Regional labour accords.
1. Introduction
Regional labour accords refer to formal or informal agreements, cooperative arrangements, memoranda of understanding (MoUs), administrative protocols and coordinated policies between two or more States or regional authorities for regulating employment relationships and protecting workers across geographical boundaries.
These arrangements are particularly important where workers are recruited in one State and employed in another, or where industries operate across multiple States.
Regional labour cooperation may address:
Inter-State migration and recruitment of workers.
Minimum wages and wage protection.
Occupational health and workplace safety.
Social security and provident fund portability.
Prevention of forced labour and exploitation.
Recognition of employment records and service benefits.
Labour inspection and enforcement cooperation.
Dispute resolution involving workers recruited in one State and employed in another.
Protection of contract and construction workers.
Coordination between regional labour departments.
Important legal distinction: India does not have one comprehensive national statute titled the Regional Labour Accords Act. Regional labour accords operate through constitutional federalism, statutory labour protections, inter-governmental arrangements and administrative cooperation. They cannot override applicable central or state legislation.
2. Constitutional Framework Governing Regional Labour Accords
The Constitution of India provides the foundation for inter-State labour cooperation.
A. Article 246 – Distribution of Legislative Powers
Article 246 distributes legislative powers between Parliament and State Legislatures.
Labour-related subjects appear in the Concurrent List, including:
Entry 22: Trade unions and industrial and labour disputes.
Entry 23: Social security, employment and unemployment.
Entry 24: Welfare of labour, working conditions, provident funds and employers' liability.
Both Parliament and State Legislatures may legislate on Concurrent List subjects, subject to constitutional limitations.
B. Article 254 – Repugnancy Between Central and State Laws
Article 254 addresses conflicts between central and state legislation concerning Concurrent List subjects.
A regional labour agreement cannot independently displace a valid parliamentary statute or resolve legislative inconsistency contrary to Article 254.
C. Article 258 – Delegation of Functions
Article 258 allows the Union Government, with the consent of a State Government, to entrust certain Union executive functions to that State.
This can facilitate administrative cooperation in labour enforcement.
D. Article 263 – Inter-State Coordination
Article 263 provides for the establishment of an Inter-State Council where coordination between States is necessary.
Although not exclusively a labour provision, it offers a constitutional mechanism for addressing inter-State labour policy issues.
E. Article 23 – Prohibition of Forced Labour
Article 23 prohibits trafficking in human beings, begar and other similar forms of forced labour.
Regional arrangements cannot legitimise exploitative recruitment practices or waive constitutional protections.
F. Article 39 and Article 43
These Directive Principles encourage:
Adequate livelihood.
Equal pay for equal work.
Protection against economic exploitation.
Just and humane conditions of work.
Living wages and decent working conditions.
They provide important policy guidance for regional labour arrangements.
3. Meaning and Scope of Regional Labour Accords
Regional labour accords can be understood through five principal categories.
3.1 Inter-State Migrant Labour Agreements
These arrangements coordinate recruitment, employment and welfare protection for workers moving between States.
For example:
Odisha workers recruited for construction projects in Gujarat.
Bihar workers employed in factories in Maharashtra.
Jharkhand workers recruited for mining operations in another State.
Uttar Pradesh workers employed in agricultural establishments in Punjab.
Such arrangements may establish recruitment verification, worker registration, wage monitoring and emergency assistance.
3.2 Regional Wage Coordination Agreements
These arrangements seek cooperation concerning wage protection and payment practices.
They may address:
Minimum-wage compliance.
Wage-payment delays.
Contractor deductions.
Wage records.
Equal remuneration.
Payment of overtime.
However, an MoU cannot substitute for the applicable statutory minimum wage.
3.3 Occupational Safety Cooperation
Regional labour authorities may coordinate inspections and safety standards in industries involving workers from multiple States.
Examples include:
Construction.
Mining.
Manufacturing.
Infrastructure development.
Transportation.
Chemical industries.
3.4 Social Security Coordination
Regional cooperation may facilitate the recognition and portability of employment-related entitlements, including:
Employees' Provident Fund.
Employees' State Insurance.
Gratuity.
Pension-related service records.
Construction-worker welfare benefits.
Such cooperation must operate within the relevant statutory schemes.
3.5 Labour Dispute Cooperation
Regional accords may establish administrative mechanisms for:
Sharing employment records.
Forwarding complaints.
Assisting workers who return to their home States.
Coordinating investigations.
Facilitating access to labour authorities.
Communicating court and tribunal orders.
