hindu Law
1. Meaning of Natural Guardian
A Natural Guardian is a person who is entitled by Hindu law to take care of the person and property of a minor.
The concept is based on personal law and customs, not necessarily statutory law, but it is codified and recognized under the Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act, 1956.
The natural guardian is presumed to act in the best interests and welfare of the minor.
2. Who is a Natural Guardian?
Under Section 6 of the Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act, 1956, the following are natural guardians of a Hindu minor:
For a male minor:
The father is the natural guardian of the person and property of a minor boy.
For a female minor:
The father is the natural guardian of the person of a minor girl, and her mother is the natural guardian of her property.
After the father’s death:
The mother becomes the natural guardian of both the person and property of the minor.
Other natural guardians:
If no guardian is appointed or available from parents, other relatives like the appointed guardian or the court-appointed guardian may take over.
3. Rights and Duties of Natural Guardian
The natural guardian has the right to custody, education, maintenance, and management of the minor’s property.
Must act in the best interest of the minor.
Cannot transfer or alienate the minor’s property without proper authority.
Acts as a fiduciary, and mismanagement or exploitation can be challenged in courts.
4. Legal Position
Natural guardianship is recognized both by personal law and statute.
The Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act, 1956 clarifies and regulates natural guardianship but does not override customary practices.
The natural guardian has priority over other guardians appointed by will or the court.
5. Important Case Laws
a) Harbans Singh v. Kartar Singh, AIR 1967 SC 1683
The Supreme Court held that the father is the natural guardian of a Hindu minor son, and the mother becomes guardian only after the father's death.
The father’s authority as natural guardian extends to managing the property and person of the minor.
b) Kamalabai v. Sadashivrao, AIR 1958 SC 131
The Court ruled that the natural guardian has a fiduciary duty and must act for the benefit and welfare of the minor.
Natural guardian’s acts can be questioned if not in the minor’s interest.
c) Mahesh Bhat v. Kamal Bhat, AIR 1973 SC 1432
Held that the natural guardian’s authority is subject to supervision by courts, especially regarding property transactions.
d) Vidyadharan v. Jagadeesh, AIR 1995 SC 2727
Reinforced that the mother becomes the natural guardian after the death of the father.
Custody and guardianship are subject to welfare of the minor.
6. Difference Between Natural Guardian and Testamentary Guardian
| Aspect | Natural Guardian | Testamentary Guardian |
|---|---|---|
| Basis | By operation of Hindu law & statute | Appointed by the will of the father or mother |
| Appointment | Automatic at birth or upon father’s death | Appointed specifically through will |
| Authority | Manages minor’s person and property | Manages minor’s person and property after appointment |
| Termination | Ends when minor attains majority or death | Ends when minor attains majority or death or as per will |
7. Summary
| Aspect | Details |
|---|---|
| Who is Natural Guardian? | Father (person and property of boy, person of girl), Mother (property of girl, both after father's death) |
| Duties | Care, custody, education, and management of property |
| Authority | Subject to court supervision for property matters |
| Legal Backing | Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act, 1956 |
| Key Case Laws | Harbans Singh v. Kartar Singh, Kamalabai v. Sadashivrao |
Conclusion
The Natural Guardian under Hindu law is primarily the father, and after his death, the mother. This role carries significant responsibilities towards the welfare and property of the minor, but it is not absolute — courts can intervene if the guardian misuses power. The legal framework seeks to balance the guardian’s authority with the protection of the minor’s interests.
RELATED Blog
0 comments