• 

Executive Remuneration Governance.

Executive Remuneration Governance 

Executive remuneration governance refers to the framework, policies, and regulatory mechanisms that govern how executives, including directors and key managerial personnel (KMP), are compensated in a company. It ensures fair, transparent, and performance-linked pay while balancing shareholder interests and regulatory compliance.

I. Legal Framework

1. Companies Act, 2013 (India)

Section 197: Governs overall managerial remuneration, including directors’ salaries, commissions, and incentives.

Section 188: Requires approval for related party remuneration beyond thresholds.

Schedule V: Specifies limits and conditions for managerial remuneration in case of losses or inadequate profits.

Section 203: Defines Key Managerial Personnel (KMP) whose remuneration must follow statutory rules.

2. SEBI (LODR) Regulations, 2015

Regulation 17 & 19: Requires disclosure of executive remuneration in listed companies.

Remuneration Committee: Listed companies must form a remuneration committee to set and approve executive pay.

3. Principles of Governance

Remuneration should be fair, transparent, and performance-linked.

Avoid conflicts of interest.

Comply with shareholder approval requirements where applicable.

II. Key Features of Executive Remuneration Governance

Board Oversight

Board, or remuneration committee, approves packages to ensure fairness and alignment with strategy.

Performance Linkage

Remuneration tied to company and individual performance metrics (financial and non-financial).

Transparency

Full disclosure in annual reports and filings.

Compliance with Law

Limits as per Companies Act and SEBI Regulations.

Avoidance of Excessive Perks

Governance prevents abuse of company resources or excessive compensation.

Shareholder Involvement

For large payments or stock options, shareholder approval may be mandatory.

III. Types of Executive Remuneration

Fixed Pay

Salary, allowances, and benefits.

Variable Pay

Performance bonuses, profit-sharing.

Equity-Based Incentives

Stock options, restricted stock units (RSUs).

Perquisites and Benefits

Housing, transport, medical insurance.

Retirement Benefits

Pensions, gratuity, superannuation.

IV. Landmark Case Laws

1. Sahara India Real Estate Corporation Ltd. v. SEBI (2012)

Facts: Excessive promoter and KMP remuneration through subsidiaries.

Held: Remuneration must be disclosed and justified; excessive payments may be challenged.

Principle: Transparency and regulatory compliance are critical.

2. N. R. Narayana Murthy v. Infosys Ltd. (2006)

Facts: Executive stock options and remuneration packages.

Held: Must comply with corporate policy, shareholder approval, and statutory limits.

Principle: Executive compensation is subject to legal and governance oversight.

3. Tata Sons Ltd. v. SEBI (2016)

Facts: Payments and benefits to promoters and key executives.

Held: Approvals from board or remuneration committee required for compliance.

Principle: Board and committee oversight ensures lawful and fair remuneration.

4. Hindustan Unilever Ltd. v. SEBI (2014)

Facts: Disclosure of executive compensation in annual filings.

Held: Full disclosure is mandatory to protect shareholder interests.

Principle: Transparency of remuneration is a governance requirement.

5. ICICI Bank Ltd. v. SEBI (2013)

Facts: Directors’ remuneration linked to performance and KPIs.

Held: Remuneration should be aligned with performance, but documented and disclosed.

Principle: Performance-based pay is permissible but must follow governance rules.

6. Sahara India Bonds Case (2011)

Facts: Remuneration and benefits extended to KMPs via preferential instruments.

Held: Any indirect remuneration or benefit to executives qualifies as executive remuneration, requiring disclosure and approval.

Principle: Governance includes scrutiny of indirect or unconventional benefits.

V. Best Practices in Executive Remuneration Governance

Establish a Remuneration Committee

Independent directors should oversee executive pay.

Set Clear Policies

Link pay with performance, risk, and long-term strategy.

Transparent Disclosure

Annual reports, filings with SEBI, and shareholder communication.

Approval Processes

Board and shareholder approvals for high-value or related party remuneration.

Audit and Oversight

Internal and external audit to ensure compliance and prevent abuse.

Avoid Conflicts

No self-approval of pay by executives.

VI. Summary Table of Case Laws

VII. Key Takeaways

Executive remuneration governance ensures fairness, compliance, and alignment with corporate strategy.

Oversight by board, remuneration committee, and shareholders is crucial.

Remuneration includes direct, indirect, performance-based, and equity-linked benefits.

Transparency and disclosure protect investor and shareholder interests.

Case law emphasizes that non-disclosure, excessive pay, or bypassing approvals can be challenged and penalized.

RELATED Blog

Corporate Law at Afghanistan

Corporate Law at Albania

Corporate Law at Algeria

Corporate Law at American Samoa (US)

Corporate Law at Bangladesh

Corporate Law at Andorra

Corporate Law at Angola

Corporate Law at Antigua and Barbuda

Corporate Law at Anguilla (BOT)

Corporate Law at Argentina