An administrative arrangement cannot remove the statutory jurisdiction of a competent Labour Court or Tribunal.
4. Statutory Framework Governing Regional Labour Cooperation
A. Inter-State Migrant Workmen Act, 1979
The Inter-State Migrant Workmen (Regulation of Employment and Conditions of Service) Act, 1979 was specifically enacted to protect workers recruited in one State for employment in another.
Its important provisions included:
Section 4: Registration of certain establishments.
Section 6: Prohibition on employment of inter-State migrant workmen without required licensing.
Section 12: Duties of contractors.
Section 13: Wage-related protection.
Section 14: Displacement allowance.
Section 15: Journey allowance.
Section 16: Other facilities.
Section 20: Inspectors and enforcement.
The Act recognised that migrant workers required protection in both the originating State and the receiving State.
The Occupational Safety, Health and Working Conditions Code, 2020 subsequently provides the consolidated statutory framework for inter-State migrant workers, subject to its commencement and applicable transitional provisions.
B. Minimum Wages Act, 1948
Historically, this Act established minimum-wage protections for scheduled employments.
Regional labour agreements could facilitate wage enforcement, but could not authorise payment below the legally applicable minimum wage.
The relevant successor framework is the Code on Wages, 2019, subject to its commencement and applicable rules.
C. Contract Labour (Regulation and Abolition) Act, 1970
This legislation historically regulated contract labour and principal-employer and contractor responsibilities.
Regional arrangements may help coordinate contractor registration, licensing, inspections and worker welfare.
Its successor framework is contained in the Occupational Safety, Health and Working Conditions Code, 2020, subject to applicable commencement provisions.
D. Employees' Provident Funds and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952
The Act established a statutory framework for provident fund protection.
Regional labour cooperation may facilitate verification of employment records and continuity of social-security accounts when workers change States.
E. Employees' State Insurance Act, 1948
The ESI framework provides social insurance protection to covered employees.
Regional coordination is relevant when employees move between establishments or States, particularly for medical benefits, employment records and contribution verification.
F. Building and Other Construction Workers Act, 1996
This legislation historically provided for construction-worker welfare boards, registration and welfare benefits.
Regional coordination is particularly important because construction workers frequently move between project locations.
The relevant successor framework is the Occupational Safety, Health and Working Conditions Code, 2020, subject to applicable commencement and transition arrangements.
5. Principal Objectives of Regional Labour Accords
5.1 Protection against migrant-worker exploitation
One major objective is to prevent exploitation of workers recruited through intermediaries.
Regional cooperation should address:
False employment promises.
Illegal recruitment charges.
Wage withholding.
Passport or identity-document retention.
Unlawful deductions.
Forced employment.
Unsafe accommodation.
5.2 Harmonisation of labour standards
Different States may have different wage notifications, procedural requirements and administrative systems.
Regional arrangements can improve coordination without eliminating legitimate differences in state-specific legislation.
5.3 Prevention of double registration
Workers may encounter difficulties when their employment and welfare records are maintained in different States.
A coordinated registration and verification mechanism can reduce duplication and facilitate portability.
5.4 Effective labour inspection
Originating and receiving States may coordinate inspections to identify violations affecting migrant workers.
The arrangement may provide for:
Joint inspections where legally authorised.
Exchange of inspection reports.
Contractor verification.
Identification of unregistered workers.
Coordination of enforcement proceedings.
5.5 Access to justice
Migrant workers may face practical difficulties pursuing employment claims after returning to their home State.
Regional accords can facilitate complaint forwarding, documentation and communication between labour authorities.
They cannot, however, create or remove judicial jurisdiction contrary to legislation.
6. Important Legal Principles Governing Regional Labour Accords
| Legal principle | Explanation |
|---|---|
| Constitutional supremacy | No accord can override the Constitution |
| Statutory compliance | Applicable labour legislation remains binding |
| Equal protection | Migrant workers receive constitutional protection |
| Non-discrimination | Workers cannot be treated unlawfully differently because of their State of origin |
| Wage protection | Regional arrangements cannot authorise sub-minimum wages |
| Administrative cooperation | States can coordinate lawful enforcement activities |
| Portability | Benefits should be administered according to applicable statutory schemes |
| Access to justice | Workers retain statutory and constitutional remedies |
7. Important Case Laws: Regional Labour Accords and Inter-State Labour Cooperation
The following Supreme Court and High Court decisions establish important principles concerning inter-State migrant labour, federal coordination, labour welfare and enforcement.
