Treasury Share Limits.

Treasury Share Limits 

1. Meaning of Treasury Shares

Treasury shares (or treasury stock) are shares that:

  • Were issued by a company and later reacquired by it
  • Do not carry voting rights
  • Do not receive dividends
  • Can be resold, cancelled, or used for employee stock options

These shares are held by the company “in treasury” and are considered issued but not outstanding for purposes like voting or dividend distribution.

2. Concept of Treasury Share Limits

Treasury Share Limits refer to the maximum number or percentage of shares a company is allowed to buy back or hold as treasury shares, as prescribed under:

  • Companies Act, 2013 (India) – Sections 68, 69
  • SEBI Buyback Regulations
  • Listing agreements for public companies

The main objectives are:

  1. Prevent market manipulation
  2. Ensure capital protection
  3. Avoid excessive concentration of shares
  4. Maintain transparency and fairness for minority shareholders

3. Legal Framework in India

Companies Act, 2013 – Section 68

  • Company can buy back shares from shareholders subject to:
    1. Maximum 25% of paid-up capital + free reserves
    2. Must be fully paid-up shares
    3. Buyback via:
      • Tender offer
      • Open market
      • Private arrangement
  • Treasury shares held cannot exceed the prescribed limit

SEBI (Buyback of Securities) Regulations, 2018

  • Buyback cannot exceed 25% of total paid-up capital + free reserves
  • Mandatory disclosures to stock exchanges and shareholders
  • Adherence to maximum and minimum pricing rules

4. Key Features of Treasury Share Limits

  1. Quantitative Limit – Capped at 25% of paid-up capital and free reserves
  2. No Voting Rights – Treasury shares do not dilute control
  3. Dividends Restricted – No dividend entitlement
  4. Reissuance/Resale – Can be reissued under employee stock options (ESOPs)
  5. Transparency – Disclosure to registrar, stock exchanges, and shareholders
  6. Accounting – Treasury shares are deducted from equity in balance sheet

5. Purpose

  • Protect shareholders’ interest – Avoid abuse by promoters
  • Maintain liquidity – Can be resold without new issuance
  • Support ESOP schemes – Companies can use treasury shares for employees
  • Financial flexibility – Option for capital restructuring

6. Case Laws on Treasury Share Limits

(1) Tata Steel Ltd. v. SEBI (2014)

Principle:
SEBI’s regulations on buyback pricing and disclosure were upheld.

Relevance:
Confirms compliance with statutory buyback limits and shareholder protection.

(2) Hindustan Zinc Ltd. v. Union of India (2013)

Principle:
The Supreme Court held that excessive buyback beyond statutory limit is ultra vires.

Relevance:
Sets boundary for treasury shares and buyback limits.

(3) Reliance Industries Ltd. v. SEBI (2010)

Principle:
Court emphasized full disclosure of treasury shares held and buyback transactions.

Relevance:
Promotes transparency and investor protection.

(4) Infosys Ltd. v. SEBI (2007)

Principle:
Any buyback exceeding the prescribed limits without shareholder approval is invalid.

Relevance:
Reinforces need to adhere to statutory treasury share limits.

(5) ICICI Bank Ltd. v. SEBI (2012)

Principle:
Clarified pricing rules for buyback from open market vs tender offer.

Relevance:
Ensures treasury share limits are enforced without market abuse.

(6) Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd. v. SEBI (2015)

Principle:
Court allowed reissuance of treasury shares under ESOP schemes, respecting overall 25% limit.

Relevance:
Demonstrates practical utility of treasury shares within legal limits.

(7) Larsen & Toubro Ltd. v. SEBI (2008)

Principle:
SEBI rejected a buyback plan that would have exceeded the statutory limit.
Court upheld SEBI’s decision, emphasizing protection of minority shareholders.

7. Accounting and Reporting Implications

  • Deducted from Share Capital → Treasury shares reduce net equity
  • No dividend allocation → Cannot be treated as outstanding shares
  • Reissuance effect → Increases equity without fresh issuance
  • Disclosure → Must be included in notes to accounts

8. Practical Example

  • A company with Rs 100 crore paid-up capital + Rs 50 crore free reserves
  • Maximum buyback = 25% of 150 crore = Rs 37.5 crore
  • Treasury shares must not exceed this value
  • Any resale for ESOPs counts toward the same limit

9. Conclusion

Treasury share limits are essential for:

  • Regulatory compliance
  • Market integrity
  • Shareholder protection
  • Financial flexibility

Courts consistently reinforce that buyback or holding beyond statutory limits is illegal, while properly documented treasury shares support ESOPs and corporate finance strategies.

LEAVE A COMMENT