Zombie Borrower Identification Gap
ZOMBIE BORROWER IDENTIFICATION GAP – DETAILED EXPLANATION WITH CASE LAWS
1. Introduction
The concept of a Zombie Borrower Identification Gap refers to weaknesses in the systems, procedures and regulatory controls used by financial institutions to identify borrowers who are financially distressed, persistently unable to service their debts, or economically non-viable but continue to receive credit, refinancing or loan extensions.
A zombie borrower is generally understood as an individual, business or other borrower that cannot sustainably meet its financial obligations from ordinary income or operating cash flows but continues to exist financially through repeated refinancing, loan restructuring, payment deferrals, capitalisation of interest or additional borrowing.
The expression is particularly associated with corporate borrowers that remain operational despite being unable to generate sufficient revenue to cover interest and principal payments. However, similar identification problems may also arise in household lending, mortgage finance, consumer credit and small-business lending.
A Zombie Borrower Identification Gap occurs when a lender fails to recognise the difference between:
A temporarily distressed but fundamentally viable borrower.
A borrower experiencing serious financial difficulty but capable of recovery through restructuring.
A borrower that is persistently insolvent or economically non-viable.
A borrower whose apparent repayment capacity depends on continuous refinancing or additional credit.
The gap becomes a regulatory and financial-stability concern when lenders classify distressed borrowers as performing, fail to recognise deteriorating credit quality, delay provisioning, or continue extending loans without a reasonable assessment of repayment capacity.
Zombie borrower identification is therefore closely connected with credit-risk management, prudential supervision, non-performing loan recognition, impairment accounting, responsible lending, restructuring practices and financial transparency.
2. Meaning and Characteristics of a Zombie Borrower
A zombie borrower is not necessarily a borrower that has formally entered insolvency proceedings or defaulted on every payment obligation.
Instead, the term generally describes a borrower whose financial condition is so weak that its continued ability to service debt depends on exceptional financial support.
In corporate lending, common characteristics include:
Persistent inability to generate sufficient operating cash flow.
Interest expenses exceeding sustainable operating earnings.
Repeated refinancing of existing liabilities.
Continuous dependence on additional borrowing.
Long-term accumulation of unpaid interest.
Repeated extensions of loan maturity.
Weak or declining profitability.
Inability to meet principal repayment obligations.
Dependence on creditor concessions or public support.
Lack of a credible business recovery plan.
In consumer lending, comparable warning signs may include persistent arrears, repeated refinancing, excessive debt-to-income ratios, dependence on new credit to repay existing credit and an inability to meet essential living expenses after debt servicing.
However, temporary financial difficulty alone does not automatically make a borrower a zombie borrower. A borrower may be temporarily distressed because of economic recession, seasonal business conditions, illness, unemployment or an unexpected market disruption.
The identification process must therefore distinguish temporary liquidity problems from structural financial non-viability.
3. Meaning of the Zombie Borrower Identification Gap
The identification gap arises when a financial institution's credit-risk systems fail to recognise the actual financial condition of a borrower.
A bank may continue classifying a borrower as performing even when the borrower is economically incapable of meeting its contractual obligations without repeated financial assistance.
This may occur because of:
Inadequate financial analysis.
Weak borrower-monitoring procedures.
Inaccurate credit-risk classifications.
Poor recognition of loan restructuring.
Incomplete information concerning related borrowers.
Excessive reliance on collateral valuations.
Inadequate cash-flow analysis.
Weak early-warning systems.
Conflicts of interest within lending departments.
Delayed recognition of credit impairment.
The gap is particularly serious when lenders deliberately or negligently postpone recognition of financial distress to avoid recording non-performing loans or increasing impairment provisions.
The resulting financial statements may present a misleading picture of the institution's asset quality and financial position.
4. Historical Development of Zombie Borrower Problems
4.1 Japan's Banking Crisis during the 1990s
The modern economic discussion of zombie lending is closely associated with Japan's financial crisis during the 1990s.
Following the collapse of asset-price bubbles, Japanese banks faced significant volumes of distressed corporate loans.