Case 1. People's Union for Democratic Rights v. Union of India (1982) 3 SCC 235
Background:
The case concerned labourers employed in construction projects connected with the Asian Games in Delhi.
Investigations revealed violations of labour-welfare legislation, including minimum-wage and contract-labour protections.
Legal issue:
Whether constitutional authorities could be compelled to enforce labour legislation protecting vulnerable workers.
Supreme Court ruling:
The Supreme Court held that payment below the statutory minimum wage can amount to forced labour under Article 23 of the Constitution.
The Court emphasised that the State must ensure effective implementation of labour-protection legislation.
Relevance to regional labour accords:
Regional cooperation cannot permit payment below minimum wages.
Recruitment and employment arrangements must respect constitutional protections.
Labour authorities must investigate violations.
Contractors and principal employers cannot escape statutory responsibilities merely through contractual arrangements.
Legal principle: Labour welfare is a constitutional obligation, not merely an administrative policy.
Case 2. Labourers Working on Salal Hydro Project v. State of Jammu and Kashmir (1984) 3 SCC 538
Background:
The case concerned workers employed on the Salal Hydro Project in Jammu and Kashmir.
The Supreme Court examined violations of labour-protection legislation affecting migrant and construction workers.
Legal issue:
Whether labour laws protecting inter-State migrant workers could be ignored in large infrastructure projects.
Supreme Court ruling:
The Court directed the authorities to ensure effective implementation of labour legislation, including the Inter-State Migrant Workmen Act, 1979.
It rejected the argument that workers recruited from another State were outside the statutory framework merely because of the circumstances of their recruitment.
Relevance to regional labour accords:
Receiving States must ensure protection of migrant workers.
Project authorities must monitor contractor compliance.
Migrant-worker status must be determined according to statutory definitions.
Regional enforcement arrangements should facilitate inspections and welfare compliance.
Legal principle: Infrastructure development cannot justify the denial of statutory labour rights.
Case 3. Sanjit Roy v. State of Rajasthan (1983) 1 SCC 525
Background:
The dispute concerned payment of wages to workers employed in famine-relief activities in Rajasthan.
Legal issue:
Whether workers engaged in public relief work could be paid less than the statutory minimum wage.
Supreme Court ruling:
The Supreme Court held that payment below the minimum wage violates Article 23 and cannot be justified by the nature of relief employment.
Relevance to regional labour accords:
Regional employment schemes must comply with minimum-wage standards.
Public authorities cannot avoid wage obligations through special employment arrangements.
Government-funded projects must maintain statutory wage protection.
Legal principle: Minimum-wage protection applies even in exceptional employment circumstances.
Case 4. Bandhua Mukti Morcha v. Union of India (1984) 3 SCC 161
Background:
The case concerned bonded labourers working in stone quarries in Haryana.
The petition highlighted exploitation, poor working conditions and failures in labour-law enforcement.
Legal issue:
Whether the State had a constitutional obligation to identify, release and rehabilitate bonded labourers.
Supreme Court ruling:
The Supreme Court recognised the constitutional responsibility of the State to protect workers from bonded labour and exploitation.
It emphasised the importance of enforcement of labour-welfare legislation and rehabilitation measures.
Relevance to regional labour accords:
Regional cooperation should identify exploitative recruitment networks.
Workers moving between States must not be subjected to forced labour.
Labour authorities should coordinate rescue and rehabilitation.
Welfare mechanisms should extend beyond the immediate workplace.
Legal principle: Constitutional labour protection includes freedom from exploitation and meaningful rehabilitation.
Case 5. Dr. Damodar Panda v. State of Orissa (1990) 4 SCC 11
Background:
The Supreme Court examined enforcement difficulties under the Inter-State Migrant Workmen (Regulation of Employment and Conditions of Service) Act, 1979.
A significant issue concerned whether officers of the originating State could investigate migrant workers employed in the receiving State.
Legal issue:
Could the receiving State prevent officers of the originating State from conducting necessary inquiries?
Supreme Court ruling:
The Supreme Court held that officers of the originating State must be permitted to conduct appropriate inquiries in the receiving State for enforcement of the legislation.
It directed States and Union Territories not to obstruct such lawful inquiries.
Relevance to regional labour accords:
This is one of the most directly relevant judgments.
It supports:
Cooperation between originating and receiving States.
Cross-border labour inspection.
Information sharing.
Administrative coordination.
Effective enforcement of migrant-worker protections.
Legal principle: Inter-State administrative boundaries cannot be used to frustrate beneficial labour legislation.
