Music Licensing Fees under Entertainment Law
I. Introduction to Music Licensing in Entertainment Law
Music licensing is a fundamental component of entertainment law, dealing with the legal rights and permissions granted for the use of music in various contexts such as film, television, advertisements, video games, public performances, and online platforms.
When music is used in any commercial or public context, the rights holder (usually the composer, lyricist, or music publisher) is entitled to compensation through licensing fees. These fees are a form of royalty for the use of intellectual property (IP) protected by copyright.
II. Types of Music Rights Involved
There are two primary copyrights in music:
Musical Composition
Covers the melody and lyrics.
Typically owned by the songwriter or music publisher.
Sound Recording (Master Rights)
Covers the actual recorded performance.
Usually owned by the record label or performing artist.
To legally use a song, a user often needs to license both rights.
III. Types of Music Licenses and Related Fees
Synchronization License (Sync License)
Purpose: To use music in audiovisual works (films, TV, commercials, YouTube videos).
Holder: Granted by the music publisher.
Fee Structure: Often negotiated as a flat fee depending on:
Popularity of the song
Duration of use
Type of production (indie film vs. commercial ad)
Territory and duration
Master Use License
Purpose: To use the original recorded version of a song.
Holder: Granted by the record label.
Fee Structure: Similar to sync licenses; may require high fees for popular recordings.
Performance License
Purpose: To play music in public venues, on radio, or online.
Holder: Managed by Performance Rights Organizations (PROs) such as ASCAP, BMI, or SESAC.
Fee Structure:
Blanket licenses for broadcasters or venues
Calculated based on size of the venue, frequency of music use, and audience size
Mechanical License
Purpose: For reproducing and distributing copyrighted songs (e.g., CD, streaming).
Fee Structure: Statutory rate per copy or stream (usually a fixed fee per unit)
IV. Determining Music Licensing Fees
Licensing fees vary greatly, and are influenced by:
Nature and scope of the use (e.g., global ad campaign vs. local documentary)
Duration and prominence of the music in the content
Budget and scale of the production
Negotiation power of the parties
Popularity or historical value of the song
V. Case Law Related to Music Licensing Fees
🧑⚖️ Case 1: Bridgeport Music, Inc. v. Dimension Films (2005)
Issue: Unauthorized sampling of a two-second guitar riff from a Funkadelic song in a rap track.
Decision: The 6th Circuit Court held that any unauthorized use of a sound recording, no matter how small, is actionable infringement.
Impact on Licensing Fees:
Reinforced the necessity of licensing even minor samples.
Pushed up licensing fees and increased caution in music clearance for films and media.
🧑⚖️ Case 2: ABKCO Music, Inc. v. Stellar Records, Inc. (2000)
Issue: Unauthorized duplication and sale of songs without obtaining mechanical licenses.
Decision: The court found infringement and awarded statutory damages.
Impact on Licensing:
Emphasized the importance of mechanical licenses and the financial consequences of not paying required fees.
🧑⚖️ Case 3: Warner/Chappell Music v. Fullscreen, Inc. (2015)
Issue: Fullscreen used unlicensed music in YouTube videos uploaded by content creators.
Outcome: Settlement, with Fullscreen agreeing to pay licensing fees.
Impact: Highlighted the responsibility of platforms and aggregators to manage music licenses.
VI. Common Disputes in Music Licensing Fee Cases
Failure to Obtain Proper Licenses
Leads to copyright infringement lawsuits.
Underpayment or Misreporting
Licensees may be audited if they underpay royalties.
Unauthorized Use in Derivative Works
Any use beyond the scope of the license is actionable.
VII. Conclusion
In entertainment law, music licensing fees play a critical role in protecting the rights of creators and ensuring fair compensation for the use of their work. Whether for a film, commercial, or digital content, failure to properly license music can result in legal liability, reputational damage, and financial penalties.
Understanding the types of licenses, their associated fees, and the legal precedents ensures that entertainment professionals navigate the legal landscape of music use responsibly and lawfully.
RELATED Blog
0 comments