Some banks continued lending to financially weak companies rather than recognising losses and restructuring their balance sheets.
These companies became commonly known as zombie firms.
The continued financing of non-viable companies contributed to inefficient allocation of capital and weakened the ability of healthier businesses to expand.
Research by economist Ricardo Caballero, Takeo Hoshi and Anil Kashyap examined the role of zombie lending in Japan's economic stagnation.
Their research became influential in the development of the zombie-firm concept.
4.2 European Banking Crisis
The global financial crisis of 2008 and the subsequent European sovereign-debt crisis increased concerns about distressed borrowers and delayed recognition of non-performing loans.
Financial institutions in several European countries faced large volumes of impaired assets.
The continued refinancing of financially weak businesses created concerns about:
Hidden credit losses.
Delayed bank restructuring.
Weak capital allocation.
Inadequate provisioning.
Reduced lending to viable businesses.
Distorted competition.
European regulatory authorities consequently strengthened prudential supervision, loan classification, impairment recognition and non-performing loan management.
4.3 Development of the Problem in Spain
Spain experienced a particularly significant increase in distressed credit following the collapse of its property market.
The construction and real-estate sectors had received substantial bank financing before the financial crisis.
When property prices declined and demand weakened, numerous developers and construction companies experienced severe financial difficulties.
Some borrowers could not repay their loans from ordinary business income and depended on restructuring, refinancing or the disposal of property assets.
Spanish banks consequently faced substantial non-performing loan exposure, especially in real-estate-related lending.
The experience highlighted the importance of identifying financially non-viable borrowers at an early stage.
5. Zombie Borrower Identification in the Spanish Banking System
Spain's zombie borrower identification framework is influenced by national banking legislation, European prudential requirements, accounting standards and supervisory expectations.
The Banco de España plays an important role in the supervision and monitoring of credit institutions.
The European Central Bank also exercises direct supervisory responsibilities over significant Spanish credit institutions under the Single Supervisory Mechanism.
The regulatory framework requires banks to maintain appropriate systems for identifying, measuring, monitoring and controlling credit risk.
Although Spanish legislation does not establish a single universal statutory definition of a zombie borrower, the underlying identification problem is addressed through rules concerning:
Non-performing exposures.
Forbearance measures.
Credit-risk classification.
Impairment recognition.
Borrower creditworthiness.
Prudential capital requirements.
Internal governance.
Risk-management procedures.
Therefore, zombie borrower identification is generally addressed through several overlapping regulatory mechanisms rather than through a standalone legal category.
6. Identification of Financially Distressed Borrowers
A reliable identification framework requires lenders to assess the borrower's actual repayment capacity.
6.1 Cash-Flow Analysis
Cash-flow analysis is one of the most important tools for identifying zombie borrowers.
A business may report accounting profits while lacking sufficient cash to meet debt obligations.
Banks should examine:
Operating cash flow.
Interest expenses.
Principal repayment requirements.
Working-capital requirements.
Capital expenditure.
Tax liabilities.
Existing debt commitments.
Expected future cash flows.
A borrower that cannot generate sufficient sustainable cash flow to service debt may require enhanced monitoring.
6.2 Interest Coverage Ratio
The interest coverage ratio measures the ability of a borrower to pay interest from operating earnings.
A commonly used formula is:
Interest Coverage Ratio = Earnings Before Interest and Taxes / Interest Expense
A persistently low ratio may indicate that a business is unable to service its financial obligations through normal operations.
However, the ratio must be interpreted in the context of the borrower's industry, accounting practices and business cycle.
6.3 Debt-Service Coverage Ratio
The Debt-Service Coverage Ratio measures the ability of a borrower to meet principal and interest payments from available cash flow.
DSCR = Net Operating Income / Total Debt Service
A ratio below 1 generally indicates that available operating income is insufficient to cover scheduled debt service.
Persistent weakness in DSCR may be a warning sign of financial distress.
6.4 Repeated Refinancing
Repeated refinancing is another important warning indicator.
For example, a company may receive a new loan to repay an earlier loan without generating sufficient additional income or improving its underlying financial position.