Case 6. Bhatta Mazdoor Sangharsh Samiti v. Labour Commissioner (Rajasthan High Court, 2003)
Background:
The dispute concerned the protection of workers employed in brick-kiln establishments and enforcement of labour-welfare legislation.
Legal issue:
Whether labour authorities could avoid their enforcement responsibilities in circumstances involving vulnerable and migrant workers.
Ruling:
The Rajasthan High Court emphasised the responsibility of the State and concerned departments to enforce the applicable labour-protection legislation.
Relevance to regional labour accords:
Labour authorities must actively monitor vulnerable sectors.
Migrant and brick-kiln workers require effective statutory protection.
Administrative coordination is essential where recruitment and employment occur across State boundaries.
Legal principle: Labour-welfare legislation must be implemented effectively rather than treated as a formality.
Case 7. Bachpan Bachao Andolan v. Union of India (2011) 5 SCC 1
Background:
The case concerned the protection of children against exploitation and trafficking, including issues involving children employed in circumstances requiring inter-State enforcement.
Legal issue:
How should public authorities respond to exploitation and trafficking through effective enforcement and rehabilitation mechanisms?
Supreme Court ruling:
The Court addressed the need for effective institutional protection of children and enforcement of relevant legal safeguards.
Relevance to regional labour accords:
Regional cooperation is necessary to prevent trafficking.
Recruitment and movement across State boundaries require monitoring.
Rescue and rehabilitation mechanisms should be coordinated.
Labour protection must include safeguards against child exploitation.
Legal principle: Inter-State coordination is important in addressing exploitation that crosses administrative boundaries.
Case 8. In Re: Problems and Miseries of Migrant Labourers, Suo Motu Writ Petition (Civil) No. 6 of 2020, decided on 29 June 2021
Background:
The Supreme Court considered the difficulties faced by migrant workers during the COVID-19 pandemic.
The proceedings examined issues concerning employment, transportation, food security, registration and welfare protection.
Legal issue:
Whether governments had adequately coordinated their response to the difficulties of inter-State migrant workers.
Supreme Court ruling:
The Court issued directions concerning the identification and registration of migrant workers, food security and implementation of welfare measures.
It emphasised the need for coordinated governmental action to protect migrant workers.
Relevance to regional labour accords:
States must cooperate in identifying migrant workers.
Registration systems should facilitate access to welfare benefits.
Migrant workers require effective food and social-security protection.
Governmental coordination is essential during emergencies.
Workers should not lose welfare access merely because they move between States.
Legal principle: Migrant-worker welfare requires coordinated action by the Union and State Governments.
Case 9. Shashank S. Mangal v. Government of NCT of Delhi (Delhi High Court, 2020)
Background:
The petition sought effective implementation of the Inter-State Migrant Workmen Act, 1979 in Delhi.
Legal issue:
Whether government authorities were adequately implementing the statutory framework for migrant-worker protection.
Ruling and significance:
The Delhi High Court examined the implementation responsibilities of the Union Government and Delhi Government and sought information concerning enforcement of the legislation.
Relevance:
Regional labour authorities must maintain effective enforcement arrangements.
Migrant-worker registration must be addressed.
Government departments should coordinate their responsibilities.
Statutory protection must be translated into actual administrative action.
Legal principle: Governmental coordination is essential for effective implementation of migrant-worker legislation.
Case 10. Public Union for Civil Liberties v. State of Tamil Nadu (2013) 1 SCC 707
Background:
The proceedings concerned enforcement of labour and welfare protections, including the rights of vulnerable workers.
Legal significance:
The Supreme Court considered the responsibilities of public authorities in implementing labour-protection legislation.
Relevance to regional labour accords:
Labour inspections must be effective.
Vulnerable workers require access to statutory protections.
Government authorities must coordinate their enforcement activities.
Labour welfare cannot be defeated by administrative inaction.
8. Legal Validity and Enforceability of Regional Labour Accords
Not every regional labour arrangement has the same legal status.
| Type of arrangement | Legal effect |
|---|---|
| Inter-State MoU | Binding according to its terms and applicable law; cannot override statutes |
| Administrative protocol | Governs coordination within lawful executive powers |
| Joint inspection agreement | Facilitates lawful enforcement cooperation |
| Wage coordination arrangement | Cannot reduce statutory minimum wages |
| Social-security coordination | Must operate within statutory schemes |
| Recruitment agreement | Cannot authorise illegal recruitment or exploitation |
| Tripartite labour agreement | May create enforceable contractual or industrial obligations, depending on its nature and legal framework |
Important legal limitations
A regional labour accord cannot:
Override constitutional provisions.
