"What is the relation between International Law and Municipal Law?
Relation Between International Law and Municipal Law
1. Basic Understanding
International law governs the relations between sovereign states and other international entities.
Municipal law (or domestic law) governs the internal affairs of a particular state.
The relationship between the two concerns how international legal norms are applied, recognized, and enforced within domestic legal systems.
2. Two Main Theories Explaining the Relation
A. Monistic Theory
International law and municipal law are part of a single, unified legal system.
International law automatically becomes part of the domestic law without needing specific incorporation.
Individuals can invoke international law directly before domestic courts.
In case of conflict, international law prevails over municipal law.
Common in civil law countries (e.g., Netherlands, France, Germany).
B. Dualistic Theory
International law and municipal law are two separate legal systems operating independently.
International law must be explicitly incorporated into municipal law through legislation to have domestic effect.
Until incorporation, international law has no direct effect within the state.
Common in common law countries (e.g., UK, Canada, Australia).
3. Practical Impact of the Relation
States are bound by international law in their international relations, but how this law affects individuals depends on domestic law.
Implementation of treaties and international obligations usually requires municipal legislation, especially in dualist systems.
Domestic courts may interpret laws in light of international law to ensure consistency.
Some international legal norms (like jus cogens norms, e.g., prohibition of genocide) may be regarded as universally binding, irrespective of municipal law.
4. Conflict Between International Law and Municipal Law
If a conflict arises:
Monist view: International law prevails.
Dualist view: Municipal law may prevail unless international law is incorporated.
Many countries adopt a balanced approach, giving priority to international law but respecting constitutional provisions.
5. Role of Constitutions
Some constitutions explicitly state the status of international law:
It may be automatically part of domestic law.
Or require legislative approval before becoming effective.
Sometimes international treaties may be superior or equal to domestic legislation.
6. Summary Table
| Aspect | Monistic Approach | Dualistic Approach |
|---|---|---|
| Relationship | Unified legal system | Separate legal systems |
| Incorporation of Int’l Law | Automatic | Requires legislative incorporation |
| Effect of Int’l Law | Directly enforceable in domestic courts | Not enforceable until incorporated |
| Conflict resolution | International law prevails | Municipal law may prevail unless incorporation |
| Examples | Netherlands, France | UK, Canada |
7. Conclusion
The relation between international law and municipal law determines how international obligations are applied domestically.
It affects the effectiveness of international law, individual rights, and state compliance.
Both approaches recognize the importance of state sovereignty but differ in the integration of international norms.
RELATED Blog
0 comments