Although refinancing can be legitimate and economically beneficial, repeated refinancing without a credible recovery plan may conceal structural insolvency.
6.5 Payment Arrears
Persistent arrears are important indicators of borrower distress.
Banks should monitor:
Missed principal payments.
Unpaid interest.
Repeated late payments.
Overdue fees.
Unauthorised overdrafts.
Repeated payment extensions.
However, payment arrears should not be treated as the only identification criterion because a borrower may be financially distressed before an actual payment default occurs.
7. Regulatory Framework under European Banking Law
7.1 Capital Requirements Regulation (CRR)
Regulation (EU) No 575/2013 establishes prudential requirements for credit institutions and investment firms.
It regulates capital adequacy, credit-risk exposure, risk-weighted assets and other prudential matters.
The regulation requires banks to maintain adequate capital against credit exposures.
The classification and measurement of credit risk are therefore important for determining the institution's prudential position.
The CRR has been substantially amended, including through Regulation (EU) 2024/1623, commonly known as CRR III.
Relevance to zombie borrower identification:
If a bank fails to identify distressed borrowers, it may underestimate the credit risk associated with its loan portfolio.
This can lead to inadequate capital allocation and an inaccurate assessment of the institution's financial resilience.
7.2 Capital Requirements Directive (CRD)
Directive 2013/36/EU establishes requirements concerning access to the activity of credit institutions, prudential supervision and governance.
It requires institutions to maintain sound internal governance arrangements and effective risk-management systems.
Banks must identify and manage risks that could threaten their financial stability.
Relevance:
Zombie borrower identification forms part of effective credit-risk management.
Weak borrower monitoring may indicate deficiencies in internal controls, risk governance and supervisory compliance.
7.3 EBA Guidelines on the Management of Non-Performing and Forborne Exposures
The European Banking Authority has issued guidelines concerning the management of non-performing and forborne exposures.
These guidelines address:
Identification of non-performing exposures.
Classification of forborne exposures.
Governance arrangements.
Portfolio monitoring.
Workout strategies.
Internal controls.
Management reporting.
Recovery and restructuring procedures.
They are particularly relevant because zombie borrowers may remain financially distressed despite receiving repeated concessions from lenders.
The guidelines encourage institutions to develop sustainable approaches to distressed credit rather than simply extending loans to postpone recognition of losses.
7.4 ECB Guidance on Non-Performing Loans
The European Central Bank has issued supervisory guidance concerning non-performing loans.
The guidance focuses on the identification, measurement, management and reduction of non-performing exposures.
It expects banks to develop appropriate governance structures and operational procedures for dealing with distressed borrowers.
The guidance is particularly important for significant institutions directly supervised by the ECB.
7.5 IFRS 9 – Expected Credit Losses
International Financial Reporting Standard 9 establishes the expected-credit-loss accounting framework.
It requires financial institutions to recognise expected credit losses using forward-looking information.
The framework generally distinguishes between:
Stage 1: Performing financial assets with recognition of 12-month expected credit losses.
Stage 2: Financial assets experiencing a significant increase in credit risk, requiring recognition of lifetime expected credit losses.
Stage 3: Credit-impaired financial assets, also requiring recognition of lifetime expected credit losses.
The identification of borrowers whose financial condition is deteriorating is essential for appropriate staging.
Relevance:
A zombie borrower may remain technically current on payments because of refinancing or temporary concessions, while its underlying credit risk has significantly increased.
Failure to identify this deterioration can result in delayed impairment recognition and misleading financial reporting.
8. Spanish Regulatory Framework
8.1 Law 10/2014
Law 10/2014 on the organisation, supervision and solvency of credit institutions is an important part of Spain's banking regulatory framework.
It establishes requirements concerning banking supervision, solvency and institutional governance.
It supports the obligation of Spanish credit institutions to maintain adequate internal control and risk-management systems.
Relevance:
A bank's failure to identify materially distressed borrowers may indicate weaknesses in credit-risk governance, internal control and supervisory compliance.
8.2 Royal Decree 84/2015
Royal Decree 84/2015 develops Law 10/2014.
It provides additional rules concerning the authorisation, operation and supervision of credit institutions.