Authorise payment below statutory minimum wages.
Eliminate the jurisdiction of Labour Courts.
Reduce statutory social-security entitlements.
Legalise forced labour or trafficking.
Exempt contractors from statutory liabilities.
Override mandatory central legislation.
Discriminate unlawfully against workers from another State.
9. Challenges in Implementing Regional Labour Accords
A. Different State labour policies
States may adopt different procedures for labour registration, inspections and welfare administration.
This can create confusion for employers and migrant workers.
B. Lack of information sharing
The originating State may not know the working conditions of its residents employed elsewhere.
The receiving State may also lack accurate information about recruitment agencies and contractors.
C. Contractor exploitation
Recruitment intermediaries may exploit differences in State enforcement systems to avoid legal responsibility.
D. Social-security portability
Workers may encounter difficulties accessing welfare schemes when changing States or returning to their home State.
E. Jurisdictional disputes
Disputes may arise concerning which State authority should investigate recruitment violations, wage claims or workplace accidents.
F. Weak inspection systems
A regional accord will have limited value if authorities lack adequate staff, records, funding and enforcement powers.
G. Language and documentation barriers
Workers may not understand employment contracts, wage records or statutory complaint procedures.
10. Essential Clauses in a Model Regional Labour Accord
A properly drafted regional labour accord should contain the following provisions:
| Clause | Subject matter |
|---|---|
| 1 | Purpose and objectives |
| 2 | Definitions of migrant and inter-State workers |
| 3 | Registration of workers and establishments |
| 4 | Recruitment agency verification |
| 5 | Minimum-wage compliance |
| 6 | Payment of wages and prevention of deductions |
| 7 | Occupational safety standards |
| 8 | Social-security portability |
| 9 | Joint inspection and enforcement |
| 10 | Information-sharing arrangements |
| 11 | Accident reporting and compensation assistance |
| 12 | Worker grievance mechanisms |
| 13 | Dispute resolution between participating States |
| 14 | Rehabilitation and emergency assistance |
| 15 | Monitoring and periodic review |
11. Practical Example: Odisha–Gujarat Regional Labour Accord
Consider a hypothetical agreement between Odisha and Gujarat concerning workers recruited in Odisha for construction employment in Gujarat.
Originating State
Odisha state map, administrative division of India. Vector illustration.
Odisha
Recruitment, worker registration, verification and pre-departure information.
Receiving State
Gujrat or Gujarat state map, India in blue color.
Gujarat
Workplace inspections, wage enforcement, accommodation and safety monitoring.
Joint responsibilities
Maintain migrant-worker records.
Exchange recruitment and contractor information.
Coordinate workplace inspections.
Facilitate wage complaints.
Assist workers injured at work.
Coordinate repatriation and rehabilitation.
Practical legal consequences
If a contractor recruits 200 workers from Odisha and employs them in Gujarat:
Applicable registration and licensing requirements must be fulfilled.
Workers must receive the legally prescribed wages.
Statutory displacement and journey allowances must be provided where applicable.
Appropriate accommodation and medical facilities must be ensured under the governing law.
Both States can cooperate in lawful enforcement.
Workers must have access to appropriate legal remedies.
The originating State cannot simply disclaim responsibility because the employment takes place elsewhere. Equally, the receiving State cannot refuse to enforce applicable labour protections because workers originated outside its territory.
12. Conclusion
Regional labour accords are important instruments for strengthening labour protection in a federal system such as India.
Their principal purpose is to ensure that workers do not lose statutory rights when they move from one State to another.
The decisions in People's Union for Democratic Rights, Labourers Working on Salal Hydro Project, Dr. Damodar Panda and In Re: Problems and Miseries of Migrant Labourers demonstrate the importance of constitutional protection, inter-State administrative cooperation and effective labour-law enforcement.
The following principles are particularly significant:
Inter-State cooperation cannot dilute constitutional labour protections.
Migrant workers remain protected by applicable labour legislation.
Originating and receiving States must cooperate in lawful enforcement.
Wage and social-security protections must be maintained.
Administrative agreements cannot override statutory obligations.
Labour authorities must ensure effective access to justice.
Regional agreements should provide practical mechanisms for inspections, registration and welfare administration.
Final legal principle: Regional labour accords should facilitate cooperation between States while preserving the supremacy of the Constitution and the statutory rights of workers. Their success depends not merely on signing agreements, but on effective implementation, monitoring and accountability.

comments