Difference Between Private International Law and Public International Law
Difference Between Private International Law and Public International Law
1. Definition
Private International Law (Conflict of Laws)
Private International Law deals with conflicts of laws where a private legal dispute involves more than one country.
It answers questions like:
Which country's law applies to a contract between parties in different countries?
Which court has jurisdiction?
Will a foreign judgment be recognized and enforced?
It primarily regulates relationships between private individuals or entities across different jurisdictions.
Public International Law
Public International Law governs the rights and duties of states and international organizations in their relations with each other.
It covers rules about sovereignty, treaties, war, diplomacy, human rights, and global issues.
It regulates interactions between states or between states and international entities.
2. Scope and Subjects
| Aspect | Private International Law | Public International Law |
|---|---|---|
| Scope | Deals with private law issues involving foreign elements such as contracts, marriage, torts, succession. | Deals with public law issues such as treaties, war, diplomacy, sovereignty, and international organizations. |
| Subjects | Private individuals, companies, corporations, partnerships. | Sovereign states, international organizations (e.g., UN, WTO), sometimes individuals (in limited cases like human rights). |
3. Nature of Law
Private International Law
It is not a separate body of law but a set of rules within domestic law that helps resolve jurisdictional conflicts.
It includes choice of law rules (which law applies), jurisdiction rules (which court has authority), and recognition and enforcement of foreign judgments.
Public International Law
It is a body of rules and principles created by treaties, conventions, and customary international law.
These rules are binding on states and govern their conduct on the international stage.
4. Purpose and Function
| Aspect | Private International Law | Public International Law |
|---|---|---|
| Purpose | To resolve disputes involving private parties across different countries. | To regulate the conduct and relations between states and international bodies. |
| Function | Determines applicable law, jurisdiction, and enforcement of judgments in cross-border civil or commercial cases. | Deals with peace and security, human rights, environmental protection, treaties, and international cooperation. |
5. Examples of Issues Covered
| Private International Law Examples | Public International Law Examples |
|---|---|
| - International contracts: Which law applies? | - Treaty law and obligations |
| - Cross-border marriages and divorces: jurisdiction and recognition | - Law of the sea and territorial disputes |
| - Succession and inheritance involving multiple countries | - Diplomatic relations and immunities |
| - Enforcement of foreign judgments | - International humanitarian law and war crimes |
6. Legal Remedies and Enforcement
Private International Law
Remedies typically involve civil courts applying rules to decide jurisdiction, applicable law, and enforcement of foreign judgments.
Relies on bilateral or multilateral treaties like the Hague Conventions on Recognition and Enforcement of Judgments.
Public International Law
Remedies include diplomatic negotiations, sanctions, adjudication by international courts (e.g., International Court of Justice, International Criminal Court).
Enforcement depends on state consent and cooperation, often lacking compulsory enforcement mechanisms.
7. Sources of Law
| Private International Law | Public International Law |
|---|---|
| - National laws and statutes on conflict of laws. | - International treaties and conventions (e.g., UN Charter). |
| - Hague Conference on Private International Law conventions. | - Customary international law (general practices accepted as law). |
| - Judicial precedents and doctrine. | - General principles of law recognized by civilized nations. |
8. Summary Table
| Aspect | Private International Law | Public International Law |
|---|---|---|
| Definition | Rules to resolve private disputes involving foreign elements | Rules governing relations between states and organizations |
| Subjects | Individuals, companies | States, international organizations |
| Nature | Domestic laws applied internationally | International treaties and customary law |
| Purpose | Jurisdiction, choice of law, enforcement of judgments | Regulating sovereignty, treaties, war, diplomacy |
| Examples | Cross-border contracts, marriage, torts | Treaties, war laws, diplomatic immunity |
| Enforcement | Courts, treaties | International courts, diplomacy, sanctions |
9. Illustration
If a German company sues an American company over a contract dispute, private international law decides which country’s law applies and where the case can be tried.
If Germany and the USA have a dispute over territory or treaty obligations, public international law governs the resolution.
RELATED Blog
0 comments