Its governance and supervisory provisions are relevant to the systems used by banks to monitor credit exposures and manage risk.
8.3 Banco de España Circular 4/2017
Circular 4/2017 establishes accounting rules, public financial information and reserved financial statements applicable to credit institutions.
It is particularly important for the classification and accounting treatment of financial assets.
The circular supports the identification of credit-risk deterioration and the appropriate recognition of impairment.
Relevance:
If a bank incorrectly classifies a distressed exposure or fails to recognise impairment, it may produce inaccurate financial information and underestimate its credit risk.
8.4 Law 5/2019
Law 5/2019 regulates real estate credit agreements.
It establishes requirements concerning borrower creditworthiness assessment and responsible mortgage lending.
Lenders must assess whether borrowers can reasonably meet repayment obligations.
Relevance:
The law helps prevent the creation of unsustainable household debt and reduces the risk that borrowers will become financially distressed immediately after obtaining mortgage credit.
8.5 Spanish Insolvency Law
The consolidated text of the Spanish Insolvency Act, approved by Royal Legislative Decree 1/2020, regulates insolvency proceedings and restructuring mechanisms.
It includes provisions concerning insolvency, restructuring plans and the treatment of financially distressed debtors.
The framework is relevant to zombie borrower identification because lenders must distinguish between borrowers that can be restored to financial viability and those requiring formal insolvency or liquidation procedures.
9. Distinction Between Non-Performing Borrowers and Zombie Borrowers
The concepts of non-performing borrower and zombie borrower are related but not identical.
A non-performing exposure is classified according to applicable prudential and accounting criteria.
Under the European prudential framework, an exposure is generally treated as non-performing when it meets specified default or unlikeliness-to-pay criteria, including the relevant 90-days-past-due threshold where applicable.
A zombie borrower, by contrast, is an economic concept describing a borrower whose continued existence or repayment capacity depends on repeated financial support despite weak underlying viability.
A borrower may therefore be:
Performing but financially vulnerable.
Forborne but still performing.
Non-performing and economically viable after restructuring.
Non-performing and economically non-viable.
Technically current because of refinancing but structurally distressed.
The distinction is important because not every non-performing borrower is a zombie borrower, and not every zombie borrower will immediately satisfy the formal criteria for non-performing classification.
10. Forbearance and the Risk of Concealing Zombie Borrowers
Forbearance refers to concessions granted by a lender to a borrower experiencing or likely to experience financial difficulty.
Such concessions may include:
Extending loan maturity.
Reducing interest rates.
Deferring principal payments.
Granting payment holidays.
Waiving certain contractual obligations.
Rescheduling repayment obligations.
Capitalising unpaid interest.
Forbearance can be a legitimate recovery tool when the borrower has a realistic prospect of returning to financial health.
However, it may create a zombie borrower identification problem when lenders repeatedly restructure loans without assessing whether the borrower is economically viable.
A bank may use successive restructuring arrangements to delay recognition of default or impairment.
An effective regulatory system must therefore distinguish sustainable restructuring from repeated refinancing designed merely to postpone financial recognition.
11. Causes of the Zombie Borrower Identification Gap
11.1 Inadequate borrower information
Financial institutions may lack complete and updated information concerning borrowers' income, liabilities, assets and business operations.
Incomplete information can prevent accurate credit-risk assessment.
11.2 Weak financial analysis
Banks may rely excessively on historical financial statements without examining current cash flows, market conditions and future repayment capacity.
11.3 Overvaluation of collateral
A lender may continue financing a distressed borrower because the value of the collateral appears sufficient.
However, collateral value does not necessarily demonstrate that the borrower has a sustainable capacity to repay the loan.
11.4 Excessive refinancing
Repeated refinancing may conceal deterioration in the borrower's financial position.
11.5 Management incentives
Loan officers and senior management may have incentives to avoid recognising losses because doing so can negatively affect financial results, capital ratios or performance assessments.
11.6 Weak early-warning systems
Banks may fail to identify warning signs such as declining revenue, increasing leverage, repeated covenant breaches and deteriorating repayment behaviour.
