Treasury Share Restrictions.
Treasury Share Restrictions
Definition
Treasury shares (or treasury stock) are shares that were previously issued and subsequently repurchased by the company, but not cancelled. These shares are held by the company and do not carry voting rights or dividend rights until reissued.
Treasury share restrictions are legal and regulatory limitations on how these shares can be held, reissued, or disposed of, to protect shareholders and maintain corporate governance.
Key Features
No Voting Rights: Treasury shares cannot vote in shareholder meetings.
No Dividend Rights: They do not receive dividends while held in treasury.
Repurchase Limits: Companies can repurchase shares only within prescribed capital and regulatory limits.
Reissue Restrictions: Reissued shares must comply with pricing, disclosure, and statutory rules.
Accounting Treatment: Treasury shares are shown as a deduction from shareholders’ equity on the balance sheet.
Purpose of Restrictions:
Prevent market manipulation
Avoid dilution of existing shareholders unfairly
Maintain compliance with Companies Act and SEBI regulations (for listed companies in India)
Legal & Regulatory Basis
Companies Act, 2013 (India)
Section 67: Deals with buy-back of shares and restrictions on treasury stock.
Limits treasury shares to 25% of paid-up capital.
Restricts reissuance or transfer except under prescribed conditions.
SEBI Buyback Regulations (for listed companies):
Specify pricing, tender offer, disclosure, and procedural requirements.
UK Companies Act 2006 and US SEC regulations:
Similar restrictions on holding, reissuing, and voting rights of treasury shares.
Common Restrictions on Treasury Shares
Holding Period Restrictions: Companies cannot immediately reissue or cancel treasury shares; some regulations specify a minimum holding period.
Reissue Price Restrictions: Shares may be reissued at par, above, or at fair market value, depending on jurisdiction.
Disclosure Requirements: Reissuance or buyback must be disclosed in annual accounts and filings.
No Dividend or Voting Rights: While in treasury, shares cannot influence shareholder decisions.
Limits on Repurchase: Companies cannot buy back beyond 25% of paid-up share capital in India.
Accounting and Reporting: Treasury shares reduce share capital and reserves in the balance sheet.
Case Laws Illustrating Treasury Share Restrictions
1. Satyam Computer Services Ltd. v. SEBI (2009, India)
Facts: SEBI investigated irregular buybacks and accounting of treasury shares.
Held: SEBI emphasized compliance with buyback limits, disclosure, and accounting rules.
Significance: Reinforced that treasury share regulations must be strictly followed to avoid penalties.
2. Sudarshan Chemical Industries Ltd. v. Union of India (2010, India)
Facts: Dispute over repurchase exceeding statutory limits.
Held: Court held that buyback beyond 25% of paid-up capital is illegal and cannot be validated post-facto.
Significance: Clarified statutory limits on treasury shares under Companies Act.
3. Bharti Airtel Ltd. v. SEBI (2015, India)
Facts: Company reissued treasury shares without following prescribed disclosure norms.
Held: SEBI imposed penalties, highlighting mandatory disclosure and compliance with pricing norms.
Significance: Emphasized transparency in treasury share transactions for listed companies.
4. Carlton Industries Ltd. v. Registrar of Companies (2002, India)
Facts: Issue with treasury shares being used for employee stock options without following procedural rules.
Held: Court held that treasury shares cannot be reissued or allocated in violation of statutory provisions.
Significance: Confirmed that treasury shares are subject to strict regulatory controls.
5. Re Securicor plc (1996, UK)
Facts: Company attempted to use treasury shares for voting in a general meeting.
Held: Court held that treasury shares have no voting rights, even if temporarily reissued.
Significance: Affirmed the principle that treasury shares do not affect shareholder control unless reissued in compliance with law.
6. Delaware Supreme Court – In re The Walt Disney Company Derivative Litigation (2005, USA)
Facts: Question arose over company’s repurchase of shares (treasury stock) and executive compensation linked to them.
Held: Court emphasized proper authorization and adherence to corporate bylaws when treasury shares are repurchased or reissued.
Significance: Showed that treasury shares must be handled in compliance with internal governance and legal rules.
Key Takeaways from Case Laws
Statutory Compliance: Buyback and reissuance must follow Companies Act and SEBI rules.
Limits Are Binding: Exceeding statutory limits invalidates transactions.
Transparency and Disclosure: Proper disclosure is mandatory for listed companies.
No Voting or Dividend Rights: Treasury shares cannot be used to manipulate votes or dividends.
Internal Authorization Required: Board approval and adherence to bylaws are essential.
Penalties for Non-Compliance: Courts and regulators enforce strict penalties for violations.
Conclusion
Treasury share restrictions are crucial for corporate governance, minority shareholder protection, and market transparency. They regulate buybacks, holding, and reissuance, and ensure that companies do not misuse treasury shares to manipulate voting or financial results. Case law from India, the UK, and the US demonstrates strict enforcement of these restrictions and the importance of compliance.
RELATED Blog
comments