11.7 Inadequate supervisory scrutiny
Insufficient regulatory scrutiny may allow financial institutions to maintain weak credit-classification practices.
11.8 Economic and political pressure
In certain circumstances, lenders may continue financing distressed companies because of concerns about employment, regional economic conditions or political pressure.
Although preserving employment and economic activity can be legitimate policy objectives, credit decisions should remain transparent and consistent with prudential requirements.
12. Consequences of the Zombie Borrower Identification Gap
12.1 Increase in non-performing loans
Failure to identify financially distressed borrowers may cause banks to accumulate loans that are unlikely to be repaid.
12.2 Inadequate impairment provisions
Delayed identification of credit deterioration may result in insufficient expected-credit-loss provisions.
12.3 Misleading financial statements
Incorrect classification of credit exposures may overstate asset quality and profitability.
12.4 Capital misallocation
Banks may continue directing financial resources towards non-viable companies instead of productive businesses.
12.5 Reduced lending to viable enterprises
Zombie lending can restrict the availability of credit for healthier businesses.
12.6 Reduced economic productivity
Financially weak businesses may continue occupying resources that could otherwise be used by more productive enterprises.
12.7 Financial instability
Large concentrations of hidden distressed loans may threaten the stability of individual banks and the wider financial system.
12.8 Consumer over-indebtedness
In household lending, repeated refinancing may increase the total debt burden and delay the borrower's ability to achieve financial recovery.
13. Important Case Laws and Judicial Authorities
There is no single leading Spanish judgment establishing a standalone legal definition of a zombie borrower. The concept is principally an economic and prudential risk-management concept.
The following decisions are relevant because they address financial distress, creditor conduct, bank supervision, restructuring, contractual fairness and the legal treatment of failing financial institutions.
13.1 Banco Español de Crédito SA v Joaquín Calderón Camino, Case C-618/10, CJEU, 14 June 2012
The Court of Justice of the European Union considered the application of Directive 93/13/EEC concerning unfair terms in consumer contracts.
The judgment addressed the powers of national courts when examining unfair contractual terms.
The Court held that national courts must be able to examine potentially unfair terms and that an unfair term must not be preserved by judicially modifying it in a manner inconsistent with the directive.
Relevance to zombie borrower identification:
The judgment is relevant to consumer lending because unfair contractual provisions may worsen borrowers' financial difficulties.
Transparent and fair lending conditions help prevent borrowers from becoming trapped in unsustainable debt arrangements.
However, the case does not directly establish a legal test for identifying zombie borrowers.
13.2 Aziz v Catalunyacaixa, Case C-415/11, CJEU, 14 March 2013
The dispute concerned Spanish mortgage enforcement and contractual terms relating to early maturity and default interest.
The Court held that national procedural rules must provide effective protection to consumers against unfair contractual terms.
Relevance:
The judgment demonstrates that lenders' enforcement rights must operate within a framework of consumer protection.
For zombie borrower identification, it is relevant to situations where repeated financial distress, mortgage enforcement and unfair contractual conditions may interact.
The decision is not a direct authority on zombie lending or corporate borrower viability.
13.3 Banco Primus SA v Jesús Gutiérrez García, Case C-421/14, CJEU, 26 January 2017
The Court examined the assessment of potentially unfair terms in Spanish mortgage-enforcement proceedings.
It clarified aspects of the judicial assessment of unfair contractual provisions and the importance of effective consumer protection.
Relevance:
The case illustrates that the legal consequences of borrower distress must be assessed through fair and effective procedures.
It is particularly relevant to distressed household borrowers whose financial position may deteriorate because of contractual terms.
13.4 Gutiérrez Naranjo and Others, Joined Cases C-154/15, C-307/15 and C-308/15, CJEU, 21 December 2016
The Court examined the retrospective effects of declaring minimum-interest clauses in Spanish mortgage agreements unfair.
It held that the limitation imposed by the Spanish Supreme Court on the financial consequences of such unfair clauses was incompatible with Directive 93/13/EEC.
Relevance:
The judgment demonstrates that unfair mortgage conditions can impose additional financial burdens on borrowers.
It supports the broader principle that financial institutions must use transparent and legally compliant lending practices.
It is not a direct precedent concerning corporate zombie borrowers.
13.5 Banco de Portugal v Banco Privado Português SA, Case C-73/11 P, CJEU, 12 July 2012
The litigation concerned state aid and financial support involving Banco Privado Português.
The Court addressed legal questions arising from the European Commission's state-aid framework.
Relevance:
The case is useful for understanding the legal environment in which financially distressed banks and financial-support measures operate.
It illustrates that public financial assistance and the treatment of distressed financial institutions are subject to European competition and state-aid rules.
It does not directly determine when a corporate borrower should be classified as a zombie borrower.
13.6 Banco de Portugal v Commission, Case T-505/13, General Court, 15 September 2016
The litigation concerned the legal treatment of financial assistance and state-aid measures in the context of a banking institution in difficulty.
Relevance:
The case illustrates the interaction between financial stability, public intervention and European state-aid controls.
It is relevant by analogy to the question of whether continued financial support is economically justified and legally permissible.
It should not be presented as a Spanish zombie-borrower case.
13.7 Banco Santander SA v J.A.C. and M.B.M., Case C-598/15, CJEU, 7 December 2017
The Court considered consumer-protection issues arising in the context of mortgage lending and the transfer of mortgage-credit rights.
Relevance:
The decision illustrates the importance of consumer protection when financial institutions transfer or manage distressed credit exposures.
It is relevant to the treatment of financially distressed household borrowers, although it does not establish a corporate zombie-borrower identification standard.
13.8 Abanca Corporación Bancaria SA and Bankia SA, Joined Cases C-70/17 and C-179/17, CJEU, 26 March 2019
The Court examined unfair early-maturity clauses in Spanish mortgage contracts.
It considered the circumstances in which an unfair contractual term could be replaced by a statutory provision and the implications for the continuation of mortgage agreements.
Relevance:
The judgment is important in understanding the treatment of distressed mortgage borrowers and the relationship between contractual enforcement and consumer protection.
It does not directly address the classification of borrowers as economically non-viable.
13.9 Banco de Portugal v Commission and Banco Privado Português, Case C-73/11 P, CJEU, 12 July 2012
This litigation is relevant to the wider European framework governing financial assistance, state intervention and the treatment of distressed financial institutions.
Relevance:
It helps illustrate that financial support decisions must comply with the applicable European legal framework.
The case should be distinguished from ordinary borrower-credit classification disputes.
14. Economic Research and the Zombie Borrower Concept
The economic foundations of the zombie borrower concept are particularly associated with research concerning Japan's banking crisis.
14.1 Caballero, Hoshi and Kashyap (2008)
Ricardo J. Caballero, Takeo Hoshi and Anil K. Kashyap published the influential study titled Zombie Lending and Depressed Restructuring in Japan.
The research examined how banks continued supporting financially weak companies after the collapse of Japan's asset-price bubble.
The authors argued that zombie lending reduced competition and weakened economic productivity.
Relevance to Spain:
The research provides a useful analytical framework for understanding the risks of continuing to finance non-viable businesses.
It helps explain why Spanish banks must distinguish between borrowers that are temporarily distressed and those whose financial problems are structural.
14.2 European Central Bank and European Banking Authority Research
European supervisory authorities have examined the consequences of non-performing loans, delayed loss recognition and inadequate restructuring.
Their work highlights the importance of:
Accurate credit-risk classification.
Early identification of financial deterioration.
Sustainable loan restructuring.
Appropriate impairment recognition.
Effective bank governance.
Timely resolution of non-performing exposures.
These principles are directly relevant to preventing zombie lending practices.
15. Difference Between Zombie Borrowers, Non-Performing Loans and Insolvent Borrowers
These concepts must be distinguished because they have different legal and economic meanings.
Zombie borrower: An economic description of a borrower that remains financially dependent on repeated support despite weak underlying viability.
Non-performing exposure: A regulatory or prudential classification determined by applicable default and unlikeliness-to-pay criteria.
Insolvent borrower: A debtor that satisfies the relevant legal criteria for insolvency under applicable national law.
Forborne exposure: A credit exposure for which the lender has granted concessions because the borrower is experiencing or likely to experience financial difficulty.
A borrower may fall within more than one category.
For example, a company may be classified as a forborne exposure and a non-performing exposure while also displaying the economic characteristics of a zombie borrower.
However, a zombie borrower is not automatically legally insolvent, and a non-performing loan is not automatically evidence of zombie lending.
16. Methods for Closing the Zombie Borrower Identification Gap
Financial institutions should develop comprehensive identification and monitoring procedures.
16.1 Enhanced credit-risk assessment
Banks should conduct detailed assessments of borrowers' financial positions, repayment capacity and future viability.
16.2 Early-warning indicators
Institutions should establish warning systems for:
Declining revenue.
Persistent negative operating cash flow.
Increasing debt levels.
Repeated covenant breaches.
Delayed repayments.
Frequent refinancing.
Deteriorating collateral values.
Significant changes in business operations.
16.3 Independent restructuring assessments
Restructuring decisions should be supported by independent financial analysis.
Banks should determine whether a borrower has a realistic recovery plan rather than repeatedly extending loans without economic justification.
16.4 Accurate impairment recognition
Institutions should apply IFRS 9 and relevant Spanish accounting requirements to identify credit deterioration and recognise expected credit losses.
16.5 Improved governance
Credit-risk decisions should be supported by appropriate internal controls, independent risk-management functions and board-level oversight.
16.6 Group exposure analysis
Banks should identify connected borrowers and assess total exposure to related companies and business groups.
This prevents the artificial presentation of separate entities as financially independent borrowers.
16.7 Supervisory reporting
Banks should maintain accurate records of non-performing and forborne exposures and provide appropriate information to supervisory authorities.
16.8 Distinguishing viable restructuring from repeated refinancing
Restructuring should be based on a credible assessment of the borrower's future financial position.
Repeated refinancing without an economically sustainable recovery plan should trigger enhanced scrutiny.
17. Regulatory and Institutional Challenges in Spain
17.1 Absence of a single legal definition
Spanish and European financial legislation does not establish one universal legal definition of a zombie borrower.
This creates challenges when comparing borrowers across institutions and industries.
17.2 Data limitations
Banks may not have access to complete information concerning borrowers' liabilities, related-party transactions and off-balance-sheet commitments.
17.3 Difficulties in determining economic viability
A business may temporarily experience weak profitability because of economic conditions but remain fundamentally viable.
Distinguishing temporary distress from structural non-viability requires careful financial analysis.
17.4 Valuation uncertainty
Collateral values may fluctuate substantially during economic downturns.
Reliance on outdated valuations can distort credit-risk assessments.
17.5 Regulatory consistency
Different institutions may apply different internal thresholds for identifying financially distressed borrowers.
Supervisory guidance and consistent classification practices are therefore important.
17.6 Balancing financial stability and economic recovery
Aggressive withdrawal of credit may force viable businesses into insolvency.
Conversely, excessive refinancing may preserve non-viable businesses and weaken financial stability.
The regulatory challenge is to encourage sustainable restructuring without facilitating indefinite zombie lending.
18. Practical Example of a Zombie Borrower Identification Failure
Assume that a Spanish bank provides a substantial loan to a manufacturing company.
The company initially generates sufficient operating income to meet its principal and interest payments.
Following a decline in market demand, its revenue falls significantly.
Its operating cash flow becomes insufficient to service its debt.
Instead of recognising the deterioration in credit quality, the bank repeatedly extends the loan maturity and provides additional financing.
The company uses the new funds primarily to pay interest on existing debt rather than investing in productive activities.
The bank continues classifying the exposure as performing without adequately examining the company's long-term repayment capacity.
This situation may create a zombie borrower identification gap.
The consequences may include:
Delayed recognition of credit deterioration.
Inadequate impairment provisions.
Overstatement of the bank's asset quality.
Continued allocation of credit to a non-viable enterprise.
Reduced availability of credit for financially healthy businesses.
Increased risk of future financial losses.
An effective system would require the bank to reassess the borrower's viability, examine its cash flows, evaluate restructuring alternatives and apply the correct accounting and prudential classifications.
19. Conclusion
The Zombie Borrower Identification Gap is an important issue in modern banking regulation because it concerns the ability of financial institutions to recognise borrowers whose apparent repayment capacity depends on repeated financial assistance rather than sustainable economic activity.
The concept developed prominently through research into Japan's banking crisis and became increasingly relevant following the global financial crisis of 2008 and the European sovereign-debt crisis.
In Spain, the problem is addressed through a combination of banking supervision, prudential requirements, accounting standards, non-performing exposure classification, creditworthiness assessment and insolvency legislation.
Law 10/2014, Royal Decree 84/2015, Banco de España Circular 4/2017, Law 5/2019, the Spanish Insolvency Act and applicable European banking legislation form important parts of the regulatory environment.
The EBA guidelines on non-performing and forborne exposures, ECB supervisory guidance and IFRS 9 also provide essential standards for identifying and managing financially distressed borrowers.
Judicial decisions such as Banco Español de Crédito, Aziz, Gutiérrez Naranjo and Banco Primus demonstrate the importance of fair lending practices, contractual transparency and effective consumer protection. However, these judgments should not be misrepresented as directly establishing a legal definition of zombie borrowers.
Ultimately, closing the zombie borrower identification gap requires accurate financial information, effective credit-risk monitoring, independent restructuring assessments, appropriate impairment recognition and strong supervisory oversight. The objective is not simply to identify borrowers experiencing financial difficulty, but to distinguish temporary distress from structural non-viability and ensure that financial resources are allocated responsibly.
20. Principal Legal Authorities and References
Spanish legislation
Spanish Civil Code of 1889.
Law 10/2014 on the organisation, supervision and solvency of credit institutions.
Royal Decree 84/2015 developing Law 10/2014.
Banco de España Circular 4/2017 on public and confidential financial reporting rules for credit institutions.
Law 5/2019 regulating real estate credit agreements.
Royal Legislative Decree 1/2020 approving the consolidated text of the Spanish Insolvency Act.
Royal Legislative Decree 1/2007, General Law for the Protection of Consumers and Users.
European Union legislation and supervisory framework
Regulation (EU) No 575/2013 on prudential requirements for credit institutions and investment firms, as amended.
Directive 2013/36/EU on access to the activity of credit institutions and prudential supervision.
Regulation (EU) No 1024/2013 establishing the Single Supervisory Mechanism.
Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) 2015/227 concerning non-performing exposures and forbearance disclosures.
EBA Guidelines on the Management of Non-Performing and Forborne Exposures, EBA/GL/2018/06.
Regulation (EU) 2024/1623 amending the Capital Requirements Regulation.
IFRS 9 – Financial Instruments, as adopted for application in the relevant EU financial-reporting framework.
Judicial authorities
Banco Español de Crédito SA v Joaquín Calderón Camino, Case C-618/10, CJEU, 14 June 2012.
Aziz v Catalunyacaixa, Case C-415/11, CJEU, 14 March 2013.
Banco Primus SA v Jesús Gutiérrez García, Case C-421/14, CJEU, 26 January 2017.
Gutiérrez Naranjo and Others, Joined Cases C-154/15, C-307/15 and C-308/15, CJEU, 21 December 2016.
Abanca Corporación Bancaria SA and Bankia SA, Joined Cases C-70/17 and C-179/17, CJEU, 26 March 2019.
Economic research
Caballero, R. J., Hoshi, T. and Kashyap, A. K. (2008), Zombie Lending and Depressed Restructuring in Japan, American Economic Review, Volume 98, Issue 5, pages 1943–1977.
Important legal qualification: The cases listed above primarily concern consumer-credit protection and mortgage lending rather than a standalone legal doctrine of zombie borrower identification. They are included for their relevance to lending practices, financial distress and creditor conduct. The economic concept of zombie borrowers must be distinguished from the formal legal and prudential classifications of non-performing exposures, forborne exposures and insolvency.

comments